Bishop Rhoades and Robert Sungenis

  • Thread starter Thread starter Michael_Forrest
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I always thought that if you have a disagreement with your brother, that you take it up with him.

Where you do not reach agreement then you take it to the church….and leave it there. Not spread slander AGAINST him!

Whilst he deals with his bishop about matters that are serious to him, as he should, it should be left to between them.

Having read through some of the stuff on his website, I have yet to find sufficient fault in what he clearly defines to be his personal understanding of what he puts forward, to warrant the negative intent of this thread. Even the material cited and linked above does not justify berating an apologia. Perhaps, it is easier from this distance to read and sift through material and examine them solely on their written form WITHOUT THE EMOTIVE baggage oozing out of this thread!

It seems an individual cannot say anything critical about all things Jewish without being labelled 'anti-Semitic. I am reminded that Christianity is anti-Semitic through the wrong lenses. Adherence to the Laws of old, under the previous system, is now erroneous regarding salvation.

I like Sungenis, from what I’ve read so far. To be sure, some of his bluntness is edgy and, I would wager, some of his views may fall short of being charitable, but he calls a spade a spade. Something quite refreshing in Apologetics and adds a dynamic practiced by some of the earliest Fathers, some who openly “hated” everything said against Christ or The Church by anyone, Jew included. But they qualified it by the remiders that Our Lord was a Jew; all His Apostles were Jews; The Church WAS Jewish.

That being said, Sungenis should respect his bishop enough to take matters up with him, outside his website, and post only the conclusion they both reach, if he must.

I have yet to find another Catholic Apologetic individual as sharp as Sungenis on “You Tube” defending the faith against Reformers of note and held in high esteem by their denominations. (I acknowledge Fr Pacwa here but he is normally “gangbanged” and talked down by loudmouthed detractors)

I expect Sungenis to make many mistakes. But so far he makes them in the honest belief that they are correct. I find the same fault in anti-Catholic scholars and theologians who rally against The Church. Some are legitimately ignorant of existing facts in the history of The Church. Some deliberately ignore them. Some build cases on dogmas of The Church and selectively cite various individuals and councils to validate their thesis. Some just have honest belief that what they have been given is correct.

For me, the issue is INTENT. What is Sungenis’ intent?

Is he anti-Jew? I haven’t seen it yet. I see a guy speaking against Jewish practices being brought into The Church. Is he correct? The sacrifice of the Mass is a ritual from the Old Testament, fulfilled and completed in The New Covenant, perpetuated through The Church. So I reserve my opinion there…for now until I read more.

Is he anti-bishopric? Well, he cites others for support, so, no.

Is he anti-Catholic? No, with bells on!

Is he anti-Christian? No, with bells on.

Is he anti-everyotherreligion? Too true! Too blunt at times, but shouldn’t he be?

In a gridiron game, the objective is to get the ball to the endzone. It seems this thread is criticizing his running style and ignoring that he is at least facing in the right direction!

If I have to fault Sungenis in this analogy, it is that he (seems)thinks he’s the quarterback!

:cool:
 
I always thought that if you have a disagreement with your brother, that you take it up with him.
Where you do not reach agreement then you take it to the church….and leave it there.
From what I see that’s what they did. But Sungenis won’t listen to the Church. Instead he slandered his bishop. They wrote to the bishop and are defending him.
Not spread slander AGAINST him!
Who is slandering Sungenis? I’m not saying no one has. But I haven’t seen it. The things I’ve read are documented straight away from Sungenis’ own hand. So they’re true. If its true, it’s not slander.
That being said, Sungenis should respect his bishop enough to take matters up with him, outside his website, and post only the conclusion they both reach, if he must.
That’s the problem right now as I see it. He’s disobeying his bishop’s direct orders to stop writing about Jews and slandering him.
sungenisandthejews.blogspot.com/2008/02/breaking-silence.html
I expect Sungenis to make many mistakes. But so far he makes them in the honest belief that they are correct…
🙂 I used to think that, too.

pugiofidei.com/fraud.htm

pugiofidei.com/sungenis5.htm

lumengentleman.com/pdf/sungenis_mohr_comparison.pdf

sungenisandthejews.blogspot.com/2008/02/theology-of-prejudice.html
It seems an individual cannot say anything critical about all things Jewish without being labelled 'anti-Semitic.

For me, the issue is INTENT. What is Sungenis’ intent?
Intent isn’t so easy to tell. To me it’s what he does out in the open that’s the problem. When you plagarize quotes from Nazis, white supremacists, holocaust deniers I think there’s a problem. When you say that Jews are an infection and that they’re excised wherever they go, I think there’s a problem. When you tell lies about Jewish converts and won’t straighten out the record after you’re caught, I think there’s a problem. When you say that Jews tried to take down Bill Dlinton by using Monica Lewinsky and that Jews are listening in on your phone lines? (Yes, he really said that). He was told to take the name Catholic off his website by his bishop and he’s making up things about his bishop just because he was ordered to stop writing about Jews. If that doesn’t sound like someone has a problem with Jews to you, I’m not going to try to convince you further. 😉

Here’s a video montage someone published using some of his quotes. cadl.blogspot.com/2007/12/infamous-video.html
 
Just an observation I have made in the past…

Sungenis seems to refrain from “dealing” with his critics other than on his own website.

The critics, however, seem to be happier when then go to websites other than their own, like CAF, to revisit the “jewish” topics.

I see the OP as one who is more angry with Sungenis than with what he writes. His “vendetta” is more evident, and perhaps worse, than any “vendetta” Sungenis has with Jews and their traditions and beliefs.

As for the poster who notices that Sungenis is blunt and calls it like he sees it… I agree.

Cardinal Kasper’s reflection on the salvation of Jews was deplorable a few years back. It was Sungenis who called that spade a spade… and not the OP or his buddies who have also come to CAF and started threads on their criticism about Sungenis.

So, we pray for all parties concerned. If Sungenis is wrong, or if the Bishop is wrong(or misinformed), well… do we NEED to know. It might satisfy the OP, but I don’t look to sleep better if one or the other is revealed.

.
 
🙂 You must’ve done a good job. I never noticed anything.

:confused: I don’t know what you’re seeing there, jj. You’re only zeroed in on doctrine. That’s never been the most serious issue, IMO.

Do you have a problem with him accusing Shoeman of saying something heretical when he never said it? And now he won’t square the record to clear Shoeman? There’s nothing confusing there. It happened.

What about the way he attacks people as Judaizers. Even Schoeman? Even you believed that from him. And he’s wrong. That’s not what a Judaizer is.

Do you have any problem with him slandering his bishop and disobeying his orders? Nothing too confusing there either, IMO.
sungenisandthejews.blogspot.com/2008/02/bishop-rhoades-sets-record-straight_21.html

Using Nazis, white supremecists, anti-Semites in his researching?

sungenisandthejews.blogspot.com/2007/05/sungenis-dishonesty-and-hypocrisy-over.html

Do you have any problem with comments like these?

“The charge of ‘anti-Semitism’ is nothing but a clever ploy."

“Christianity is certainly not inherently violent, but unfortunately, Judaism tends to be, because real Judaism considers all non-Jews goyim that are less than animals, and this precipitates a loathing and violence against non-Jews.”

“The Jews…do intend to rule the world. And now the problem is that they want to rule the Catholic Church, too.”

“Are the Protocols (of the Elders of Zion) forged? I don’t know. What I do know is that there is a lot of reason to believe that there are certain people, yes, the Jews, who would like us all to believe that they are forged.”

“You know, the thing about Bill Clinton was, you know, he tried to secure this peace accord between Israel and the Arabs and wasn’t successful with that, and he did some other things that the Jews didn’t like, because he got some power under him and he thought he could, you know, do whatever he wanted and then they, you know, they sent Monica Lewinski in there after him, you know, and brought him down.”

“The Jews are godless and getting more ungodly with each passing day.”

"Unfortunately, the Jews haven’t changed in our day. They are still the same godless racists they were in Jesus’ day. Few of them have repented of their sins.”

“The nation of Israel has control of AMDOCS, the central telephone operation in the United States. It’s one way the Mossad spies on American citizens, including you and those you talk to."

“the Jewish element has so infected our Catholic Church today…”

sungenisandthejews.blogspot.com/2007/03/sixteen-proofs-of-sungeniss-anti.html

sungenisandthejews.com/Section2.html

Really. It’s all there with proof from his own hand. It’s not like he denies writing all this hateful stuff. It’s gotten so bad he had to take the name Catholic off his website. I don’t know how much clearer it could be.

But if you don’t see it, I guess you don’t see it. :o
Hey Rick,

You may not like me for saying this and I am not trying to getting in a defend Sungenis at all costs-I accept he has made some mistakes, some serious. But personally whilst I think that what Sungenis has written above is harsh, over emotional and perhaps not prudent. I don’t really see how the stuff he has written is anti-semetic. Is this any different from what people like Robert Spencer and other notable Catholic’s say about Islam, and Muslims wanting to rule the world? Why should we tiptoe around when it comes to Jews? I accept it most be done in a courteous manner and obviously Sungenis has overstepped the mark, in that respect. But I certainly wouldn’t call Sungenis a racist or anti-Jewish by what he has written, anymore then I would call Robert Spencer anti-Islamic.

The You Tube video that was also posted on Mark Shea’s website, trying to imply that Sungenis was a Nazi sympathiser, don’t you think that was slander and overstepping the mark? Do you that is was fair of Mark Shea do that? Depicting Sungenis next to Nazi concentration camps? If that was made by a Catholic (maybe you know more about this), they should be made aware that level of slander is a serious sin.

I just think all the accusations against Sungenis are way, way over the top. As someone who just surfs the internet and has no personal interest in defending Sungenis (I neither know him or have met him, or support his apostolate) I think people are getting caught up in the emotion of things, rather then looking at the hard facts.

Obviously you think otherwise, but I respect that perhaps you know more about it then me about me. Its just that I have looked at the links you have posted and it just feels like this has been blown way,way out of proportion.

God bless,

Eric
 
Obviously you think otherwise, but I respect that perhaps you know more about it then me about me. Its just that I have looked at the links you have posted and it just feels like this has been blown way,way out of proportion.

God bless,

Eric
agreed,… now if that is so, the question becomes…“Why”

There I think one can see the “group-think” of Sungenis accusers who visit other sites to promote their agenda.

.
 
Mr. S - If you can read what he’s done and not be bothered, I’m not going to waste your time and mine trying to convince you.

I suspect you’re in a pretty small minority on that outlook, though. And something tells me that’s just fine with you.

And about Cardinal Kasper (or was it Keeler?), a lot of people were against his ideas. But they didn’t plagarize paranoid hateful conspiracy stuff about Jews to counter him.

I don’t know about the motives of everyone who takes issue with him. And I don’t know what your motives are for defending him so much, either. I try not to judge minds and hearts. I can only judge what I read and I don’t see it the way you do about the people who criticism him. Sungenis has kept at this for a long time. So if he’s not silent, why should other people be silent in reaction to him?

Eric,

I don’t really care whether a peson calls it antisemitism or not. But whatever you call it, Sungenis has definitely got a serious problem when it comes to Jews.

I don’t know Spencer, but if he’s using the kind of blighted sources Sungenis uses, if he lies about Muslims and even Muslim converts to Catholicism and doesn’t apologize and clear up the record, if he’s been at it for years, then I think he has a serious problem, too.

About the video, it’s at a blog put out by some somewhat liberal Catholics (at least that’s what it looks like to me), not Shea’s.

And we see it differently. I didn’t take it saying Sungenis was a Nazi sympathizer. I took it as showing Sungenis talking about powerful Jews who are into everything and trying to take over the world and then depicting the huge contrast with weak Jews who were persecuted. And I took as implying that hateful and paranoid ideas about Jews can lead to atrocities. And I agree with that.

The German people weren’t monsters, Eric. And not even all of the Nazis were either, especially at the beginning. It’s a serious mistake if we think that we can’t become monsters or that our hateful and paranoid ideas can’t encourage others to become monsters. It doesn’t take that much.

Sungenis has put out a good dose of hateful material and ideas when it comes to Jews. And they’re not even mostly his own ideas, at least from what I can tell. I didn’t believe it at first myself and I have a couple of Jewish friends, too.

So, it was a rude awakening to find out the everything. I guess I realized I was kind of callous and naive. The more I read, the more obvious it became. And it kind of scares me to see how easy it ease to believe this conspiracy stuff and the other stuff he put out.

When it gets to the point that even your own bishop orders you to stop and then you tell him no thanks and slander him, then I guess you’re right. I don’t think it’s overblown.
 
Eric - I’m going to be away. So nothing personal if I don’t write anything further.

One quick note, though. On another thread that was closed, you wrote something about Zionism.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=3504140&postcount=12

I don’ t disagree that there’s problem with Zionism, especially with Protestants. But a lot of anti-zionist argument is just a cover for hatred against Jews. It’s sometimes clever and somewhat hard to deconstruct unless you really do your homework. You might want to be at least as careful about swallowing that, too. There are dangers in both directions (speaking from experience here).

But truthfully, I’d rather not even think about this for a while anyway. It’s depressing. It just darkens the soul and the mind. But the business with his bishop certainly seemed worth knowing. And then I saw someone accusing Jewish converts with some of the old faulty accusations Sungenis made. I had to learn about those myself back a while ago.

I really hope he pulls out of it and squares everything up with his bishop. If he pulled himself together, there’s a lot of good he can still do, IMO. But I think it’ll take time before people trust that he’s got it really straightened out.

Here’s praying he does what his bishop told him to do and that he squares everything up with him :o

Pax
 
Man! I’ve just spent the week on Sungenis’ website.

Now there’s a Catholic to be proud of.

Given the multiple anti-Catholic issues he confronts head on, he pulls no punches.

HE DA MAN!

:cool:
 
Man! I’ve just spent the week on Sungenis’ website.

Now there’s a Catholic to be proud of.

Given the multiple anti-Catholic issues he confronts head on, he pulls no punches.

HE DA MAN!

:cool:
We can only hope that the “issue” with the bishop will soon be seen in the light of day for what is really happening. In the meantime the bishop refuses to grant an imprimature to another excellant piece of work by Sungenis, and tries to control the word Catholic. Go figure…:cool:
 
We can only hope that the “issue” with the bishop will soon be seen in the light of day for what is really happening. In the meantime the bishop refuses to grant an imprimature to another excellant piece of work by Sungenis, and tries to control the word Catholic. Go figure…:cool:
Listen, I think Dr. Sungenis’ books are as excellant as much as anyone and stick up for him when its called for but this is getting just flat out rediculous. I’ve read as much as I can at this point and just try to pray now for him but come on! So you think you know what’s in the bishop’s mind, Mr. S? Are you a mindreader? Did you talk to the bishop? No? So, you wrote to Dr. Sungenis or people from CAI, right? I did that too and I got burned.

I lost a lot of respect when him and his apologists from CAI told falsehoods about the imprimaturs to me and everyone else who asked them over and over. They did it right to me. They thought they were being clever and made it sound like everything was fine with his apologetics study bible and it just flat out wasn’t. They were doing advertisments for him over here at the CAF and I called them on it. When you do a translation that’s supposed to get approved by the Church. That’s right in cannon law. And he didn’t. I don’t care why anyone thinks he got turned down. So do the translation the right way and get it approved like everyone else has to. But he’s still selling it, right and acting like it’s all okay? Says who? Who comes first, Dr. Sungenis or the Church?

And even though I don’t think he’s an antisemite or a racist he’s definately got something bitter against Jews. You’ve got to admit it. Zionism is dangerous but its way more than that. He’s stuck on Jews for whatever reason. When I look at those statements he wrote about Jews I’d definately be burned if someone said them about Catholics. And I bet every single of you would be too if your honest.

And even if some of the Jewish converts have their problems (I don’t know because I never read all their books or whatever there writing) that doesn’t make it right to spread lies about them! Come on! You can’t be serious.

You know what? I think the bishop is doing him a huge favor. Someone needs to get him away from Jews for a while or something. Why not his bishop? Who says its not God telling him this through the bishop? I think he is.

I’m not going to pck a layman over his Bishop and back up slander against a bishop. No way. No how. This just is flat out not Catholic and it makes me sick to my stomach that anyone here would do it. :mad:
 
At first when Sungenis wrote that the Jews were the true anti semites because they rejected Jesus and Jesus was Jewish 🙂 or when he wrote that Lenin and Stalin were Jewish 😉 or when he plagarized from a nazi anti Jewish tract 😛 , that here was one of the most brilliant humoristic Catholic satirists alive. 👍

However then I got to thinking how maybe there was no Robert Sungenis and maybe he was just a front for a cabal of power hungry bolshevic Jews set out to destroy Catholicism along with their Judaizer allies:shrug:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top