Addition/Removal of Books in the Bible?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DannyGR
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DannyGR

Guest
I go to a Christian school, and noticed how the bible I use (KJV) has 66 books in it, and that some other versions had more and was curious to why that is. I’ve heard something about the printing companies removing them, and I’ve heard that Catholics “added” them. Also, did the earlier bibles have more than 66 books, or did they generally start out with more, and they were removed for other reasons?

Thanks for the answers ahead of time! 🙂
 
I go to a Christian school, and noticed how the bible I use (KJV) has 66 books in it, and that some other versions had more and was curious to why that is. I’ve heard something about the printing companies removing them, and I’ve heard that Catholics “added” them. Also, did the earlier bibles have more than 66 books, or did they generally start out with more, and they were removed for other reasons?

Thanks for the answers ahead of time! 🙂
Hi DannyGR, welcome to the forums.

Protestant bibles generally only have 66 books as Martin Luther removed 6 and a bit books(parts of Ester and Daniel etc.) in his translation of the Bible claiming that the later wisdom literature(the duterocanon) was not inspired. Catholics have had 73 books since we put the bible together in the 300s.
 
I go to a Christian school, and noticed how the bible I use (KJV) has 66 books in it, and that some other versions had more and was curious to why that is. I’ve heard something about the printing companies removing them, and I’ve heard that Catholics “added” them. Also, did the earlier bibles have more than 66 books, or did they generally start out with more, and they were removed for other reasons?

Thanks for the answers ahead of time! 🙂
It’s hard to say who really “added” or “removed” from the Bible (originally at least). For the first few hundred years different churches had different sets of books they considered canon. IIRC, it was at the Council of Nicaea where the early Church decided on what books definitively constitute the Bible. From that point on, the Bible consisted on 73 books. Only later, during the Protestant Reformation, did Protestant groups remove the 7 deuterocanonical books, along with parts of Esther and Daniel.
 
DannyGR,

The story of how the Bible came into being is long and complex. But remember “Complex does not always mean difficult”. You would do well to use the search function here on Catholic Answers to find threads that deal with how the Bible was put together. As a start, a list of the same books in the Catholic bible of today was published by the Council of Carthage in 395 A. D.
 
To the OP,

The bible came, in the first place, from the Catholics. Later, after that, then people started picking and choosing from what the Catholics had picked out. We started it, they changed it.
 
I go to a Christian school, and noticed how the bible I use (KJV) has 66 books in it, and that some other versions had more and was curious to why that is. I’ve heard something about the printing companies removing them, and I’ve heard that Catholics “added” them. Also, did the earlier bibles have more than 66 books, or did they generally start out with more, and they were removed for other reasons?

Thanks for the answers ahead of time! 🙂
Danny, Welcome to the CAF. The original KJV was translated and printed in 1611 and included or was an identical to the Catholic Bible that it was translated from “The Vulgate”
The Vulgate had used the “Septuagint” or LXX OT written in Greek

After the reformation Calvin and Co. decided to review the KJV and as for the source for the Old Testament decided to use the Masoretic version of the OT written in Hebrew instead, which is a LATER version to the LXX. (The Jews distrusted the LXX because it was used by those pesky Christians)
They in fact removed some books that gave credibility and weight to some of the teachings of the Catholic Church.
Since there were no surviving original manuscripts in Hebrew or Aramaic for the removed books of the Masoretic OT they also removed those books as “not inspired” and threw them out of the New KJV in 1885.

Now of Course God likes to play jokes on all of us and of course he played a major one on Calvin and Co.
When they discovered the scrolls in the Dead Sea in the 1940’s lo and behold there were fragments of some of the “removed” books in Aramaic.
Uh Oh and now?
Well there you have it, The Catholic Church accepted the LXX as authoritative because The Apostles and Jesus used it! It was the version that all the Jews of His time used except the Sanhedrin which of course only would use the one in Hebrew.
It is like what happened after Vatican II, the Church up to that point was using Latin for Mass and guess what, not many people could understand what was being said.
So the Church translated the Missal into all the languages where mass is celebrated. (Mass in Vernacular)
Same thing happened in Israel, they had been conquered by the Greeks first and the Romans second, Greek was the language the people used everyday, but when they went to the Sinagogue the Shabath and the Rabbi read the Torah no one understood any thing.
About 200 years before our Lord was born 70 odd scholars (Rabbis) decided to translate the Torah into Greek hence the name Septuagint or LXX for the number of “translators” that worked on the project. 😃
 
Thanks guys for the really informative replies! The Wizard mentioned maybe doing some more research, I’ll be sure to do that. I was been watching the forums for a while before joining it, tying to learn as much as I can. 🙂
 
I go to a Christian school, and noticed how the bible I use (KJV) has 66 books in it, and that some other versions had more and was curious to why that is. I’ve heard something about the printing companies removing them, and I’ve heard that Catholics “added” them. Also, did the earlier bibles have more than 66 books, or did they generally start out with more, and they were removed for other reasons?

Thanks for the answers ahead of time! 🙂
catholicapologetics.info/apologetics/protestantism/wbible.htm
 
I go to a Christian school, and noticed how the bible I use (KJV) has 66 books in it, and that some other versions had more and was curious to why that is. I’ve heard something about the printing companies removing them, and I’ve heard that Catholics “added” them. Also, did the earlier bibles have more than 66 books, or did they generally start out with more, and they were removed for other reasons?

Thanks for the answers ahead of time! 🙂
amazon.com/Why-Catholic-Bibles-are-Bigger/dp/1581880103

Peace,
Ed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top