A billion years with an evening?

  • Thread starter Thread starter strugglingalong
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No assumptions. Quasars are measured to be very distant. There are millions of astronomical objects with measured distances in excess of 10,000 light years, any one of which is enough to refure the contention of a universe that is 6,000 years old. For an example see SN 1987A whose structure allows us to use basic trigonometry to calculate it’s distance as 168,000 light years.

There are no assumptions, well established astronomical methods have been used to measure the distances to quasars.

rossum
SN_1987A’s distance can be estimated becasue the angular size of the expanding rings can be resolved. By definition, anything “very distant” is at cosmological distances, and can mainly have distance estimated through the assumption that redshift relates to velocity or expansion. Even relative brightness does not work since quasars do not fit, and since we do not know what a quasar is (outside the assumption framework). We do not have a model of what relative brightness of a quasar should be, because we do not have one at close enough distances to study. In fact quasars have been a real problem for the assumption of redshift.

So SN_1987A is a very bad example to compare to quasars, and SN_1987A is within the realm of what we have some handle on. Quasars are one of the counfounding issues in astronomy.
 
Our entire cosmology is built on fundamental, unprovable assumptions, including:
  1. The universe is isotropic and homogeneous: i.e., everywhere appears to the the center. Another option is the one place that we have been (here) and actually made observations (which appear to make us central) IS the center. Science chooses the ignore 50% of the possibilites in order to maintain there philosophical position (we are godless, here by accident, the product of nauralistic materialism).
  2. Redshift is expansion. This is an assumption.
Some fundamental things we do not understand:
  1. Gravity: science has definitively identified no mechanism for gravity
  2. Inertia: Science has only speculated on causes of inertia
We cannot even do engineering without these concepts. Yet we do, because we have an understanding of the effects of these parameters (as parameters in a model), but no fundamental understanding of the physical mechanism by which they arise and operate.

We need to be careful under this scenario about changing our interpretations of Scripture, especially if it goes against what the Church has previously taught. This threatens to be following the current fad, and being so enamoured in it that we reject God. “Put no false gods before me”.

There is no reason for a Catholic not to keep an open mind on this, even a Catholic who is a scientist. From the evidence we have, it is still quite possible that the earth sits mobile in the center of the universe. In fact if we do not ignore half the possibilies, it seems a likely possibility. Only the assumptions of the current naturalistic/materialistic scientific establishment keep this possibility from being considered. See www.geocentrism.com .
 
But we have already found hundreds of prehistoric human garbage dumps. So we have plenty of data as to what humans ate. And that data shows not a single instance of humans eating dinosaurs. How could dinosaurs be plentiful enough to be painted, but rare enough that they have not been found in a single one of these garbage dumps?
I don’t see the point of this ‘insistence’ for dino dinner evidence, Mikey. Survival dictates your food supply. That always, automatically, rules out the ability, in favour of capability!

You’re using a ‘now’ measuring stick to the ‘then’ environment!

If food supply is readily available, or easily obtained in other forms, without the risk of ‘sacrificing’ some loss to obtain it, why would you? Even now, you do not see it in the animal world. The rare exceptions are only brought on by need; starvation! But even there, the starving predator does not make a play for an impropability!

Hey, ‘hildegaard’

I didn’t know that site existed!

Thank you…

:cool:
 
I don’t see the point of this ‘insistence’ for dino dinner evidence, Mikey. Survival dictates your food supply. That always, automatically, rules out the ability, in favour of capability!

You’re using a ‘now’ measuring stick to the ‘then’ environment!

If food supply is readily available, or easily obtained in other forms, without the risk of ‘sacrificing’ some loss to obtain it, why would you? Even now, you do not see it in the animal world. The rare exceptions are only brought on by need; starvation! But even there, the starving predator does not make a play for an impropability!

:cool:
Arguments are usually made in this fashion - we do not see the evidence so therefore it cannot be. It is a bogus argument.

Perhaps it could be modified - we do not yet see the evidence so therefore we can draw no conclusion.
 
Perhaps. The other thing is, starvation or the necessity to hunt food successfully normally drives the starving animal AWAY from its danger areas! We find in nature, some animals roam into surroundings they don’t normally forage into.

I thought we were ‘animals!’

:cool:
 
I don’t see the point of this ‘insistence’ for dino dinner evidence, Mikey. Survival dictates your food supply. That always, automatically, rules out the ability, in favour of capability!
“Mikey”?

Anyway, my question is an obvious one, and reasonable people would agree. If dinosaurs roamed the earth with humans, then humans would have hunted some of them down and eaten them (or even eaten dead ones). But there’s not a shred of bone evidence to show that they actually did so. You can offer no defensible reason why humans would have eaten every other type of creature with bones, but always and everywhere avoided dinosaurs.
You’re using a ‘now’ measuring stick to the ‘then’ environment!
No I’m not. I’m using a ‘then’ measuring stick.
If food supply is readily available, or easily obtained in other forms, without the risk of ‘sacrificing’ some loss to obtain it, why would you? Even now, you do not see it in the animal world. The rare exceptions are only brought on by need; starvation! But even there, the starving predator does not make a play for an impropability!
Humans routinely killed and ate very large and dangerous mammals. So why wouldn’t they eat small and fairly harmless dinosaurs? By your own standards, they should have done so. But there’s no evidence.
 
Our entire cosmology is built on fundamental, unprovable assumptions, including:
  1. The universe is isotropic and homogeneous:
Not an assumption, all measurements so far have shown that the observable universe is indeed isotropic and relatively homogeneous. Homogeneity is not perfect because we have galaxies and stars rather than a uniform cloud of hydrogen.
  1. Redshift is expansion. This is an assumption.
No, redshift can have many causes: dust clouds, gravitation and expansion. The contribution of the different components has been measured and exists.
Some fundamental things we do not understand:
  1. Gravity: science has definitively identified no mechanism for gravity
  2. Inertia: Science has only speculated on causes of inertia
Gravity I agree with you. We can measure it and predict its effects but we are not yet sure what actually causes it. Inertia I do not have the background knowledge to comment. Just because we do not know some things does not mean that we do not know anything at all. We do not know the name of Cain’s wife; does that mean that we can know nothing from the Bible?
We need to be careful under this scenario about changing our interpretations of Scripture, especially if it goes against what the Church has previously taught. This threatens to be following the current fad, and being so enamoured in it that we reject God. “Put no false gods before me”.
Interpretations of scripture can be changed (remember Limbo?). The Church has not pronounced infallibly on this so Catholics are free to change interpretations as the science changes.
From the evidence we have, it is still quite possible that the earth sits mobile in the center of the universe.
Did you mean “mobile” or “immobile”? If the earth is at the centre of the universe then the moon is not. What experiment could we perform on the moon to show that the moon is not at the centre?

The crust of the earth is in motion, as at Thingvellir (Þingvellir) in Iceland. What experiment could we perform in Thingvellir to show that one side (at least) of the valley is in motion relative to the centre of the universe?

rossum
 
Not an assumption, all measurements so far have shown that the observable universe is indeed isotropic and relatively homogeneous. Homogeneity is not perfect because we have galaxies and stars rather than a uniform cloud of hydrogen.
All measurements up to now show that the universe is isotropic from our perspective. If we assume the universe is a 4-D toroid or some other non-obvious shape, then it is possible the entire universe is isotropic. 50:50 chance at this point. Why ignore 50% of the possibilities?

Stephen Hawking (A Brief History of Time):

"…all this evidence that the universe looks the same whichever direction we look in might seem to suggest there is something special about our place in the universe. In particular, it might seem that if we observe all other galaxies to be moving away from us, then we must be at the center of the universe.
…

There is, however, an alternate explanation: the universe might look the same in every direction as seen from any other galaxy, too. This, as we have seen, was Friedmann’s second assumption. We have no scientific evidence for, or against, this assumption. We believe it only on grounds of modesty: it would be most remarkable if the universe looked the same in every direction around us, but not around other points in the universe."

Yes, Dr. Hawking it would be remarkable, and my God is remarkable!
No, redshift can have many causes: dust clouds, gravitation and expansion. The contribution of the different components has been measured and exists.
The contribution for different components with the assumption that one of the components is expansion has been done. Everything left over gets assigned to the other components.
Gravity I agree with you. We can measure it and predict its effects but we are not yet sure what actually causes it. Inertia I do not have the background knowledge to comment. Just because we do not know some things does not mean that we do not know anything at all. We do not know the name of Cain’s wife; does that mean that we can know nothing from the Bible?
We can have knowledge of the universe, just not absolute knowledge.
Interpretations of scripture can be changed (remember Limbo?). The Church has not pronounced infallibly on this so Catholics are free to change interpretations as the science changes.
Limbo was never scriptural. Bad example.
Did you mean “mobile” or “immobile”? If the earth is at the centre of the universe then the moon is not. What experiment could we perform on the moon to show that the moon is not at the centre?

The crust of the earth is in motion, as at Thingvellir (Þingvellir) in Iceland. What experiment could we perform in Thingvellir to show that one side (at least) of the valley is in motion relative to the centre of the universe?

rossum
The earth’s crust is not the earth. The crust may move. Also the best evidence that the crust moves is from measurements using quasars, ASSUMED to be at cosmological distances, as a reference, but be it as it may, the crust can move and the universe can still be geocentric. Local motion on the earth does not destroy the theory.

The only thing that keeps the other 50% from being considered is the naturalistic/materialistic (atheistic) philosophy of cosmologists. Catholics should just look at what they have to say, consider it, but not reject what the Church has taught (my view anyway, and St. Bellarmine’s amongst others).

Spend some time at www.geocentrism.com and see what the scientists themselves are saying. Your claims are more absolute than theirs. Think about it.
 
All measurements up to now show that the universe is isotropic from our perspective.
I am glad we agree.
We can have knowledge of the universe, just not absolute knowledge.
Agreed, with the proviso that we make use of the knowledge we currently have until such time as we have better knowledge. Newton’s theory was very useful even though it does not apply in as many circumstances as Newton thought it did.
Limbo was never scriptural. Bad example.
Fine. Then the Christian attitude to salvery has changed between the time of the Roman Empire and now. Scriptural interpretations have changed over time in the past. We should not be surprised if they also change in the future.
The earth’s crust is not the earth.
Then what part of the earth is (im)mobile relative to the centre of the universe? The earth’s crust is certainly a part of “the earth”.
Also the best evidence that the crust moves is from measurements using quasars, ASSUMED to be at cosmological distances, as a reference, but be it as it may, the crust can move and the universe can still be geocentric.
The measurement of the movement of the crust of the earth has nothing to do with quasars. All you have to do is to find a place where a boundary between two tectonic plates is on land (as in Thingvellir) and place two markers on either side of the plate boundary. Measure the distance between the markers very accurately over a period of time. The two plates at Thingvellir are separating at a few centimetrees a year - about the speed that your fingernails grow.
Local motion on the earth does not destroy the theory.
I do not claim that it does, but it does allow us to test the theory. If two parts of the earth are moving relative to each other then at least one of them must be moving relative to the centre of the universe. What experiment can you perform to show this motion relative to the centre of the universe? At Thingvellir at least one side of the valley must be in motion relative to the cente of the universe. How can you show this motion in an experiment?

rossum
 
I am glad we agree.
Good one issue put to rest. From our perspective the earth appears central. There thus 2 possibilities:
  1. The earth (or nominally our galaxy) is central;
  2. Everywhere is central;
As Stephen Hawking said [referring to 2]:

“…We have no scientific evidence for, or against, this assumption…”
Agreed, with the proviso that we make use of the knowledge we currently have until such time as we have better knowledge. Newton’s theory was very useful even though it does not apply in as many circumstances as Newton thought it did.
Agreed, science continues to make new discoveries. Some day we may even know what gravity and inertia are! Then we can start to really understand how the universe works with confidence.
Fine. Then the Christian attitude to salvery has changed between the time of the Roman Empire and now. Scriptural interpretations have changed over time in the past. We should not be surprised if they also change in the future.
I am not sure anything has changed theologically on slavery. It was always considered undesireable, but the Church accepted that some people ended up in the situation due to wars etc. The scriptures taught to treat slaves respectfully. I think racial based slavery is a different category. Don’t confuse societal attitudes with Church dogma and doctrine.
Then what part of the earth is (im)mobile relative to the centre of the universe? The earth’s crust is certainly a part of “the earth”.
I would say minimally the center of mass.
The measurement of the movement of the crust of the earth has nothing to do with quasars. All you have to do is to find a place where a boundary between two tectonic plates is on land (as in Thingvellir) and place two markers on either side of the plate boundary. Measure the distance between the markers very accurately over a period of time. The two plates at Thingvellir are separating at a few centimetrees a year - about the speed that your fingernails grow.
True, it can be done locally, but it is also done through Very Long Baseline Interferometry, whcih uses quasars.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_Long_Baseline_Interferometry

"Motion of the Earth’s tectonic plates "
I do not claim that it does, but it does allow us to test the theory. If two parts of the earth are moving relative to each other then at least one of them must be moving relative to the centre of the universe. What experiment can you perform to show this motion relative to the centre of the universe? At Thingvellir at least one side of the valley must be in motion relative to the cente of the universe. How can you show this motion in an experiment?

rossum
Not necessarily, the earth-universe act as a system.

I think both assumptions suffer from falsifiability issues. Find a center and you have disproven isotropy, but also proven the existence of a center.
The ultimate truth is that there is no Ultimate Truth.
If this is where you are coming from, then I suspect we will have a hard time actually resolving this.
 
I would say minimally the center of mass.
If the earth’s centre of mass is stationary at the centre of the universe, then because many parts of the earth’s surface are in motion with respect to that centre of mass (due to continental drift and other mechanisms), those parts of the earth’s surface are also in motion with respect to the centre of the universe.

This allows us to test Hawking’s assumption you quoted earlier. If everywhere is the centre of the universe then all points on the earth’s surface are equally the centre of the universe and we would expect all experiments to show zero motion relative to the centre of the universe. However, if the centre of the universe is at the centre of mass of the earth, then many points on the earth’s surface are in motion with respect to the centre of the universe. Experiments performed at such points on the earth’s surface should be able to show any such motion relative to the centre of the universe.

Where is you data from such experiments? I have already suggested one possible location, in Thingvellir. Unless you have done some experiments to show such motion the your contention has no support in experiment.
Not necessarily, the earth-universe act as a system.
But it is a system with parts, and those parts are in relative motion. In particular your geocentric universe has parts of the earth’s surface in motion relative to the centre of the universe. The common scientific theory has the centre of the universe everywhere, and hence thare can be no relative motion between any location in the universe and the centre of the universe. That is a difference in predictions between the two theories. Where is your experimental evidence to show the relative motion between the centre of the universe and parts of the surface of the earth? This is science, you need experimental support.
I think both assumptions suffer from falsifiability issues. Find a center and you have disproven isotropy, but also proven the existence of a center.
I have proposed a way to experimentally test different predictions from the two theories. What experimental results do you have to support your position?
If this is where you are coming from, then I suspect we will have a hard time actually resolving this.
You are not the first person to notice my sig. The original source is Mark Siderits, “Thinking on Empty: Madhyamika Anti-Realism and Canons of Rationality” in S Biderman and B.A. Schaufstein, eds, Rationality In Question (1989). Dordrecht: Brill.

I have not read Siderits but saw the quote in a piece on Nagarjuna. The “Madhyamika” in Siderits’ title refers to the religious and philosophical school that Nagarjuna founded. I have seen the same quote again in other places in reference to the Madhyamika and Nagarjuna - it seems quite popular. The quote is intentionally paradoxical; paradox is necessary to remind us that words are insufficient when trying to describe the fundamental nature of reality.

For a philosophical discussion of Nagarjuna and reality see the web article “Nagarjuna and the Limits of Thought”. The Siderits quote is at the end of section four of the article:

There is, then, no escape. Nagarjuna’s view is contradictory. The contradiction is, clearly a paradox of expressibility. Nagarjuna succeeds in saying the unsayable, just as much as the Wittgenstein of the Tractatus. We can think (and characterize) reality only subject to language, which is conventional, so the ontology of that reality is all conventional. It follows that the conventional objects of reality do not ultimately (non-conventionally) exist. It also follows that nothing we say of them is ultimately true. That is, all things are empty of ultimate existence; and this is their ultimate nature, and is an ultimate truth about them. They hence cannot be thought to have that nature; nor can we say that they do. But we have just done so. As Mark Siderits (1989) has put it, “the ultimate truth is that there is no ultimate truth.”

Science does not deal with ultimate truth, it just deals with “the best answer we have so far”.

rossum
 
If the earth’s centre of mass is stationary at the centre of the universe, then because many parts of the earth’s surface …
I am not sure the significance of the earth’s surface. If there is motion on the surface, and the earth-universe are a system, the universe could change ever so slightly to adjust for it.
…Science does not deal with ultimate truth, it just deals with “the best answer we have so far”.

rossum
I agree, and actually, your statement does work within scientific knowledge, but makes it difficult once discussions of Catholic theology begin (where there is absolute knowledge, granted with interpretive difficulties).

I would add,

Science does not deal with ultimate truth, it just deals with “the best answer we have so far” within the philosopical framework in which we interpert it.
 
I am not sure the significance of the earth’s surface. If there is motion on the surface, and the earth-universe are a system, the universe could change ever so slightly to adjust for it.
You are resorting to speculation, “could change”, rather than experimentation. This puts you in the realm of philosophy rather than science. A perfectly good realm to be in, but not one that has any standing inside science. If you want a scientist to accept geocentrism then you are going to have to provide experimental evidence to show the relative motion of some parts of the earth and the centre of the universe.

Where is your evidence?

rossum
 
Genesis 1:20-21 tells us that God created birds on day five of creation week. Genesis 1:26-27 tells us that God created man on the sixth day of creation week.

Genesis 2:18-19 tells us that God created birds after He created man (Genesis 2:7).

Genesis 1 places the creation of birds on day five and the creation of man on day six; Genesis 2 places the creation of birds after the creation of man. Hence Genesis is telling us that either day five followed after day six, or that the events of the two days overlapped.

Standard 24-hour days do not overlap and do not change their order. Hence the days described in Genesis are not standard 24-hour days.

Origen thought so:“What intelligent person will suppose that there was a first, a second and a third day, that there was evening and morning without the existence of the sun and moon and stars? Or that there was a first day without a sky?”
  • Origen, as quoted in the Philokalia
God could have done anything, but he actually did it in a particaular way. Making the assumption that God in not deceptive, then the evidence He left in the rocks and in our genes tells us that the methods He used involved billions of years and evolution.

rossum
The above gave the occasion to reread the rich and poignant account of our origins .

The fascination with this topic as seen by the many threads and posts seems healthy …if we get the beginnings right , then the rest of the journey may be in the right direction …

The deepest yearning and question in our hearts may be - was The Father really there …and so hands on …
Code:
  As to the age of the universe itself - seems those first verses in -  Gen 1 : 1and 2 -  would accomodate any age of the  general universe , since it does not p(name removed by moderator)oint any time period  !
Seems the subsequent verses gives us an account of creation in reference particulary to the earth and it’s immediate environs ;and even here seems the verses leave enough room , to accomodate whatever the truth may be !

Chapter two is mostly a recap of the earlier creation account but this time particularly in reference to man - the beloved son Adam , how there was a garden specifically prepared for Adam , in the midst of creation of the earth ; 2:19 only says how all the animals, who had already been made , were brought to Adam to be named !

An awesome , loving and generous Father indeed !
Code:
And what a day our children could have,  just revisualising those glorious days , instead of the  subtle lies of the evil one that gets drilled in with most 'nature programs' - how man is the enemy of creation and the  cause of the animals  not making it ( well partially true ;  but it is the workings of  enemy induced   greed that causes the problems !)
Blessings !
 
The Church has ruled that the universe is of finite age.

God bless,
Ed
 
The Church has ruled that the universe is of finite age.

God bless,
Ed
I have not heard of this.

Most astronomers would probably agree with a finite age, but perhaps not all. Some might argue for a temporally infinite oscillating universe. While that does not seem as elegant as a universe with a temporal beginning, I don’t see it as a problem for theology.
 
The Church has ruled that the universe is of finite age.
That seems to make sense if (as we believe) the universe is a created thing. Can a created thing be of infinite age? I doubt it, though I couldn’t prove it either way.
 
That seems to make sense if (as we believe) the universe is a created thing. Can a created thing be of infinite age? I doubt it, though I couldn’t prove it either way.
The universe and all its parts is still a contingent being, whether it has an infinte extension in space–or time–or not. It is a material being with extension in space and time of whatever length, and as such is capable of being reduced to its parts, in both time and space.

A contingent being is but might not have been.

Only God is a non-contingent being.

And a universe, whether it has a finite or an infinite extension in time or space, still requires God to create it (as well as to create time and space.)

From his vantage point outside of time and space, it really makes little difference whether he creates it with a finite extension in space or an infinite extension in space, a finite extension in time or an infinite extension in time. It’s still a created, contingent universe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top