Accusation of self-righteousness

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jump4Joy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jump4Joy

Guest
Is that a way to detract from another’s holiness? Why is it difficult for some people to believe people can be holy? Not everyone harbors grudges. Some people can forgive the most heinous acts freely. Instead of working on their own holiness, others try to determine if this person is indeed that good. Why? Not everyone flies off the handle easily. Not everyone engages in judging, gossiping, backbiting, holds racial prejudice. Why do some people attempt to rationalize their sin by calling it human nature or they believe they can know how the average person thinks? Some people can remain completely rational, objective, and stoic in the face of opposition. What’s so wrong about being honest about your good qualities or saying you could handle a situation better than someone else did?
 
This is due to our brokenness which has not been fully healed that we have not become like Christ.

As long as we are carrying our unhealed brokenness, the Christ that is in us is being suppressed but instead we see the wretched inner man in us being control by our fallen nature.

If we look at the saints, or perhaps realistically someone in our parish, who has overcome or able to control the negative aspect of their character, they have nothing against anybody but love.
 
Why is it difficult to be holy? It looks far easier to go to hell
 
Obviously. Jesus said as much. It is like choosing the narrow road which few would take, unlike the wide road which many choose but which lead to damanation. Yet, nothing is impossible with God.

Holiness must be achieved through repentance which brings about transformation in us. If there’s an area that we cannot repent of, we need to ask God to help us by the power of the Holy Spirit.
 
It almost doesn’t seem real to never be angry, feel hatred or that that is how God intended us to be. It is difficult to think loving your enemies is real commandment. With such high standards who goes to heaven?
 
Those who choose to love are the ones going to heaven. I would like to hope that I could bring others with me to heaven.
 
How do you sincerely love your enemy and what does that look like?
 
I pray that I have a change of heart and they would no longer be my enemies. I have a friend that believes in Wiccan (sort of). She lived with her boyfriend until she became pregnant. She wanted to be very pregnant when she got married. She knew my religious beliefs and she wanted to know why I did not hassle her about her lifestyle. I told her that I did not need to lecture her and that I hoped one day she would find her way. I cared about her.
 
Well, a number of thoughts came up, and this turned out longer than expected.

It seems to me there are few things more elusive than pride and humility. Self-knowledge is difficult enough, so we should be very slow to think we know what motivates other people (for instance, accusing someone of self-righteousness). Our Lord’s command “Judge not” seems to me to most often apply to the intentions of others. Someone can be objectively wrong, or do something objectively wrong, or I strongly think they’re wrong, but I’m unlikely to know why they did it. Their intentions are not for us to judge, unless they really make them explicit.

If someone thinks it is that easy to discern pride and self-righteousness, they might wonder about some of the sayings of our exemplars:
“Learn of me, because I am meek, and humble of heart.” (Mt 11:29)
“My soul doth magnify the Lord.” (Lk 1:46).
“Be ye followers of me, as I also am of Christ.” (1 Cor 11:1).
“I speak that which I have seen with my Father: and you do the things that you have seen with your father [satan].” (Jn 8:38).

It seems people often accuse others of self-righteousness, simply because they disagree with them. It’s unfortunate how powerful an idle word can be. When someone seems arrogant or self-righteous, they might just be saying what they know or at least believe is true. And it’s not easy to say the hard truth sometimes without sounding self-righteous. Humility is actually pretty easy to fake–or maybe I’m just very good at it, because people think I’m humble even though I’m not. I imagine the Pharisees considered Jesus extremely self-righteous. So we should try to be gentle and decent, but we shouldn’t worry much about how we come across. As St. Mother Teresa says, “God has not called me to be successful; He has called me to be faithful.”–We be faithful; God takes care of the windy, wobbly nuances of Providence.
 
Last edited:
Or at least, these things are hard to discern because of our own lack of holiness. There’s a wonderful book, “Self-Abandonment to Divine Providence,” where Fr. J.P. de Caussade explains that God often hides the gifts we have from us, because we are in danger of becoming proud, even though He is in fact working good things through us.
“We compel God to conceal his gifts from us and the interior riches with which he adorns us. Otherwise, the smallest breath of vanity or complacency, however imperceptible, would rot and destroy these flowers and fruits. Once you are in a state to wear and enjoy these without danger, God will cause your eyes to open. Your only endeavor, then, will be to praise and bless him, forgetting yourself and rendering all the glory of your deliverance to your divine Liberator. Meantime, follow the present guidance of his Holy Spirit, and do not terrify your heart. Be sure that there is no sin in all you are experiencing at this time, since you endure it with so much grief and you would know such happiness could you extirpate these wretched results of your sensitiveness. Uphold yourself in this blessed longing; offer up your prayers; be patient in your petitions; above all humble yourself before God: he it is who will complete the work he has begun in you; there is none other able to perform it. Recognize that this is the delicate sacrifice God asks of you before filling your heart with the ineffable delight of his pure love.”

Your feelings of anger are not sinful. When we choose to do good to our enemies, despite our anger, then we are loving them and loving God through them. But of course we need to pray for this. You may feel powerless in this trial, but by trusting less in yourself, you have much greater cause to trust completely in God, who alone will lead you in holiness.
Hope some of this is helpful.
Ave Maria and God bless!
 
It almost doesn’t seem real to never be angry, feel hatred or that that is how God intended us to be. It is difficult to think loving your enemies is real commandment. With such high standards who goes to heaven?
Sure, emotion is a part of us and we do show those emotions. It is important not to allow them to let us to sin though. And if we do, which we have to improve the next time, not to.

As Jesus said, nothing is impossible. There are so many saints around us if we try to look into the Christ that is in them. The standard is high, because God is high compared to human, but God’s promise is that He will be with us. We need to allow God to mould us into the man and woman He wants us to be.
 
Last edited:
Maybe holiness is difficult to understand. Or another person’s holiness reveals our own depravity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top