Lot's wife/Onan

  • Thread starter Thread starter monina
  • Start date Start date
Not open for further replies.


How are we as Christians to interpret Scripture regarding Lot’s wife being turned into a pillar of salt for looking back at Sodom and Gomorrah? Why was she given the ultimate punishment for this?

I ask this in light of a discussion in another forum regarding the sins of Onan, who was slain by God. This passage is given as justification for the sin of spilling one’s seed.

Why are we to interpret Onan’s deed as sinful, but not much is said regarding other Old Testament people killed for what seems to me to be minor infractions, such as looking back at a burning city?!

Thank you
Dear Monina,

To disobey God is not a minor thing. We see this in the disobedience of Adam and Eve. We are not God’s equal. When one considers all that Jesus suffered to atone for sin, it ought to give us pause. He is not only showing us something of the magnitude of infinite love, He is also showing us what an offense sin is against an infinitely good God.

Being killed by becoming a pillar of salt is not the ultimate punishment. Death comes to us all. The ultimate punishment is to choose ourselves over God for all eternity—which what hell is.

Onan disobeyed God in failing to put his duty to the family and nation before his own self-interest. The God-given Mosaic ‘levirate’ law required that the child which would have been conceived would have been considered the child of his dead brother and Onan chose to disobey it.

We live in a culture that disdains and trivializes the virtue of obedience. To obey lawful authority, of course, is to acknowledge and acquiesce to a right that is not ours. This can offend our pride and our desire for un-restrained dominance over our lives. But God does a much better job of being God than we ever could. To obey Him is to be fully ourselves.

There is no easy way to learn this. We all learn it the hard way. But learn it we must.

Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.
Not open for further replies.