D
Deconi
Guest
I always thought that if you have a disagreement with your brother, that you take it up with him.
Where you do not reach agreement then you take it to the church….and leave it there. Not spread slander AGAINST him!
Whilst he deals with his bishop about matters that are serious to him, as he should, it should be left to between them.
Having read through some of the stuff on his website, I have yet to find sufficient fault in what he clearly defines to be his personal understanding of what he puts forward, to warrant the negative intent of this thread. Even the material cited and linked above does not justify berating an apologia. Perhaps, it is easier from this distance to read and sift through material and examine them solely on their written form WITHOUT THE EMOTIVE baggage oozing out of this thread!
It seems an individual cannot say anything critical about all things Jewish without being labelled 'anti-Semitic. I am reminded that Christianity is anti-Semitic through the wrong lenses. Adherence to the Laws of old, under the previous system, is now erroneous regarding salvation.
I like Sungenis, from what I’ve read so far. To be sure, some of his bluntness is edgy and, I would wager, some of his views may fall short of being charitable, but he calls a spade a spade. Something quite refreshing in Apologetics and adds a dynamic practiced by some of the earliest Fathers, some who openly “hated” everything said against Christ or The Church by anyone, Jew included. But they qualified it by the remiders that Our Lord was a Jew; all His Apostles were Jews; The Church WAS Jewish.
That being said, Sungenis should respect his bishop enough to take matters up with him, outside his website, and post only the conclusion they both reach, if he must.
I have yet to find another Catholic Apologetic individual as sharp as Sungenis on “You Tube” defending the faith against Reformers of note and held in high esteem by their denominations. (I acknowledge Fr Pacwa here but he is normally “gangbanged” and talked down by loudmouthed detractors)
I expect Sungenis to make many mistakes. But so far he makes them in the honest belief that they are correct. I find the same fault in anti-Catholic scholars and theologians who rally against The Church. Some are legitimately ignorant of existing facts in the history of The Church. Some deliberately ignore them. Some build cases on dogmas of The Church and selectively cite various individuals and councils to validate their thesis. Some just have honest belief that what they have been given is correct.
For me, the issue is INTENT. What is Sungenis’ intent?
Is he anti-Jew? I haven’t seen it yet. I see a guy speaking against Jewish practices being brought into The Church. Is he correct? The sacrifice of the Mass is a ritual from the Old Testament, fulfilled and completed in The New Covenant, perpetuated through The Church. So I reserve my opinion there…for now until I read more.
Is he anti-bishopric? Well, he cites others for support, so, no.
Is he anti-Catholic? No, with bells on!
Is he anti-Christian? No, with bells on.
Is he anti-everyotherreligion? Too true! Too blunt at times, but shouldn’t he be?
In a gridiron game, the objective is to get the ball to the endzone. It seems this thread is criticizing his running style and ignoring that he is at least facing in the right direction!
If I have to fault Sungenis in this analogy, it is that he (seems)thinks he’s the quarterback!

Where you do not reach agreement then you take it to the church….and leave it there. Not spread slander AGAINST him!
Whilst he deals with his bishop about matters that are serious to him, as he should, it should be left to between them.
Having read through some of the stuff on his website, I have yet to find sufficient fault in what he clearly defines to be his personal understanding of what he puts forward, to warrant the negative intent of this thread. Even the material cited and linked above does not justify berating an apologia. Perhaps, it is easier from this distance to read and sift through material and examine them solely on their written form WITHOUT THE EMOTIVE baggage oozing out of this thread!
It seems an individual cannot say anything critical about all things Jewish without being labelled 'anti-Semitic. I am reminded that Christianity is anti-Semitic through the wrong lenses. Adherence to the Laws of old, under the previous system, is now erroneous regarding salvation.
I like Sungenis, from what I’ve read so far. To be sure, some of his bluntness is edgy and, I would wager, some of his views may fall short of being charitable, but he calls a spade a spade. Something quite refreshing in Apologetics and adds a dynamic practiced by some of the earliest Fathers, some who openly “hated” everything said against Christ or The Church by anyone, Jew included. But they qualified it by the remiders that Our Lord was a Jew; all His Apostles were Jews; The Church WAS Jewish.
That being said, Sungenis should respect his bishop enough to take matters up with him, outside his website, and post only the conclusion they both reach, if he must.
I have yet to find another Catholic Apologetic individual as sharp as Sungenis on “You Tube” defending the faith against Reformers of note and held in high esteem by their denominations. (I acknowledge Fr Pacwa here but he is normally “gangbanged” and talked down by loudmouthed detractors)
I expect Sungenis to make many mistakes. But so far he makes them in the honest belief that they are correct. I find the same fault in anti-Catholic scholars and theologians who rally against The Church. Some are legitimately ignorant of existing facts in the history of The Church. Some deliberately ignore them. Some build cases on dogmas of The Church and selectively cite various individuals and councils to validate their thesis. Some just have honest belief that what they have been given is correct.
For me, the issue is INTENT. What is Sungenis’ intent?
Is he anti-Jew? I haven’t seen it yet. I see a guy speaking against Jewish practices being brought into The Church. Is he correct? The sacrifice of the Mass is a ritual from the Old Testament, fulfilled and completed in The New Covenant, perpetuated through The Church. So I reserve my opinion there…for now until I read more.
Is he anti-bishopric? Well, he cites others for support, so, no.
Is he anti-Catholic? No, with bells on!
Is he anti-Christian? No, with bells on.
Is he anti-everyotherreligion? Too true! Too blunt at times, but shouldn’t he be?
In a gridiron game, the objective is to get the ball to the endzone. It seems this thread is criticizing his running style and ignoring that he is at least facing in the right direction!
If I have to fault Sungenis in this analogy, it is that he (seems)thinks he’s the quarterback!