Experience with Dr Popcak

  • Thread starter Thread starter DHW
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DHW

Guest
Does anyone have experience with Dr Popcaks telecounseling services? I am at the point where I think I’m finally ready to seek counseling for my very troubled marriage. My husband will not go to counseling but I think I need to to be able to figure out how to handle my situation. I am probably only a half step away from him leaving the marriage. I am looking for first hand experience with Popcak and his associates. I have read many of his books so I think he would be a good fit for me but I assume I would get one of his associates. Anyone have experience good or bad to share?
 
I’ve only heard him on his radio show and I care for him on the show. To me he seems to not listen to the complaint of the person and will just pick a tiny piece of the problem. He then gives very generic advise that doesn’t seem to attack the problem the person who called in.

To be completely fair I have no idea if that is how he runs his practice.
 
I have no experience/knowledge of Dr. Popcak but tons of experience on how to save a marriage.

Can you give some background? How did you come to marry him, how long married, kids, problems etc.?
 
Because of the nature of people, experts on radio call in shows have to be vague. Counseling is intensely personal and it takes time to really tackle issues. Also, people might sue for malpractice over very specific radio advice.

Dr Popcak comes across as a professional.
 
Haven’t used him myself, but I’d echo the thing about how real-life counselors aren’t able to professionally counsel a radio caller in the same way they’d counsel a real life patient/client. That kind of advice goes in the “for entertainment purposes only” category.
 
I come from an extremely dysfunctional family of origin and so did my ex. The dysfunction significantly spilled over into the marriage and really negatively impacted my well-being.

I had the opportunity to have counseling with Dr. Popcak. (He wasn’t “Dr.” yet back then.)
He has a solid understanding of Catholic Theology, and strives to live within the boundaries of it.

My marriage suffered infidelity and my then husband blatantly refused to acknowledge his role in his affair. There were other things in the marriage that my then husband blamed me for and I would constantly try harder to please him and make things right.

I was self-pay with Dr. Popcak, who offered to counsel my husband and I together for some sessions. Like your husband, my husband also refused any counseling. I did several sessions and eventually ran out of funds. I would have liked to continue. However, the work that Dr. Popcak did with me set me on a path to have better boundaries with my family and others.

Sadly, my husband continued on his unhealthy path and no matter what I did to improve, nothing in our relationship changed in my husband’s perspective of me. From his point of view, I was in the marriage, so therefore what he thought was my fault he blamed me for. (Even if someone else did or said something, if he thought I did, he considered it done by me, period.)

I learned from Dr. Greg that while I can change myself and make me a better person, I can’t change someone else. Dr. Greg had basically told me that what I was getting from my husband, I was going to get, because I was being minimized, blame-shifted and gas-lighted. Dr. Popcak was very concerned for me and expressed that concern. But he did recognize and respect that I was also on my own path and was going to do what I felt was best for me and my family (ie stay in the unhealthy marriage).

Nine years later, I had enough and separated and divorced. But I can say that without Dr. Popcak’s earlier wisdom, I wouldn’t have developed the healthier boundaries that I have today.
 
Thank you for sharing your experience. I’m sorry you went through all that.
 
I’m not quite ready to share details on the forum, I am looking for recommendations for professional help but Thank you.
 
That is your opinion. Having been a counselling for many years, I find him far more interested is hearing himself talk than actually helping people with their concerns.

I find him repetitive and unoriginal. Dr. Ray gives specific advise that isn’t the same for every caller.
 
I did several sessions and eventually ran out of funds.
OP, be warned; it’s not in a pay-to-play counselor’s best interest to quickly solve your marriage issues. Unfortunately, wasted time with them, or denial or other time killers many times ends in divorce.

Don’t think this can’t happen to you. If you’re serious about saving your marriage time is not on your side. Don’t be afraid to do anything and everything to save your marriage.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top