An rock-solid, knock-out argument, against Calvinism

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic_Dude
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
actually we are taught that Christ died for those who will believe other wise how can Jesus death cover those who committed the unforgivable sin? such as Judas and the Pharisees and those already damned in the torment side of Sheol not Purgatory. that Christ Himself said was a chasm that was fixed so no one can cross sides and help the other. it is unforgivable and people will commit it! so therefore Christs death does not atone every ones sins nor does it cleanse all sins this is why in John 17 Christ did not intercede for the forgiveness of everyone’s sins but only those whom sins could be forgiven and those are the ones Father chose to give to Jesus Christ john 6:44. but also why John himself taught us not to pray for the forgiveness of someone whom we know committed this sin as it will be in vain just as it would be if Christ did so on the cross.1 John 5:16-18

Father sent His Son into the world that whoever believes in His Sons testimony will be saved.obviously not everyone is going to believe nor can they because Only the Lord opens the hearts of those who are not perishing to accept and believe the Gospel Message acts 16:13-15 Ephesians 2:8 Hebrews 12:2.and only those who Father gave His Son are drawn and given to Jesus to believe. so your argument is not rock solid. your works salvation is based on God foreknowing your choice for Him to make His own but according to God He chose people before the foundations were laid and before we did anything to make His choice to ensure election out of His own Good pleasure and Will but also based on the promise of Abraham and not of any descent or work of the Law. so God ensured to make sure election was sure of His own sovereign choice that the offspring of Abraham that is to be chosen for salvation were not blood descent nor the ones who depend on the law in general as both Hebrew and gentile have the moral law of God . if that were so then only the Hebrews would be chosen, just for them to be destroyed by God and all of us winding up in eternal darkness. because the Law was not given to us to save us but only show how much we need God for salvation as the law was never meant to perfect or depend upon but only God who is the author and perfecter of our faith and salvation.

so the elected offspring of Abraham is through Faith as He was accredited righteousness through Faith in God alone and not of any works of the law so this model stays the same for all those who are children of the promise. Hebrew and Gentile.

it still stands that the world is in total depravity and none of us can come to God freely because we only freely live by our nature. our nature is naturally rebellious against God and only seek evil continually Genesis 6:5 before the flood and after the flood Genesis 8:21. as you yourselves are not under God because even though you believe essential doctrines your secular doctrines deny Jesus Christ’s Deity and Call God a liar. this doctrine is the immaculate conception.

when you say that Jesus could only be perfect through a sinless created woman but according to God only He is Perfect. you also call God a liar because you claim that not all have sinned as God said we did because you believe that Mary was sinless, but in order for that to happen every body in Mary’s bloodline would have to be sinless as well which is passed down through Adam(image and likeness and nature). but if we go to her bloodline in Luke 3:23 it shows it goes all the way back to Adam who sinned and through Adam to Seth did Seth carry on the corrupt Image and Nature of his father seen in Genesis 5. so that doctrine is false and your assembly denies Jesus as God and calls Him a liar. and believe in a works based salvation that Denies Gods Sovereign Choice as stated through out the word of God.

here are some amongst many
Romans 9
Romans 8:29-30
Ephesians 1:5

none of this is unfair or unjust because what have we given to God that He owes us anything? God out of His choice could destroy all of us but promised that He would not when He proclaimed this to Noah and then Promised Abraham that through Him will a remnant being chosen by Faith from Hebrew and Gentile.
 
Purgatory is a false doctrine based on apocrypha’s that are not inspired works nor are taught or referenced in the bible by any prophet,Apostle or Jesus Christ.there are contradictions in the apocrypha’s so why would you trust it to be inspired works of God? let alone a doctrine that says if you continue in sin on earth you will be saved through fire after death.!? only satan wants you to believe that because once you are in fire after death there is no redemption/ this is temporary torment with eternal consequences,you are held in the torment side of Sheol bound for 2nd death when Christ returns… 1 John 3 states that all those who continue in deliberate sin on earth are not the children of God but of the devil so how can you be saved after death when judgment follows?.
we who are born of God by faith in Jesus Christ alone are made spiritually alive to live a life although not perfectly but strive against sin and seek spiritual good towards God continually.It is Jesus Christs Perfection and Righteousness that Father sees when He looks down from His throne and sees us. we can not be made perfect through ourselves nor can we merit our salvation through the observance of the law or man made traditions, sacraments, baptism but only Faith in Jesus works on the Cross. you do know that Jesus perfectly fulfilled Gods written Law so that we can cease from the law to gain approval correct? this is the same thing the Pharisees stumbled at because they sought salvation and righteousness through the law yet did not find it nor obtain it but only those who put there trust in Jesus Christ will inherit it as it is a free gift and nothing owed. what have you given God that He owes you anything?
is it rather you allow God to take over your lives to perform Good deeds in you that is the product of your already obtained free salvation and not something you do to merit what God does not owe you!! we do not deserve salvation but your leaders teach you faith plus works and not faith alone. while I am saved by my faith alone but the product of already receiving free salvation is to allow God to do great works in me through word and deed so He may receive glory and gather fruit from me.by doing so my service and His plan is accomplished in me during sanctification. do you not know that upon Faith in the True Jesus Christ and His works on the Cross that you receive salvation, son-ship, citizenship,priesthood,being co-heirs and a guarantee of being resurrected immortal by the Holy Spirit right at the moment you believe and God saves you?none of this is gained through the + but only through Faith that is given to you for free! Ephesians 2:8 Hebrews 12:2
all books of the OT were quoted in the NT Jesus Christ quoted Abel all the way to Zechariah son of Berekiah seen in Zechariah 1:1 who’s grandfather was Iddo. along with the Apostles constantly quoting from the OT scriptures show me once where these doctrines are quoted and mentioned by other prophets in the OT
 
contradictions of the satanic apocrypha’s

Wisdom 8:19,20 is another contradiction between the apocrypha and Scripture. “For I was a witty child, and had a good spirit. Yea rather, being good, I came into a body undefiled.” However, the Bible teaches that all are born with original sin. “Through one man’s offense judgment came to all men… by one man’s disobedience many were made sinners” (Romans 5:18, 19). “There is none righteous, no, not one” (Romans 3:10). The author of Wisdom believes he was an exception.
Condones the use of magic

Tobit 6:5-7, “Then the angel said to him: Take out the entrails of this fish, and lay up his heart, and his gall, and his liver for thee: for these are necessary for useful medicines. 6 And when he had done so, he roasted the flesh thereof, and they took it with them in the way: the rest they salted as much as might serve them, till they came to Rages the city of the Medes. 7 Then Tobias asked the angel, and said to him: I beseech thee, brother Azarias, tell me what remedies are these things good for, which thou hast bid me keep of the fish? 8 And the angel, answering, said to him: If thou put a little piece of its heart upon coals, the smoke thereof driveth away all kind of devils, either from man or from woman, so that they come no more to them.”
Is it true that the smoke from a fish’s heart, when burned, drives away evil spirits? Of course not. Such a superstitious teaching has no place in the word of God.
Teaches that forgiveness of sins is by human effort.

Salvation by works:

Tobit 4:11, “For alms deliver from all sin, and from death, and will not suffer the soul to go into darkness.”

Tobit 12:9, “For alms delivereth from death, and the same is that which purgeth away sins, and maketh to find mercy and life everlasting.”
We know from Scripture that alms (money or food, given to the poor or needy as charity) does not purge our sins. The blood of Christ is what cleanses us, not money or food given to poor people. “but if we walk in the light as He Himself is in the light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus His Son cleanses us from all sin,” (1 John 1:7).

Money as an offering for the sins of the dead:

2 Maccabbees 12:43, “And making a gathering, he sent twelve thousand drachms of silver to Jerusalem for sacrifice to be offered for the sins of the dead, thinking well and religiously concerning the resurrection.”
Can anyone truly accept that money isn’t offering for the sins of dead people? Such a superstitious and unbiblical concept has no place in Scripture.

Historical Errors
Wrong historical facts:

Judith 1:5, “Now in the twelfth year of his reign, Nabuchodonosor, king of the Assyrians, who reigned in Ninive the great city, fought against Arphaxad and overcame him.”

Baruch 6:2, “And when you are come into Babylon, you shall be there many years, and for a long time, even to seven generations: and after that I will bring you away from thence with peace.”

The book of Judith incorrectly says that Nebuchadnezzar was the king of the Assyrians when he was the king of the Babylonians.1
Baruch 6:2 says the Jews would serve in Babylon for seven generations where Jer. 25:11 says it was for 70 years. “And this whole land shall be a desolation and a horror, and these nations shall serve the king of Babylon seventy years.”

Conclusion
Obviously the apocrypha has serious problems. From magic, to salvation by works, to money as an offering for the sins of the dead, and blatant incorrect historical facts, it is full of false and unbiblical teachings. It isn’t inspired of God. Likewise, neither is the Roman Catholic Church, which has stated the Apocrypha is inspired. This shows the Roman Catholic Church is not the means by which God is communicating his truth to his people, that the Magisterium has erred greatly, and that it is infested with man’s false tradition, rather than God’s absolute truth.
 
Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also (1 John 2:23).

your assembly denies Jesus because you do not put your trust in His finished work on the Cross for your salvation, neither do you teach the full Deity of Christ.the essential doctrines of the Christian Church are true but are only used a front for you to be secretly taught demonic doctrine
 
Though I did not come up with this argument, I believe it is a definitive knock-out blow to Calvinism, particularly the Protestant notion of Limited Atonement and Penal Substitutionary Atonement. As many know, the letters in the word TULIP each stand for a particular aspect of Calvinism, all of which stand or fall together. The L, Limited Atonement (and thus Penal Substitution), can be proven false in just a few simple steps:
  1. The non-elect individual is commanded to believe in the Gospel or be damned.
  2. “The Gospel” = Jesus died for your sins.
  3. But according to Limited Atonement, Jesus didn’t really die for the non-elect.
  4. Thus, non-elect are told to believe Jesus died for them when He in fact did not.
  5. Thus, the non-elect is not legitimately given an option to accept, and thus cannot be damned because the offer wasn’t even genuine. He is being damned for not accepting God’s lie to him!
Conclusion: Limited Atonement is false, which in turn means Calvinism is false. 👍
#5 “God’s lie to him”? What in the world are you referencing?
 
Though I did not come up with this argument, I believe it is a definitive knock-out blow to Calvinism, particularly the Protestant notion of Limited Atonement and Penal Substitutionary Atonement. As many know, the letters in the word TULIP each stand for a particular aspect of Calvinism, all of which stand or fall together. The L, Limited Atonement (and thus Penal Substitution), can be proven false in just a few simple steps:
  1. The non-elect individual is commanded to believe in the Gospel or be damned.
  2. “The Gospel” = Jesus died for your sins.
  3. But according to Limited Atonement, Jesus didn’t really die for the non-elect.
  4. Thus, non-elect are told to believe Jesus died for them when He in fact did not.
  5. Thus, the non-elect is not legitimately given an option to accept, and thus cannot be damned because the offer wasn’t even genuine. He is being damned for not accepting God’s lie to him!
Conclusion: Limited Atonement is false, which in turn means Calvinism is false. 👍
Abridged Conclusion: Calvinism = believing in the wrong JC or JC-founded Church.

http://www.galleryhistoricalfigures.com/images/JohnCalvin_Rt.jpg http://www.divinerevelations.info/documents/jesus_pictures/jesus_060.jpg

TULIP is PUTIL. < (Second P pronounced as Ph or F).

PS: Great example of deductive reasoning cited Catholic Dude. :clapping:
 
Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also (1 John 2:23).

your assembly denies Jesus because you do not put your trust in His finished work on the Cross for your salvation, neither do you teach the full Deity of Christ.the essential doctrines of the Christian Church are true but are only used a front for you to be secretly taught demonic doctrine
His “work” was not finished just by being crucified. He finished the reason why he was crucified after his ascension back to his Father Heb. 7:12.
 
I would like to cheerfully add to the original argument :):

If everyone is commanded to believe in the Gospel (that is: Jesus Christ died to pay for your sins), then the non-elect are commanded to believe a lie.
“that is: Jesus Christ died to pay for your sins” is not true. Further everyone to save himself from God’s wrath must obey what the message requires regarding the sin of Jesus Christ’s murder.
 
Jack, Welcome to CAF. I hope we can answer your questions. As to your question to me: Yes, there is abundant scriptural support that we are saved by Faith but enter eternal life by good works and mercy.

Lets start with Matthew’s Gospel: If this isn’t enough for you, we can expand to other passages from other New testament authors

Matthew 7:
21 “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father in heaven.
22 Many will say to me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name? Did we not drive out demons in your name? Did we not do mighty deeds in your name?’
23 Then I will declare to them solemnly, ‘I never knew you. Depart from me, you evildoers.’
24 “Everyone who listens to these words of mine and acts on them will be like a wise man who built his house on rock.
25 The rain fell, the floods came, and the winds blew and buffeted the house. But it did not collapse; it had been set solidly on rock.
26 And everyone who listens to these words of mine but does not act on them will be like a fool who built his house on sand.
27 The rain fell, the floods came, and the winds blew and buffeted the house. And it collapsed and was completely ruined.”
Matthew 19:
16 Now someone approached him and said, “Teacher, what good must I do to gain eternal life?”
17 He answered him, “Why do you ask me about the good? There is only One who is good. If you wish to enter into life, keep the commandments.”
18 He asked him, “Which ones?” And Jesus replied, " ‘You shall not kill; you shall not commit adultery; you shall not steal; you shall not bear false witness;
19 honor your father and your mother’; and ‘you shall love your neighbor as yourself.’”
20 The young man said to him, “All of these I have observed. What do I still lack?”
21 Jesus said to him, “If you wish to be perfect, go, sell what you have and give to (the) poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me.”
22 When the young man heard this statement, he went away sad, for he had many possessions.

matthew 25:
31 “When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, he will sit upon his glorious throne,
32 and all the nations will be assembled before him. And he will separate them one from another, as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats.
33 He will place the sheep on his right and the goats on his left.
34 Then the king will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father. Inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.
35 For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, a stranger and you welcomed me,
36 naked and you clothed me, ill and you cared for me, in prison and you visited me.’
37 Then the righteous will answer him and say, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink?
38 When did we see you a stranger and welcome you, or naked and clothe you?
39 When did we see you ill or in prison, and visit you?’
40 And the king will say to them in reply, ‘Amen, I say to you, whatever you did for one of these least brothers of mine, you did for me.’
41 Then he will say to those on his left, ‘Depart from me, you accursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.
42 For I was hungry and you gave me no food, I was thirsty and you gave me no drink,
43 a stranger and you gave me no welcome, naked and you gave me no clothing, ill and in prison, and you did not care for me.’
44 Then they will answer and say, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or naked or ill or in prison, and not minister to your needs?’
45 He will answer them, ‘Amen, I say to you, what you did not do for one of these least ones, you did not do for me.’
46 And these will go off to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life.”
And isn’t it true that He says there are very few ever who ever find out what the small narrow door into God’s kingdom actually is?
 
Natural man always resists the Holy Spirit. It is only by the power of the Holy Spirit that a man can be changed to be pliant to the Spirit of God. The alternative to this is the idea that man does not need prevenient grace - Pelagianism. But I think you know that.
Your position is a Cart before the horse concept. The message must first be heard and then obeyed prior to receiving the gift of God’s spirit. There are no exceptions.
 
#5 “God’s lie to him”? What in the world are you referencing?
According to the argument as presented, it’s the notions in #1 and #2: that the non-elect is commanded to believe in the Gospel or be damned, and that Jesus died for his sins.

I’m not certain that, according to Limited Atonement, the non-elect are considered included in the offer of salvation. (The problem comes, of course, in determining who the elect are, anyway. ;))

The argument can be defeated, it seems, by modifying #2:

“2) ‘The Gospel’ = Jesus died for the sins of the elect”.

Doesn’t that, then, stick with the notion of limited atonement and yet defeat the argument presented here? :confused:
 
Though I did not come up with this argument, I believe it is a definitive knock-out blow to Calvinism, particularly the Protestant notion of Limited Atonement and Penal Substitutionary Atonement. As many know, the letters in the word TULIP each stand for a particular aspect of Calvinism, all of which stand or fall together. The L, Limited Atonement (and thus Penal Substitution), can be proven false in just a few simple steps:
  1. The non-elect individual is commanded to believe in the Gospel or be damned.
  2. “The Gospel” = Jesus died for your sins.
  3. But according to Limited Atonement, Jesus didn’t really die for the non-elect.
  4. Thus, non-elect are told to believe Jesus died for them when He in fact did not.
  5. Thus, the non-elect is not legitimately given an option to accept, and thus cannot be damned because the offer wasn’t even genuine. He is being damned for not accepting God’s lie to him!
Conclusion: Limited Atonement is false, which in turn means Calvinism is false. 👍
I’m not sure. In Calvinism the non-elect aren’t given the grace to believe to begin with. Double-predestination means God’s already damned them. Our wills, according to them, have nothing to do with our salvation-or loss of it.
 
According to the argument as presented, it’s the notions in #1 and #2: that the non-elect is commanded to believe in the Gospel or be damned, and that Jesus died for his sins.

I’m not certain that, according to Limited Atonement, the non-elect are considered included in the offer of salvation. (The problem comes, of course, in determining who the elect are, anyway. ;))

The argument can be defeated, it seems, by modifying #2:

“2) ‘The Gospel’ = Jesus died for the sins of the elect”.

Doesn’t that, then, stick with the notion of limited atonement and yet defeat the argument presented here? :confused:
1&2 are nonsensical nonsequiturs. The murder of Jesus Christ was not a direct benefit. For 1&2 to have any possibility of being valid. A substantiated argument that proves Acts 7:52, “And now you have betrayed and murdered Him” to be a false statement must be presented. The soteriological problem that you fail to identify is a misinterpretation of the word atonement. The contemporary soteriological error is assuming that atonement means resolved but its actual meaning is adjustment. By the murder of Jesus Christ a sin was added that is unilaterally accountable. Only by the murder of Jesus Christ has the law of God been modified, i.e. atoned, for making a change to it. His crucifixion was for no other purpose.
 
1&2 are nonsensical nonsequiturs.
The question is, however, whether they accurately describe the Calvinist belief system. 😉
Only by the murder of Jesus Christ has the law of God been modified, i.e. atoned, for making a change to it.
Umm… pardon? No, that’s not correct – the ‘deficiency’, as it were, wasn’t in God’s law, but in humanity’s response to God’s covenant. That’s what required the atonement! 👍

Regardless, that’s not the matter at hand. The question here is whether the OP’s construction validly represents what Calvinists believe (and therefore, whether it accurately describes a logical contradiction within that framework).
 
The question is, however, whether they accurately describe the Calvinist belief system. 😉

Umm… pardon? No, that’s not correct – the ‘deficiency’, as it were, wasn’t in God’s law, but in humanity’s response to God’s covenant. That’s what required the atonement! 👍

Regardless, that’s not the matter at hand. The question here is whether the OP’s construction validly represents what Calvinists believe (and therefore, whether it accurately describes a logical contradiction within that framework).
Hummm Pardon? See Heb. 7:12. Calvinism is debated 24/7 and so are all other contemporary soteriological assumptions. Pitting one bad apple against another bad apple and you make something good? If a soteriological procedure that was not deficient preexisted Jesus’ crucifixion; what in the world was he crucified for? Not only was there a change of the priesthood made upon the Lord’s ascension the law was also changed too. Your defense, “but in humanity’s response to God’s covenant = That’s what required the atonement” , but by the crucifixion, resurrection and ascension of Jesus Christ an entirely new covenant has been established by law. Calvinism has none of that and so does every other church’s soteriological paradigm.
 
Hummm Pardon? See Heb. 7:12.
Yes, but the “change in law” wasn’t the reason for Christ’s sacrifice!
Pitting one bad apple against another bad apple and you make something good?
Hmm… if I’m not mistaken, I’d think you were saying that Catholic soteriology is a ‘bad apple’…? :hmmm:
If a soteriological procedure that was not deficient preexisted Jesus’ crucifixion; what in the world was he crucified for?
For our sins: “By his obedience unto death, Jesus accomplished the substitution of the suffering Servant, who ‘makes himself an offering for sin’, when 'he bore the sin of many”, and who “shall make many to be accounted righteous’, for ‘he shall bear their iniquities’. Jesus atoned for our faults and made satisfaction for our sins to the Father.” (CCC, #615)
 
Yes, but the “change in law” wasn’t the reason for Christ’s sacrifice!

Hmm… if I’m not mistaken, I’d think you were saying that Catholic soteriology is a ‘bad apple’…? :hmmm:

For our sins: “By his obedience unto death, Jesus accomplished the substitution of the suffering Servant, who ‘makes himself an offering for sin’, when 'he bore the sin of many”, and who “shall make many to be accounted righteous’, for ‘he shall bear their iniquities’. Jesus atoned for our faults and made satisfaction for our sins to the Father.” (CCC, #615)
Catholic soteriology isn’t the only one that is bad it is unilateral condition of all contemporary religions.
 
1&2 are nonsensical nonsequiturs. The murder of Jesus Christ was not a direct benefit. For 1&2 to have any possibility of being valid. A substantiated argument that proves Acts 7:52, “And now you have betrayed and murdered Him” to be a false statement must be presented. The soteriological problem that you fail to identify is a misinterpretation of the word atonement. The contemporary soteriological error is assuming that atonement means resolved but its actual meaning is adjustment. By the murder of Jesus Christ a sin was added that is unilaterally accountable. Only by the murder of Jesus Christ has the law of God been modified, i.e. atoned, for making a change to it. His crucifixion was for no other purpose.
Would you mind spelling out the mechanism at work in this soteriological model? How did the murder of Jesus Christ effect a change in God’s law?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top