I would say minimally the center of mass.
If the earth’s centre of mass is stationary at the centre of the universe, then because many parts of the earth’s surface are in motion with respect to that centre of mass (due to continental drift and other mechanisms), those parts of the earth’s surface are also in motion with respect to the centre of the universe.
This allows us to test Hawking’s assumption you quoted earlier. If everywhere is the centre of the universe then all points on the earth’s surface are equally the centre of the universe and we would expect all experiments to show zero motion relative to the centre of the universe. However, if the centre of the universe is at the centre of mass of the earth, then many points on the earth’s surface are in motion with respect to the centre of the universe. Experiments performed at such points on the earth’s surface should be able to show any such motion relative to the centre of the universe.
Where is you data from such experiments? I have already suggested one possible location, in Thingvellir. Unless you have done some experiments to show such motion the your contention has no support in experiment.
Not necessarily, the earth-universe act as a system.
But it is a system with parts, and those parts are in relative motion. In particular your geocentric universe has parts of the earth’s surface in motion relative to the centre of the universe. The common scientific theory has the centre of the universe everywhere, and hence thare can be no relative motion between any location in the universe and the centre of the universe. That is a difference in predictions between the two theories. Where is your experimental evidence to show the relative motion between the centre of the universe and parts of the surface of the earth? This is science, you need experimental support.
I think both assumptions suffer from falsifiability issues. Find a center and you have disproven isotropy, but also proven the existence of a center.
I have proposed a way to experimentally test different predictions from the two theories. What experimental results do you have to support your position?
If this is where you are coming from, then I suspect we will have a hard time actually resolving this.
You are not the first person to notice my sig. The original source is Mark Siderits, “Thinking on Empty: Madhyamika Anti-Realism and Canons of Rationality” in S Biderman and B.A. Schaufstein, eds, Rationality In Question (1989). Dordrecht: Brill.
I have not read Siderits but saw the quote in a piece on Nagarjuna. The “Madhyamika” in Siderits’ title refers to the religious and philosophical school that Nagarjuna founded. I have seen the same quote again in other places in reference to the Madhyamika and Nagarjuna - it seems quite popular. The quote is intentionally paradoxical; paradox is necessary to remind us that words are insufficient when trying to describe the fundamental nature of reality.
For a philosophical discussion of Nagarjuna and reality see the web article “Nagarjuna and the Limits of Thought”. The Siderits quote is at the end of section four of the article:
There is, then, no escape. Nagarjuna’s view is contradictory. The contradiction is, clearly a paradox of expressibility. Nagarjuna succeeds in saying the unsayable, just as much as the Wittgenstein of the
Tractatus. We can think (and characterize) reality only subject to language, which is conventional, so the ontology of that reality is all conventional. It follows that the conventional objects of reality do not ultimately (non-conventionally) exist. It also follows that nothing we say of them is ultimately true. That is, all things are empty of ultimate existence; and this is their ultimate nature, and is an ultimate truth about them. They hence cannot be thought to have that nature; nor can we say that they do. But we have just done so. As Mark Siderits (1989) has put it, “the ultimate truth is that there is no ultimate truth.”
Science does not deal with ultimate truth, it just deals with “the best answer we have so far”.
rossum