have any of your fellow seminarians converted to the RCC and/or EO?
Though I mentioned a spat, that was just the impetus to leave the LCMS. I had started the class on the professor’s side on an issue, and by the end of the class, I railed against that same position.
This is not that spat, but it did shake my confidence in Lutheranism: One year, I wrote a paper on the doctrine of
theosis in Luther for a history class. The professor of that class loved it. A systematics professor (both were teaching classes on Luther) spent 20 minutes of a 50 minute class railing against the notion that Luther taught anything approaching
theosis. To the history professor, Luther was a Catholic in exile, who was pushed to certain positions by the polemics and politics of his day (this same professor chastised the class for making Reformation Day a day of celebration, when it should be a day of mourning, a common theme in the history department—another history professor explicitly said that Lutherans should regard themselves as Catholics in exile and recognize the Pope as our rightful churchly authority and work towards reconciliation with him). To the systematics professor, however, Luther was wholly Protestant and his changing theology reflected his maturing thought and had nothing to do with external forces (he also hated JDDJ and any ecumenical effort with the Catholic Church).
Normally, a difference of interpretation of Luther isn’t particularly important, but when his views are specifically referenced in the BoC, they are.
The other big issue was ecclesiology, though that was always present. The biggest weakness in Lutheran theology is, and always has been, ecclesiology. While the Scandinavian Lutherans can make a case for themselves from an Anglican or perhaps even Orthodox understanding, I do not think any other Lutheran group really can. Certainly not the Reformers themselves.
[I should note that my history professors are all marvellous. Unfortunately, it is the opinion of my last LCMS pastor that those professors keep quiet and don’t publish near as much as others in order to keep their job.]
A couple years ago, an Orthodox priest in town relayed that he was in the process of receiving a pastor at a Lutheran church in town, and an alumnus of my school, into the Orthodox Church. He also said that he regularly gets a lot of visitors and converts from students or alumni from my school, overwhelmingly those who have done most of their course work under the history faculty.
Addendum: When I was on campus more, I heard of a few alumni crossing the Tiber, but I haven’t heard any specific reports recently. Of course, I live on the opposite end of town from school and where most of my classmates live.