A Tale of Two Eucharists (Continued)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Socrates4Jesus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That was the British government executing her as an enemy of the British state (all fair and true); she was not executed for witchcraft, and not executed by the Church at all.
Thank you for the correction. My mistake.

:o
 
One need not go to get, but to give. We may simply go to be present with Him who condescends to be present with us.
Thank you, George. When you say you are closer to Him, i’m assuming you mean Jesus. Are you saying that Jesus is the Eucharist, or do you believe that the Eucharist is not Him but that He is merely present in the Eucharist?
 
Dear Soc,

thanks for precising. Indeed I was not aware of major protestant positions supporting the idea of a further Covenant.
What is different in the picture you describe from the model I’m more familiar with, is that you call the visible pre-costantinian Church ( if i am correct ) catholic Church. Many protestant brothers put it that the Catholic Church was born out of the deviation. Do you mean that - according to the picture you are coming from - the Catholic Church was there even in the first century ?

In any case, we have this issue of the legitimate earthly authority.
If we agree there is one in the NT as in the OT, and if they say
the visible Church went astray, what happened and is of the legitimate NT earthly authority ? Now, it appears that while authority can clearly change expression, organization, in other words can develop, it is a principle and as such cannot disappear. Therefore we should see where legitimate acknowledgeble authority ( the one against which Korah’s sin can be made ) shifted or remained in the IV century, and how it developed to our days according to that picture.

As for the concrete supposed compromises, I guess we could examine them in a new thread.

Another aspect which is interesting here is: admitting the visible Church at the beginning of the IV century ( or in the late IV, if the turning point is the establishment of Niceen Christianity as the official religion ) was still the truth bearer, did she look more like the present Catholic Church,
or more as the X modern faith community I can find today ?
Did she believe, to come back to the present topic, in Real Presence or in a symbolic Lord Supper ?
The Protestant position with which i’m most familiar is one i’ve heard taught by both Evangelical and Calvary Chapel teachers. It is that, even though the official teaching of the Roman Catholic church strayed from the genuine gospel of who Jesus is and how we might know Him for all eternity, there remained, within the church, a faithful remnant. This remnant held to the true gospel throughout the history of the church and is still present today within Her.

There is a precedent for this in the Old Testament: When the vast majority of the Jewish people turned their backs on God and lived for sin rather than Him and suffered His judgement, there remained a faithful few to pick up the pieces after God’s wrath subsided. In the case of the Roman Catholic church, it had become unfaithful, but the remnant of the true catholic (or universal) church remained faithful. The split into two religions did not occur until Luther, who was one of the faithful remnant. This is why you will find Protestant churches having in their creeds a statement of belief in the catholic (with a small c) church. Hence, the Gates of Hell might have won battles against the policy makers of the Roman Catholic church, but did not win the war against the true saints of the true catholic church who prevail faithfully to this day.

Again, i’m not trying to argue that this is true. I’m just telling you what i’ve been taught. What is needed is some unbiased expert who truly understands the history whom i can ask many questions.
 
I tend more to think that He meant it literally.

Not being able to read John in the original language in which it was written, not knowing the Aramaic in which it was spoken nor the idioms of the time, and not being present when He spoke the words, we may never know for sure (on this earth).

For example, take the story of the Canaanite woman in Matthew 15:21-28. I used to wonder how our loving Lord would call anyone a dog :eek: ! Then I read that in the language of the time, there were two words for dogs: one was for the mangy stray and the other was for a beloved family pet. Jesus did not use the first meaning which would have been ian insult, He used the word for the second meaning, and that by His using the second meaning she understood what He meant and replied with a response which showed her faith.

Another example is CAF where sometimes posters sometimes get upset with one another because what was posted lightheartedly was taken seriously or sarcastically or as an insult.

So, while He may have spoken figuratively, I don’t really think we will ever know for sure.
You, Rose might find it as interesting as i did to learn that there was a prayer that ancient Jewish rabbis of Jesus’ day faithfully prayed when they woke up each morning: “Lord, I thank you that I was not born a slave, a dog, or a woman.”

The word dog, i learned from studying ancient Jewish culture, was a racial slur meaning anyone uncircumcised like a dog (that is, any non-Jewish Gentile). In other words, the rabbi was thanking God for giving him:
  • His Freedom
  • His Jewish heritage and religion
  • His status in society
    The Samaritan woman was half Jewish and half Gentile (as the Samaritans interbred with non-Jewish people). So the racial slur dog would have been familiar to her, as well as to Jesus.
Now, one might point the finger at the ancient Jewish male and call him racist and sexist, but the ancient Jewish nation, due largely to their precepts of the religion, did more to protect the rights of foreigners and woman than any pagan nation of the time. The most perfect Jewish rabbi of all (Jesus the Messiah) did even more to protect us against racism and sexism. At least, that’s how i see it.
 
I look with my heart and I see Jesus. 🙂
Thank you, JM for sticking with me to the end!

I’m still a little confused about this, and want to make sure i understand correctly before i leave. Please tell me: When you say you look at the Eucharist and see Jesus, do you mean the Eucharist is Jesus? or do you mean the Eucharist is not Jesus but that Jesus is present in the Eucharist.
 
Thank you, Ut. Have you ever been to Adoration Chapel? If so, why did you go and did you get that for which you went?
I’ve made a commitment to spend one hour at my Church’s adoration chapel every first Friday.

For me, the Eucharist is central to my faith. When my faith was almost gone, I asked God to prove his existence to me. There is a certain devotion that I had read about in my mother’s old church book that promised wonderful graces for a person if they would spend one hour in front of the blessed sacrament every first Friday of the month for nine months. I told God I would do this devotion, but in return, he had to prove himself to me because I could no longer believe.

After those nine months were over, I was transformed in my faith. I found a peace I never had before. The intellectual answers came later. I enrolled in a Classical Studies program where I learned about the faith of the early church fathers. I also learned about Catholic mysticism, monasticism, and theology based on the writting of such as Saints Benedict, Anselm, Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, Bonaventure, Theresa of Avila, John of the Cross, and Therese of Lisieux to name only a few. I also read the Bible cover to cover over four times, and I am still reading it today and every day. The journey is still ongoing.

So to answer your question as to why I go, it is the source of my faith or at least the focal point in which I encounter Christ the man, my channel to the Trinity. I also believe the Eucharist is the source of all Graces. If there is anything holy in the Catholic church, it comes from the Eucharist, the man Christ, the second person of the Holy Trinity.

God bless,
Ut
 
Thank you, JM for sticking with me to the end!

I’m still a little confused about this, and want to make sure i understand correctly before i leave. Please tell me: When you say you look at the Eucharist and see Jesus, do you mean the Eucharist is Jesus? or do you mean the Eucharist is not Jesus but that Jesus is present in the Eucharist.
The Eucharist is Jesus.

In the prayer of the Consecration, the priest asks the angels to take away the bread and the wine, and to send Jesus in its place. Thus, Jesus perfectly displaces the bread and the wine, which is now gone away into Heaven to become “bread of angels” as St. Thomas Aquinas so eloquently calls it in one of his hymns. 🙂
 
The Protestant position with which i’m most familiar is one i’ve heard taught by both Evangelical and Calvary Chapel teachers. It is that, even though the official teaching of the Roman Catholic church strayed from the genuine gospel of who Jesus is and how we might know Him for all eternity, there remained, within the church, a faithful remnant. This remnant held to the true gospel throughout the history of the church and is still present today within Her.

There is a precedent for this in the Old Testament: When the vast majority of the Jewish people turned their backs on God and lived for sin rather than Him and suffered His judgement, there remained a faithful few to pick up the pieces after God’s wrath subsided. In the case of the Roman Catholic church, it had become unfaithful, but the remnant of the true catholic (or universal) church remained faithful. The split into two religions did not occur until Luther, who was one of the faithful remnant. This is why you will find Protestant churches having in their creeds a statement of belief in the catholic (with a small c) church. Hence, the Gates of Hell might have won battles against the policy makers of the Roman Catholic church, but did not win the war against the true saints of the true catholic church who prevail faithfully to this day.

Again, i’m not trying to argue that this is true. I’m just telling you what i’ve been taught. What is needed is some unbiased expert who truly understands the history whom i can ask many questions.
Code:
 Dear Soc,

            sorry, I was somewhat confused  by:
Many Protestants think of the Roman Catholic church the way the Roman Catholic church thinks of the non-Christian Jewish people: They respect them for being the bearer of the truth,

Usually, in Protestantism the "Roman Catholic church " is not described as “bearer of the truth”. Now I think I’m led back by your recent description to familiar models, about which I had given this hint:
( generally the protestant model I see proclaimed is rather the going astray of the original apostolic visible Church, producing in a certain period - not exactly clear what period - the Catholic Church, with the true doctrine being conserved according to different sub-models by the “invisible church” or by scattered local visible churches…,
Code:
      we should now understand whether the "faithful remnant" of those teachers  fits sub-model  a) "invisible church"  or b) scattered visible churches.
In both cases among the common questions are:
  • Which present faith community would the faithful remnant look like (most) through the whole of those 12 centuries ( IV to XVI ) ?
-Which present faith community would the pre-compromises mainstream IV century Church look like (most) ? ( and in which side of the eucharistic “battlefield” would that church be ?)

“Luther … was one of the faithful remnant.”

That can lead us back to the present topic again. Do you know Luther’s position on the Real Presence ? 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top