Ask a Montessorian

  • Thread starter Thread starter HumbleThinker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

HumbleThinker

Guest
I need practice explaining Montessori to parents and those in the community and you need to hear about Montessori education, so please ask me any and every question that you have about the Montessori approach to education. Thanks for the help! 🙂
 
I need practice explaining Montessori to parents and those in the community and you need to hear about Montessori education, so please ask me any and every question that you have about the Montessori approach to education. Thanks for the help! 🙂
One question you might be getting is: “Was Maria Montessori an occultist?” She did have some association with Madame Blavatsky’s group in India in the early 1900’s, though this cached article via Google (from what looks like a Catholic-oriented site) pretty much debunks that rumor:
webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:py-Ew-rCLesJ:www.womenofgrace.com/blog/%3Fp%3D16584+&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
 
Can you give me a quick rundown of what differentiates Montessori education? We have one relatively close by that a good friend works at but I’ve never looked into it that much (mostly because I doubt we can afford it but who knows what will happen before my oldest starts K).
 
Can you give me a quick rundown of what differentiates Montessori education? We have one relatively close by that a good friend works at but I’ve never looked into it that much (mostly because I doubt we can afford it but who knows what will happen before my oldest starts K).
Hate to hear about the cost being prohibitive. There are many schools that do try to cater to those who aren’t in the upper middle class with mechanisms such as scaled tuition, but unfortunately the high priced ones are especially prominent here in America. Which is very unfortunate because Montessori’s original Children’s Houses were for abjectly poor children, though the first one at least was effectively a public school funded in large part by the Ministry of Housing.

The biggest point that differentiates Montessori is that it is an aide to life, equipping children to develop all of their abilities to their own individual potentials. To do this, there is a unique level of freedom allowed to the children to choose their “work.” It is not the heavy, teacher-directed control of traditional forms of education, but it is also not the nearly absolute freedom of some other “progressive” forms of education. True, inner freedom is developed, not given, which requires the exercising of discipline on the part of the child, which itself requires limits to be set.

Another major point is that children not only can but desire to do “work” at a young age, a term coined out of respect for the child’s actions. Montessori work has much of the characteristics of play that make it developmentally powerful for young children; it is not to be confused with the drudgery that is traditionally identified with the term “work.”

From a logistical standpoint, Montessori classrooms have large adult-to-child ratios (the original Children’s Houses were 30-40+ children for a guide and assistant). They also have a mixed age grouping. A primary classroom for instance is 3-6, while lower elementary is 6-9. The materials in the Children’s House are sized for the child to encourage their proper use.

A final important point is that the classroom is literally a children’s house, not a teacher’s classroom: it is made for children to work in, live in, while the guide is simply there to guide them in properly interacting with their environment. When the children are truly engaged, the guide can effectively disappear as an active participant and do her real work of observation.

This is just the cliff notes version as you requested, but there are so many more points I could bring up and more detail that I could go into each point given here. Let me know if you would like more information. 🙂
 
My daughter went to Montessori school K-4th (we couldn’t afford it anymore) and excelled in everything. She went to Catholic school for 5th grade and it was a super, major, extreme disaster; she ended up failing half her classes, even though I knew she could do it. She never did well in school after that and ended up dropping out of high school in her senior year because she would not have had enough credits to graduate. Do you have any insight what happened? Sometimes I wondered if the Montessori school over embellished her grades and progress, but she had high test scores and effortlessly learned to read by her 5th birthday. I had a lot of confidence in the Montessori Method, but in her case, it did not seem to translate outside of that environment. I would like to try my grandson in a Montessori school, but I don’t want a repeat of what happened to his mother. 🤷
 
My daughter went to Montessori school K-4th (we couldn’t afford it anymore) and excelled in everything. She went to Catholic school for 5th grade and it was a super, major, extreme disaster; she ended up failing half her classes, even though I knew she could do it. She never did well in school after that and ended up dropping out of high school in her senior year because she would not have had enough credits to graduate. Do you have any insight what happened? Sometimes I wondered if the Montessori school over embellished her grades and progress, but she had high test scores and effortlessly learned to read by her 5th birthday. I had a lot of confidence in the Montessori Method, but in her case, it did not seem to translate outside of that environment. I would like to try my grandson in a Montessori school, but I don’t want a repeat of what happened to his mother. 🤷
I would only be guessing at what her specific circumstance was. In general, studies have found that Montessori children transitioning into traditional school perform on par and often better than their non-Montessori peers on various academic and non-academic measures. This of course won’t be true for all children.

To use an analogy, think of a butterfly in its four stages. A caterpillar cannot eat the same things or live the same life as it will when it becomes a butterfly; eating what it is meant to eat and do what it is meant to do as a caterpillar can only lead to it being a better butterfly, though it of course still needs to eat and act like a butterfly for it to grow optimally. Children have stages just like a butterfly, each with its own specific needs. A Montessori primary classroom (optimally) meets the needs of each child at the first plane of development (0-6). But just as with children who are wholly brought up in a traditional school system, a bad teacher or two can lead to serious negative consequences in the long term for the child even if their needs prior were met.

One thing that caught my eye about what you wrote was that you seemed to be saying your daughter had grades and tests in her Montessori classroom. Grades and tests are explicitly against the Montessori philosophy for various reasons that I can elaborate on if you want me to. Was this a public Montessori school perhaps, which unfortunately still have to take standardized tests no matter how closely they adhere to Maria Montessori’s original framework? I obviously cannot evaluate the rest of the implementation in your daughter’s Montessori classroom, but this sends up a red flag to me personally.

Let me know if there is anything else I can help with. Here is a blog post from a very good Montessori blog that may help you decide if the Montessori school(s) in your area is right for you child. mariamontessori.com/mm/?p=1264
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top