Are we supposed to confess all our sins since baptism or just since gaining knowledge about God's Commandements?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FrancescaMaria
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

FrancescaMaria

Guest
Hello,
I was baptized as a baby in a Protestant church, but was raised atheist in a country where any religious education was forbidden. When I was confirmed and received first Communion in America, I was not advised to make my first Confession at the time. When I did come to my first Confession about 6 months after regularly receiving the Communion, the priest instructed me to confess what I want to work on now (i.e. now that I know there is a loving God and what his Commandments are - and I had no other instruction on the sacrament at the time) and to go from there, so I did. I have been practicing for almost 25 years now, but now I am hearing that everyone needs to make their first confession of all their sins since baptism, not conversion, so I have doubts. I do not think I could remember my childhood and teenage sins now, much less to assess how my conscience was developed at the time. Also, as my conscience gradually developed, I am now confessing things that I did not consider serious enough (and probably did not confess) during the initial years of my journey. I would appreciate any help. I used to love my spiritual journey, but I have doubts now that I might have been in a state of sin all this time, and it really scares me. Thank you!
 
If possible we should confess all our sins since baptism at a first confession. Even if someone was not a person of faith prior to their conversion they would still have known right from wrong at least in a general sense and were capable of being culpable for sins.

However in a case like yours where decades passed between baptism and first confession, it can be quite difficult to remember everything. In such cases the person just confesses to the best of their knowledge and should later on they remember something they can confess it at that time. Remember, while confession of venial sins is always recommended it is not necessary to call to mind every single venial sin from the past decades.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top