Abstaining during the Honeymoon

  • Thread starter Thread starter TreeHugger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You aren’t married until you consummate the marriage.
Wow! So Joeseph and Mary were never really married? That changes a whole lot of beliefs.
 
40.png
TAS2000:
Wow! So Joeseph and Mary were never really married? That changes a whole lot of beliefs.
Interesting observation…never thought of it that way.

When we went through our pre-marital counseling we were quizzed by the priest about our physical capacity to engage in sex and any known impediment thereto. Thinking this was odd, we asked why it mattered and were told that if we were unable to consumate the marriage, we could not be married in the Catholic Church–something which, to this day bothers me, though I’m not sure if it is an absolute prohibition. If it is, then anyone who suffers from an injury or illness prior to marriage which prevents sexual intercourse is not qualified to marry(?)
 
Island Oak:
Interesting observation…never thought of it that way.

When we went through our pre-marital counseling we were quizzed by the priest about our physical capacity to engage in sex and any known impediment thereto. Thinking this was odd, we asked why it mattered and were told that if we were unable to consumate the marriage, we could not be married in the Catholic Church–something which, to this day bothers me, though I’m not sure if it is an absolute prohibition. If it is, then anyone who suffers from an injury or illness prior to marriage which prevents sexual intercourse is not qualified to marry(?)
Yes. It is an absolute impediment to marriage. No dispensation can be granted for the inability to consummate a marriage.

As for the Joseph and Mary comment, of course they were married. Their marriage existed before the foundation of the Church and therefore would not be subject to the same laws that govern Catholic marriage today.
 
Well, I was being sarcastic when I brought up Mary and Joeseph, but I would LOVE to see some documentation about not being able to marry if you are physically unable to consumate. A very dear friend’s brother is a quadrapalegic (since he was 18), who obviously will never be able to consumate. I was unaware that there was a restriction, and never heard of it before. Where would that be documented? I would have thought the quizing at the marriage classes was more of a “full disclosure” sort of thing, so both parties go in with a full understanding and not be surprised later on.
 
My wife and I abstained during our honeymoon. Not by choice though.

Took a cruise.

She gets seasick.
 
40.png
Christian4life:
…
But, I’m not saying you don’t have a good enough reason to abstain, dear, that is between you and God!
Thank you for saying that. You are the first I’ve ever seen ackowledge that.

Ham1 and Benedictus made the same claim, that if one isn’t ready to have children right away one isn’t ready for children. Perhaps that would be appropriate spiritual direction for some couples but is it authentic Catholic teaching or just the opinion of some?

Also, what constitutes a “serious reason”? What doesn’t? This is going to vary for one couple to the next: two couples could decide that they are going to delay having children because completing educational goals is important. For one it could be morally right because they have discerned that this is God’s plan for their marriage and the other could be sinning because they were doing so for selfish reasons.
 
Yes. It is an absolute impediment to marriage. No dispensation can be granted for the inability to consummate a marriage.
Just for the record, I asked my priest last night, and he said, yes, it was an impediment, but that you could get a dispensation.
 
Canon 1084 is pretty clear that permanent impotence is an impediment to marriage. I can’t find any canon that would allow granting a dispensation.
 
In terms of Mary and Joseph not being married because they did not consummate, keep in mind that marriage was not a sacrament then. Jesus was not around to have created the sacraments yet. Therefore…they could not have had an invalid marriage because it was not a sacrament to begin with at that time.
 
We abstained as she was in the fertility period.

God gave us marriage along with the delightful gift of children. But those of us who were confirmed (another sacrament) were also given the gift of wisdom.

I don’t remember reading anything about honeymoons in the bible or any church documents. It is no more important to have intercourse on the honeymoon than any other day(s) of married life.

Marriage is a lifelong commitment, delay of days is of no importance.

2nd point…

Canon law is not doctrine. Any canon can be changed, and any canon can be dispensed. As with any man made law, a variance can be granted by the appropriate authority.
 
Canon 1084 states that impotence is an impediment, but that sterility is not. So is a permanent disability like being a quadrapalegic considered impotence or sterility? And either way, I’d still think that you could get a dispensation from the appropriate authority, which I believe would be the bishop.
 
We abstained for 10 days after our wedding. It was so difficult, but we had just cause to delay pregnancy and felt like it was necessary. We also delayed our honeymoon to two weeks post wedding, and were VERY happy we did that. 🙂

We did not get much support for our choices, but it was what worked for us. And we got to enjoy Aruba as husband and wife! 🙂
 
40.png
TAS2000:
Canon 1084 states that impotence is an impediment, but that sterility is not. So is a permanent disability like being a quadrapalegic considered impotence or sterility? And either way, I’d still think that you could get a dispensation from the appropriate authority, which I believe would be the bishop.
Total physical impotence is the impossibility of having intercourse. For instance if a man has no genitalia. Even a quadraplegic can sometimes have intercourse, he just can’t feel it.
 
Marraige is one of the only sacraments where the initiation of the sacrament is not reliant upon the priest. Here, the priest is only a witness. It’s when the husband and wife come together in the marital embrase for the first time is what makes it happen. Every act after that is just a copy and remembrance of the first time they have sex. Hence, waiting for any reason is not a good idea…if you died that night…would you be married?..
👍
 
Hey all,
I know that circumstances may change, but as of now, it looks like my fertile time is going to fall smack right during the honeymoon. My fiance and I are planning on using NFP for about 2 months. I was just wondering if anyone else abstained during their honeymoon. :crying:

Then again, we have been doing it for the last 22 / 24 years of our lives, right?
We waited a week or so.
 
Humm…I would certainly prefer to have a consummated and thus indisolvable etc marriage for my honeymoon…but I suppose if some serious reason came up at that time…

From the Compendium of the Catechism:
  1. When is it moral to regulate births?
2368-2369
2399

The regulation of births, which is an aspect of responsible fatherhood and motherhood, is objectively morally acceptable when it is pursued by the spouses without external pressure; when it is practiced not out of selfishness but for serious reasons; and with methods that conform to the objective criteria of morality, that is, periodic continence and use of the infertile periods.
  1. What are immoral means of birth control?
2370-2372

Every action - for example, direct sterilization or contraception - is intrinsically immoral which (either in anticipation of the conjugal act, in its accomplishment or in the development of its natural consequences) proposes, as an end or as a means, to hinder procreation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top