Application for Nullity Issues

  • Thread starter Thread starter SuzyWong
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SuzyWong

Guest
I am 60 years old and in RCIA program. I have applied for nullity from my former spouse. I married young. It has been over 35 years since we divorced. I have had no contact with him or his side of the family for 25 years. My situation is that as it is necessary to contact a respondent, my former spouse has not been heard from for 4 years by our children. He is not only violent, mentally unstable, but has committed crimes and the belief of our children is that he has left the country (under false documents). Due to his violent nature, if I were able to contact him, I would not feel safe in doing so. If the Diocese were ever in some miracle, able to reach him, he would in no way participate in the question/answer process. He suffers from delusions and mental illness. Some of his family members also suffer from mental illness and have been treated for such. Normally the Church will not involve the children from the former marriage. I am not certain that I will ever have the opportunity to have an annulment granted by the Church - because no one seems to know the whereabouts of my former spouse. It is the Diocese duty to locate my former spouse/respondent to notify him of my application. Therefore, I suppose that I will not ever be able to receive Eucharist nor have my present marriage (a very good one) of 30 years blessed in the Church. I feel at a loss. I would appreciate your thoughts and prayers.
 
I am 60 years old and in RCIA program. I have applied for nullity from my former spouse. I married young. It has been over 35 years since we divorced. I have had no contact with him or his side of the family for 25 years. My situation is that as it is necessary to contact a respondent, my former spouse has not been heard from for 4 years by our children. He is not only violent, mentally unstable, but has committed crimes and the belief of our children is that he has left the country (under false documents). Due to his violent nature, if I were able to contact him, I would not feel safe in doing so. If the Diocese were ever in some miracle, able to reach him, he would in no way participate in the question/answer process. He suffers from delusions and mental illness. Some of his family members also suffer from mental illness and have been treated for such. Normally the Church will not involve the children from the former marriage. I am not certain that I will ever have the opportunity to have an annulment granted by the Church - because no one seems to know the whereabouts of my former spouse. It is the Diocese duty to locate my former spouse/respondent to notify him of my application. Therefore, I suppose that I will not ever be able to receive Eucharist nor have my present marriage (a very good one) of 30 years blessed in the Church. I feel at a loss. I would appreciate your thoughts and prayers.
Please talk to an actual priest about this matter. They know better than random interent strangers.

However, death in absentia occurs after 7 years. Has he really not been heard from by anyone? Is there any “real” evidenence that he went to another country? If he’s been gone for 4…he’s well on his way to that and you or your children could have him legally declared dead.
 
If the Diocese were ever in some miracle, able to reach him, he would in no way participate in the question/answer process. He suffers from delusions and mental illness.
You, the petitioner, do not contact him. The tribunaL handles that. All you must do is provide what information you have. They make a good faith effort to contact him. If they cannot find him or if he declines participation, the nullity process proceeds without him.
I am not certain that I will ever have the opportunity to have an annulment granted by the Church - because no one seems to know the whereabouts of my former spouse.
Participation by the former spouse is not necessary.
Code:
Therefore, I suppose that I will not ever be able to receive Eucharist nor have my present marriage (a very good one) of 30 years blessed in the Church.  I feel at a loss.  I would appreciate your thoughts and prayers.
It does not necessarily follow that your petition will be denied because the ex cannot be located or refuses to participate.

If you and/or he were unbaptized, there is also the possibility of the dissolution of the bond via the Pauline or Petrine Privilege.

Please take things one step at a time.
 
Thank you so much 1ke and purplesunshine. You give me hope where I had little. My priest is looking into this issue for me. 🙂
 
We also have a group here that may be helpful with a Canon lawyer. The above advice is correct. There is a standard protocol as to what is done in each situation to show a “good faith attempt” and your Tribunal/priest/advocate will be able to help you with this. Basically the reason all of this is done up front is so a vindictive ex-spouse who is mentally unstable (or for that matter one who actually has been wronged) cannot come back after the fact and say they did not have a chance to defend the Sacrament and have the case appealed and drawn out. It protects both parties, the Sacrament, and the Church.

Please have faith, this is not the process it was 35 years ago. Feel free to use that link in my signature block.
 
Thank you JoanofArc2008. Not that it matters in the nullity process nor in contacting the respondent but I believe that I neglected to mention that both I and the respondent are non-Catholics, although I am in the RCIA program. The religious status of the respondent is unknown as is where the respondent resides, or even if the respondent is still living. :eek: Both the respondent and I have been re-married (not in the Catholic church) for 30 years. Still, I understand the need for the respondent to have an opportunity to voice an opinion of the nullity that I am seeking. And I appreciate your explanation regarding the appeal process, which I was unaware of prior to your post. 🙂
 
Suzy,

I suggest getting a copy of the book Annulment: The Wedding That Was by MIchael Smith Foster. It might be helpful to you.
 
Thank you JoanofArc2008. Not that it matters in the nullity process nor in contacting the respondent but I believe that I neglected to mention that both I and the respondent are non-Catholics, although I am in the RCIA program. The religious status of the respondent is unknown as is where the respondent resides, or even if the respondent is still living. :eek: Both the respondent and I have been re-married (not in the Catholic church) for 30 years. Still, I understand the need for the respondent to have an opportunity to voice an opinion of the nullity that I am seeking. And I appreciate your explanation regarding the appeal process, which I was unaware of prior to your post. 🙂
No problem - you are correct - the way that it would matter if one of you is a Catholic is if there was a lack of form issue. I am going to ask this just to be sure. Are you absolutely 100% sure that he was not baptized Catholic as an infant and then just did not practice. I am just making sure because that would most likely save you going through the formal process if you can find a copy of his baptismal certificate - which is not always impossible. Now if as purple sunshine stated you all think there is a good chance he is dead then there is a procedure for that under Canon law as well. That is more a question for the Canon lawyer.
 
I am 60 years old and in RCIA program. I have applied for nullity from my former spouse. I married young. It has been over 35 years since we divorced. I have had no contact with him or his side of the family for 25 years. My situation is that as it is necessary to contact a respondent, my former spouse has not been heard from for 4 years by our children.

…
, I suppose that I will not ever be able to receive Eucharist nor have my present marriage (a very good one) of 30 years blessed in the Church. I feel at a loss. I would appreciate your thoughts and prayers.
there seems to be a lot of misinformation and wrong assumptions here.
Please sit down again with the priest is receiving you into the Church and go over all of this with him, as it appears the parish has not given you all the information you need.

First, you don’t need an annulment at all unless you have remarried in the meantime, or plan on marrying again. Being divorced is not by itself a barrier to entering the Church and receiving sacraments.

The annulment investigation can proceed even if he cannot be found, or does not participate or cooperate. By itself those circumstances will not ruin your case. Make sure the advocate who is working with you on the annulment knows all your concerns and his history as well. Put all of what you have said in your own testimony so it goes on the record.

the grounds for annulment will be based on conditions that pertained at the time of the marriage, not on what happened afterward, unless these things (such as is violence, mental illness etc) shed light on the circumstances that existed at the time you got married.

You deserve some more peace of mind and counsel on this, please see your priest again. Most of these matters turn out to be far easier than first appears, and move faster than you anticipate. the first thing to look at is whether or not your first marriage followed proper form (the laws of the CAtholic Church) because if not, that proceeding is much simpler and faster than a full annulment investigation.

Talk to your priest again.

Welcome home.
 
I am 60 years old and in RCIA program. I have applied for nullity from my former spouse. I married young. It has been over 35 years since we divorced. I have had no contact with him or his side of the family for 25 years. My situation is that as it is necessary to contact a respondent, my former spouse has not been heard from for 4 years by our children. He is not only violent, mentally unstable, but has committed crimes and the belief of our children is that he has left the country (under false documents). Due to his violent nature, if I were able to contact him, I would not feel safe in doing so. If the Diocese were ever in some miracle, able to reach him, he would in no way participate in the question/answer process. He suffers from delusions and mental illness. Some of his family members also suffer from mental illness and have been treated for such. Normally the Church will not involve the children from the former marriage. I am not certain that I will ever have the opportunity to have an annulment granted by the Church - because no one seems to know the whereabouts of my former spouse. It is the Diocese duty to locate my former spouse/respondent to notify him of my application. Therefore, I suppose that I will not ever be able to receive Eucharist nor have my present marriage (a very good one) of 30 years blessed in the Church. I feel at a loss. I would appreciate your thoughts and prayers.
You don’t contact him. The Diocese does. If he fails to respond or it comes back as “refused” the Diocese proceeds without him, at some point. Each diocese is different on how long or how many attempts, but they send the letter(s). Your diocese can explain this in the absence of any ability to find him. But they will proceed without his participation.

Why do you think you cannot be granted an annulment?

Granted this is from the Diocese in Minnesota but its FAQ’s on annulment are recommended.

stcdio.org/offices/tribunal/annulments/annulment-faqs/70-will-my-former-spouse-be-contacted.html
 
there seems to be a lot of misinformation and wrong assumptions here.
Please sit down again with the priest is receiving you into the Church and go over all of this with him, as it appears the parish has not given you all the information you need.

First, you don’t need an annulment at all unless you have remarried in the meantime, or plan on marrying again. Being divorced is not by itself a barrier to entering the Church and receiving sacraments.

The annulment investigation can proceed even if he cannot be found, or does not participate or cooperate. By itself those circumstances will not ruin your case. Make sure the advocate who is working with you on the annulment knows all your concerns and his history as well. Put all of what you have said in your own testimony so it goes on the record.

the grounds for annulment will be based on conditions that pertained at the time of the marriage, not on what happened afterward, unless these things (such as is violence, mental illness etc) shed light on the circumstances that existed at the time you got married.

You deserve some more peace of mind and counsel on this, please see your priest again. Most of these matters turn out to be far easier than first appears, and move faster than you anticipate. the first thing to look at is whether or not your first marriage followed proper form (the laws of the CAtholic Church) because if not, that proceeding is much simpler and faster than a full annulment investigation.

Talk to your priest again.

Welcome home.
She is re-married, neither were Catholic. She described this in some of the later posts - you probably both hit submit around the same time 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top