Adam & Eve vs. Mary

  • Thread starter Thread starter jpjd
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I hereby apologize to my Catholic teachers and instructors from my days in Catholic grammar school, highschool, and beyond. Likewise, I apologize to my friends on this thread for having made the mistatements concerning the Blessed Virgin and concupiscence. Likewise, and most importantly I apologize to our Lord and Savior and his holy mother for the mistatement of the facts.
Hold the phone Pax. Consider this:

“From her conception Mary was was free from all motions of concupiscence. (Sent. communis)” Ludwig Ott, Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, p. 202 (1974).

The theological grade of certainty for this particular doctrine is as follows:

“Common teaching (sententia communis) is doctrine, which in itself belongs to the field of free opinions, but which is accepted by theologians generally.” Id. at 10.

Ott claimed, and the 1974 version of FCD held, that it is a doctrine that falls into the field of free opinion. Whether there has been teaching since that time that would change this - I don’t know of any, but there could be. Or it could be that Ott was simply wrong.

That being said, I believe it and would be untrue to my own conscience to deny it. But I don’t think you were totally out in left field.
 
Hold the phone Pax. Consider this:

“From her conception Mary was was free from all motions of concupiscence. (Sent. communis)” Ludwig Ott, Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, p. 202 (1974).

The theological grade of certainty for this particular doctrine is as follows:

“Common teaching (sententia communis) is doctrine, which in itself belongs to the field of free opinions, but which is accepted by theologians generally.” Id. at 10.

Ott claimed, and the 1974 version of FCD held, that it is a doctrine that falls into the field of free opinion. Whether there has been teaching since that time that would change this - I don’t know of any, but there could be. Or it could be that Ott was simply wrong.

That being said, I believe it and would be untrue to my own conscience to deny it. But I don’t think you were totally out in left field.
Thanks for the kind words, but I did tend to zone out on this one. The Lord knows how to keep me humble.
 
Thanks for the kind words, but I did tend to zone out on this one. The Lord knows how to keep me humble.
Well, from everything I’ve seen it looks like a permissible theological opinion.
 
OK, so to confirm what is being said here:
  1. Mary, as well as Adam & Eve, did not have concupiscence.
  2. Not having concupiscence means that they* could* sin, but Mary never personally sinned, but Adam & Eve (obviously) did sin.
Is this correct?
 
One small addition just so things are clear. Adam and Eve suffered from concupiscence subsequent to the fall.
 
I think we some times confuse concupiscence with the great gift of free-will.
I don’t think God predestined Mary to not sin, but rather knew how she would use her free-will. Adam and Eve also, although created without concupiscence, used their free-will to sin.
I think temptation and concupiscence are also different as Jesus was tempted by Satan.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top