Book warning: A Bad Kitty Christmas

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes. And what happens in contemporary culture is that people conveniently ignore the second half of that: Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life–whomsoever* follows him* shall have eternal life.

Just because Jesus preached to the prostitutes and tax collectors doesn’t mean that he approved of, or accepted what they did with their lives.

I’m not saying you’re saying that, Ed. Just that’s what so many people use to justify doing whatever feels good at the moment.
Of course Jesus preached to sinners. What he didn’t do was put his seal of approval on books which attempted to say there was nothing whatever wrong with sinful behavior. He didn’t tell the prostitute, ‘you’re okay just the way you are; your lifestyle is fine;’ he said ‘neither do I condemn you; go, and avoid this sin from now on.’

We do children a terrible disservice by enabling confusion about moral issues.
 
Rest well, Crescentinus. In the morning please let me know if that comes from the Catechism or some other Catholic reference source.

I still think the real question lies in defining what ‘enabling’ looks and feels like, but again, that’s a topic for another thread in another forum. 😊
And yet I had shown it to you already. O:
And here it is:
Enabling sin is probably the worst form of hate there is, because it shows hatred against another person’s soul!
Forgive my lack of eloquence.
 
Of course Jesus preached to sinners. What he didn’t do was put his seal of approval on books which attempted to say there was nothing whatever wrong with sinful behavior.
But putting a seal of approval on sinful behavior is not what this thread is about. The thread concerns condemning a book because it mentions sinful behavior which the child may very well encounter on his or her own.

The book provides an opportunity to teach in a controlled environment. Sin often wears the guise of something good. If the parents are willing to teach morality, the book could be a valuable tool. Of course, some parents would rather skip the lesson or put it off. And that is okay. Cautioning parents that it contains an episode of concern seems reasonable so they can make an informed decision. The movie Bambi has an episode in which his mother is murdered and Bambi has to literally to run away to save his own life. This scene could easily traumatize a child. That in itself doesn’t mean that Bambi should be condemned, but that a parent needs to exercise judgement and guidance…

What doesn’t seem reasonable is to condemn the book and mutter about conspiracies.
 
I allow my kids to read all kinds of books, since it lets me discuss them. If I ban books, they will eventually read them when I’m not around.

Of course since the Catechism calls on us to accept gays with the utmost love and respect I don’t feel the need to freak out when a gay character shows up in a book.

You do understand that your kids can’t “catch gay”, right?

God bless
Thank you for this thoughtful post.
 
But putting a seal of approval on sinful behavior is not what this thread is about. The thread concerns condemning a book because it mentions sinful behavior which the child may very well encounter on his or her own.

The book provides an opportunity to teach in a controlled environment. Sin often wears the guise of something good. If the parents are willing to teach morality, the book could be a valuable tool. Of course, some parents would rather skip the lesson or put it off. And that is okay. Cautioning parents that it contains an episode of concern seems reasonable so they can make an informed decision. The movie Bambi has an episode in which his mother is murdered and Bambi has to literally to run away to save his own life. This scene could easily traumatize a child. That in itself doesn’t mean that Bambi should be condemned, but that a parent needs to exercise judgement and guidance…

What doesn’t seem reasonable is to condemn the book and mutter about conspiracies.
Please point to any “conspiracy” I cited.

Peace,
Ed
 
But putting a seal of approval on sinful behavior is not what this thread is about. The thread concerns condemning a book because it mentions sinful behavior which the child may very well encounter on his or her own.

The book provides an opportunity to teach in a controlled environment. Sin often wears the guise of something good. If the parents are willing to teach morality, the book could be a valuable tool. Of course, some parents would rather skip the lesson or put it off. And that is okay. Cautioning parents that it contains an episode of concern seems reasonable so they can make an informed decision. The movie Bambi has an episode in which his mother is murdered and Bambi has to literally to run away to save his own life. This scene could easily traumatize a child. That in itself doesn’t mean that Bambi should be condemned, but that a parent needs to exercise judgement and guidance…

What doesn’t seem reasonable is to condemn the book and mutter about conspiracies.
From what I’ve read here, the book in question, “Bad Kitty Christmas” has only a single mention of a possibly gay character. That doesn’t particularly concern me. Personally, I would rather that childrens books have no gay characters, because they can’t possibly understand what it means. What is of more concern to me are books like “Heather Has Two Mommies,” or “King and King,” which actively promote the idea of homosexual marriage as a normal thing.

Neither would I want a children’s book which portrayed a happy hooker as a main character or a swinging couple. No matter how evil the world may be, I think that children are entitled to their innocence. Let’s not try to get them to lose their innocence at such early ages.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top