Canonical validity of an online exchange of marriage vows

Flax

New member
I have a question regarding the validity of a marriage under the 1983 Code of Canon Law.

Suppose a Catholic and a baptized non-Catholic mutually exchange marriage vows online. Neither a priest or deacon nor any witnesses are present. They simply express their consent to marry with a usual vow over the internet.

My understanding is that:
  • Canon 1108 §1 generally requires the presence of an authorized Church official and two witnesses for a valid marriage.
  • Canon 1116, which allows marriage before witnesses without a priest or deacon in certain circumstances, still requires two witnesses.
  • Canon 1117 determines when the canonical form is binding.
  • Canon 1127 §2 allows a dispensation from canonical form in certain circumstances, while still requiring a public form of celebration.
  • Canon 1688 provides for a documentary process in certain cases where the nullity of a marriage is clear from documents, including a defect of canonical form.

My questions are:
  1. Could such an exchange of vows ever constitute a valid marriage under canon law, assuming the Catholic party was bound by canonical form and no dispensation had been granted?
  2. If the marriage is invalid due to a defect of canonical form, is a formal declaration of nullity or any other canonical procedure required, or can the defect simply be acknowledged without initiating a case?
  3. Does the Code of Canon Law or any authoritative canonical commentary address marriage vows exchanged remotely via the internet?
I would appreciate answers based on the CIC and authoritative canonical sources, rather than merely general pastoral advice. Thank you!
 
These are excellent questions. I'll give it a shot.

Could such an exchange of vows ever constitute a valid marriage under canon law, assuming the Catholic party was bound by canonical form and no dispensation had been granted?

I do not believe so. Quite apart from it being over the Internet, there is no dispensation from canonical form, and there are no witnesses.

If the marriage is invalid due to a defect of canonical form, is a formal declaration of nullity or any other canonical procedure required, or can the defect simply be acknowledged without initiating a case?

The canonical procedure is required in the case of any putative marriage.

Does the Code of Canon Law or any authoritative canonical commentary address marriage vows exchanged remotely via the internet?

Not to my knowledge. The CIC was promulgated in 1983 when the Internet as we know it did not exist.

If anyone here has more or better information, I'll welcome it.
 
Suppose a Catholic and a baptized non-Catholic mutually exchange marriage vows online. Neither a priest or deacon nor any witnesses are present. They simply express their consent to marry with a usual vow over the internet.

My understanding here is that neither party is actually present for any type of exchange of vows.
So on top of there being no witnesses, and no Church official present for the exchange of vows, the wedding couple themselves also are not witness and are not present.

Correct?
 
My understanding here is that neither party is actually present for any type of exchange of vows.
So on top of there being no witnesses, and no Church official present for the exchange of vows, the wedding couple themselves also are not witness and are not present.

Correct?
Such an exchange of vows would not constitute a valid marriage under canon law, provided that the Catholic party was bound by canonical form and no dispensation had been granted. The requirements of canon 1108 §1 would not be fulfilled, since neither an authorized Church official nor the two required witnesses were present. Canon 1116 does not change this conclusion, as it still requires the presence of two witnesses, while canon 1127 §2 does not provide for a marriage celebrated entirely without the required public form.

Consequently, no formal declaration of nullity or other canonical procedure would ordinarily be necessary merely to establish that no valid marriage came into existence in these circumstances.

Separately, one should check the applicable civil law, since the legal recognition of a marriage conducted remotely depends on the jurisdiction concerned.
 
My understanding here is that neither party is actually present for any type of exchange of vows.
So on top of there being no witnesses, and no Church official present for the exchange of vows, the wedding couple themselves also are not witness and are not present.

Correct?

One would think so.

One thing that has somewhat vexed me in all of this, is the concept of marriage by proxy. Canon law does allow for it (Canon 1105), but I have had to wrinkle the brows at how a sacrament can be confected without the two spouses actually being physically present to one another, in that they are (someone correct me if I'm wrong) the "matter" of the sacrament. I'd welcome some education on the matter.
 
I have had to wrinkle the brows at how a sacrament can be confected without the two spouses actually being physically present to one another

At the very least, someone needs to sign the certificates.
Physical presence would seem to be a requirement.
 
Back
Top