Adopt Children AND Become A Nun?

  • Thread starter Thread starter yahwehsdaughter
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

yahwehsdaughter

Guest
Let’s say I adopt a child while single, have a male best friend as the second legal guardian (their father) although we are not married and don’t live together. When they are out of the house, can I become a nun? Would any of this be okay with the Church, or would it be sin/frowned upon?
 
I really think you should discern fully if you would like to be a nun or sister. There is traditionally a cut off age for entering the religious life. Do this before deciding to adopt. If you do become a nun or sister you can look at an order that works with children if you feel that is your calling.
 
Last edited:
There could be exceptions but I think the majority of the Orders wouldn’t accept someone with an adopted child as a full professed member (at least not in this time; in the Middle Ages there were widowed mothers who became nuns with their children but that was more of a social security measure).

You are much more likely to be accepted as an oblate/third order/secular religious, in other words, a secular person associated to the Order.
 
Last edited:
Some people think it’s wrong to purposely have a child outside of marriage because they think it will ruin the kids (even in adoption). I am not converted to the faith yet, so I don’t know all the rules about marriage and family. I just know this kind of thinking was very frowned upon when I was Protestant.
 
I want to be a cloistered nun 😊 the monastery I want to join would allow me to join until 45 (it’s my dream monastery ❤️). I emailed them my question and will wait for a response. If they say yes or no, I will take it as the will of God. I feel Mary has been leading me to go there through many prayers.
 
But you said adopt, not give birth. The difference is that in the former case, you didn’t commit the sin of fornication.
 
Thanks for this answer. I would rather be a nun, so if I can’t adopt, I will just join the order. I will always have spiritual children and will pray for the orphans 😊
 
I feel that I have been called… Is there a way to know that I have or haven’t? :confused:
 
Okay, I guess it’s not a sin. I was just checking, since some other Catholic friends I’ve talked to thought it was a very bad idea, and pretty much all my Christian friends (Protestant) thought it was near sinful. I just wanted to make sure I wasn’t thinking about doing anything wrong.
 
I want to be a cloistered nun 😊 the monastery I want to join would allow me to join until 45 (it’s my dream monastery ❤️). I emailed them my question and will wait for a response. If they say yes or no, I will take it as the will of God. I feel Mary has been leading me to go there through many prayers.
Please keep discerning this as raising a child can take you on a very different path. Being a cloistered monastery things to consider would be seeing your grown child and any grandchildren she or he may have and life that goes in that general direction. Once life gets in the way and children and relationships forged with them, its hard to walk away from that, even when they are grown and going about their own lives.
 
Last edited:
I see your point. I will just be a nun then. I don’t think I’m very resolute about the idea of having children. I’m just sad that more kids aren’t adopted, especially teenagers. I don’t know if I would be a good parent, but I feel sad and want to help them. Not really a good reason to adopt/raise children, I guess.

Thanks for the advice.
 
I know. I have prayed about this and asked for much intercession and have received signal graces that this is the place I’m supposed to go. I feel like your attitude is very hostile towards me and you are treating me like I’m dumb. I don’t know if that’s your intention, but you are coming off that way. I will find a spiritual director. I have been taking steps towards preparing for joining the monastery since I was sure I found the right one. If I am not accepted there, I will assume, “fine, it wasn’t God’s will, and all those things I thought were signs were not,” I will end up on a different path at that point, but I don’t see a reason to deviate from this so early just because you are sowing doubts about my decision. Thank you for your advice. I will find a spiritual director. Please pray for me in this, as I’m sure it will take some time to find one.
 
I wasn’t sure how to define myself since I’m technically not Catholic yet.

RCIA hasn’t started here yet, but I will be attending soon.
 
To my knowledge, there is no reason why a woman, who has been a mother, cannot become a religious (nun or sister) as long as her children are grown and able to live on their own and provide for themselves. It is by no means common, but there doesn’t seem to be any reason why not. Obviously, if she had been married, she would have to be widowed (or, hypothetically, granted a decree of nullity).

However, to do as the OP suggests, and adopt children, presumably see them through to adulthood, and then seek to enter a convent, that would both be highly out of the ordinary, and would raise a question that begs to be answered, “why are you adopting now, with the eye towards going into the convent in twenty-odd years?”.

If you feel as though you are truly called to motherhood, yet do not wish to marry, my advice would be to focus on that vocation, and what might happen twenty years from now, well, that’s a long way off. I would add that deliberately becoming a single parent has a huge set of challenges of its own. Ideally, children need both parents, husband and wife, in the same home.
 
I’m not going to discourage you, I hope! I know you really like the cloistered idea but please keep yourself open to other areas, too. Many nuns have hundreds of children they have raised through orphanages! It can satisfy the mothering urge as well as serving God…two blessings in one!

As an adopted child myself, parenting doesn’t end at adulthood. They are your children for life. I can’t even imagine the internal struggles one would face with being cloistered and never seeing or interacting with any grandchildren.

You have much thinking and asking questions ahead of you. The advice above has been excellent. Take your time and ask all your questions as you proceed…much good luck to you!
 
I wasn’t sure how to define myself since I’m technically not Catholic yet.

RCIA hasn’t started here yet, but I will be attending soon.
One step at at time, get through RCIA, you will then have several years before a religious organisation will look at your application. You can starting now, go and volunteer for an organisation that religious sisters work with. Examples are aged care, schooling, charity work, and more tricky social justice causes like modern day slavery.
 
Hi @yahwehsdaughter.
I think you should take one step at the time.
First you need to start RCIA, after you will get received in the Church. If I am not mistaken there is a rule that a new convert can not enter religious life for few years.
Also, adoption is not that easy. There are some requirements in terms of age difference between adoptee and adoptive parents (you said you feel bad about teenagers not being adopted but you sounds pretty young), background checks etc.
Also I find odd a father would ask you to be a guardian unless you are part of the extended family or in a serious relationship with him.
As a mom I second what other people said earlier. Once you have children (adopted or by birth) there is a bonding that is not ending when the child turns 18 and a cloistered nun would be unable to support a grown up son/daughter much because the obedience to the convent rules will be the priority.
I will keep you in my prayers, may you find what is your calling.
 
As a woman who lived in a monastery for just over two years, and then left and eventually became a mom, I can understand the deep calling to both that can sometimes be felt at the same time.

Adopting an older child means adopting a child who has known heart-wrenching loss and likely trauma. Most children in need of adoption still have at least one living parent!

To take a child like that into your home and create a family with them, with the intention of then walking out of their life completely as soon as they’re able to support themselves — no self-respecting social worker would allow you to adopt under those conditions! These children are going to be needing more support than most kids, and for a longer period of time.

Parenthood is for life. There are some rare souls who enter monasteries when their children are much older. One woman I know (mom and grandma, I think) lives in a Benedictine monastery as a claustral oblate. She wears the habit, but she can’t make vows, at least if I understand it correctly.

Pray and discern. But for now, get into that RCIA program.

God bless you!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top