A question about Mary and Joseph

  • Thread starter Thread starter Binary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m not convinced that canon law doesn’t apply to pre-Christ marriages, because canon law itself prescinds from Natural Law. Right? .
the portions of canon law that depend on natural law flow from it. Not all tenets of canon law however are dependent on it. What you or I become convinced of is irrelevant. You asked the teaching, you received excellent answers, and referrals to more extensive discussion, which you appear not to have read.
 
the portions of canon law that depend on natural law flow from it. Not all tenets of canon law however are dependent on it. What you or I become convinced of is irrelevant. You asked the teaching, you received excellent answers, and referrals to more extensive discussion, which you appear not to have read.
Well, so far the only reason I have to think that canon law doesn’t apply to all people in all times is your assertion of that fact. Forgive me for being skeptical. I received excellent answers for my first question re: the validity of a Josephite marriage, specifically Joseph’s marriage. Now I have a corollary to that question, “Why not allow permanently impotent people to marry also?”

Swizzle has presented the idea that it is an issue of consent. Would it be correct to say that permanently impotent people lack the ability to fully consent to marital vows?

I did read that whole thread. Why wouldn’t I read material that someone provided to answer my question? I didn’t understand all of it, and I still have some questions, so here we are. If my questions are bothering you, I’ll be happy to delete this thread.
 
=Binary;7802869]In order to avoid scandalizing anyone, let me say that this isn’t intended to be a “gotcha” question or a criticism. I’m asking bluntly because I genuinely want to know.

The Church would refuse to marry any two people who said that they intended to remain celibate for life. Does this mean that Mary and Joseph’s marriage is invalid in the eyes of the Church?
GREAT QUESTION!

The answer has at least THREE components:
  1. It was the Will of God [because it was the will of both Mary and Joseph]
2.This was a church practice only at the time of its event. The CC and her authority were still in the furture.
  1. It was seen as necessary [perhaps only highly beneficial?] by God to not further complicate th many issues surrounding the Incarnation. I.E. If it happened Once, why not mutiple times. From Genesis On, Yahweh preached and taught ONLY One God. “I AM” your God… there is NO-OTHER. Thus the Trinity is not readily introduced until the Birth of Christ, and THOUSANDS of years of seating this beleif and understanding: One God."
God Bless,
Pat
 
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I would think that canon law is not a creation of truth, only a codification of it.
That is exactly correct. What you’re missing is that God can, and in this case has made exceptions to the rule. And in the case of Joseph and Mary, God had made a formal exception…

“If she marries after she makes a vow or after her lips utter a rash promise by which she obligates herself and her husband hears about it but says nothing to her, then her vows or the pledges by which she obligated herself will stand." (Numbers 30:6-7)

So, why do you think God made this exception under the Law of Moses? 😉

God bless.
 
A point of clarification here is that there is a difference between “celibate” and “continent” and there was a lengthy discussion about the two terms in the catholic living forum. I was completely unaware of the nuances of these things before that discussion.

I will be paraphrasing from memory but I believe that a person who is single and not sexually active is celibate and married persons who may at one time have consummated their marriage may at one point consent to living together but sleeping separately and thus they are monogamous and continent.

1ke, puzzleannie, or anybody else please correct me if I have misstated this.

Great topic for discussion by the way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top