D
Debora123
Guest
Huh?I dont recall anyone saying you had to.
Huh?I dont recall anyone saying you had to.
I dont recall anyone saying you had to believe in an actual antichrist.Huh?
I have a problem with this. I see the quote from Karl Keating, but does the Church really teach we are free to believe or not believe the literal interpretation of the stories/miracles in the Old testament?Well I never said the OT is just stories you can choose to believe or disbelieve. At least not like that. I meant we are free to believe or disbelieve them in their literal form.
Here’s a reliable source using the OT story of Jonah and the whale as an example:
Just read the forward in The End of the Present World and the Mysteries of the Future Life. I think Vatican II does not want to offend other faiths that prevent conversion. Telling the Jews that the messiah they await is the antichrist is offensive. Maybe some guilt for the Holocaust.Interesting. How did that change?
That’s why we specifically refer to the OT here. What you describe above is the NT. Totally different.I have a problem with this. I see the quote from Karl Keating, but does the Church really teach we are free to believe or not believe the literal interpretation of the stories/miracles in the Old testament?
I think this is dangerous ground.
Are we not then free to believe or not believe the replication of the bread or Lazarus’ resurrection, Christ’s resurrection, the Ascension, walking on water etc? Those all have spiritual meanings, but if we are free to ignore the literal, we are in trouble.
The OT is part of the Bible., so I’m not sure why the way we treat the OT should be different from the way we treat the NT. Is it because the people were less sophisticated in OT days?That’s why we specifically refer to the OT here. What you describe above is the NT. Totally different.
Karl Keating is the man who founded CAF. No, his works are not heresy. Yes, we, as Catholics are free to believe in the OT stories in a literal OR allegorical way.
Well, of course Karl isn’t infallible. What he said regarding the OT isn’t something he “made up.” He merely only reaffirmed what is already a Catholic stance.The OT is part of the Bible., so I’m not sure why the way we treat the OT should be different from the way we treat the NT. Is it because the people were less sophisticated in OT days?
I know who Karl Keating is and as much as I respect his knowledge and work, he is not infallible, but that doesn’t mean I am calling him a heretic either.
I am trying to figure out how much consensus there is on this in the world of Catholic theology and what the Church specifically teaches.
I’ll search the forum to see if a similar topic was discussed on a recent thread. I feel like there might have been a recent thread on something similar. If not, I’ll start one. I’ll also do some research on this.
I was never taught this in my instruction, so I’ll check with my SD as well.
This is very disturbing to me.![]()
I already have an appointment.Well, of course Karl isn’t infallible. What he said regarding the OT isn’t something he “made up.” He merely only reaffirmed what is already a Catholic stance.
If you are struggling with this, then yes, speaking with your SD will help. Perhaps he will be better at explaining this to you.
I already have an appointment.![]()