I agree. Nilla pudding is also called “mock banana pudding” but uses no bananas. Nanna pudding uses bananas. Two different things that may taste similar…but aren’t!
It’s a southern dialect. My grandmother used to make ‘niller puddin’ from the recipe on the box of nilla wafers. Then one day when I was working a buffet at a country club in the Blue Ridge mountains, one of the bus boys proclaimed, “I’m gonna eat me a big ole bowl of nanner puddin”, and I thought to myself, “That ain’t nanner puddin, that’s niller puddin”.
… I would consider “niller” pudding the banana flavored pudding from a box with crunched up ‘Nilla wafers’ in it. But Nanner Pudding is banana pudding… with sliced bananas in it!
If you can combine either niller or nanner pudd’n with nilla wafers or nanner slices, there are four combinations: niller-nilla, niller-nanner, nanner-nilla, and nanner-nanner.
… …
Nanu-Nanu!
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
DISCLAIMER: Catholic Answers has turned over the archive to Catholic-Questions.org and no longer owns, manages, or moderates the forums. For additional apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.