Can a demon kill a human?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cor5755
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

cor5755

Guest
Hello all, I have wondered about this question for quite some time. I have read of demonic possession but the possessed person lives, although a very tormented life. Movies almost always show the possessed person being killed by the demon. Just curious to see different opinions on this.
 
A demon has no means to kill a person, although a demon may have the ability to influence a person in such a way that the person takes his or her own life.
 
Yes, a demon can kill a human, but only if God permits it. For a Scriptural example of this, see the Book of Tobit. Seven men were killed by the demon Asmodeus (Tobit 3:8).
 
Yes, a demon can kill a human, but only if God permits it. For a Scriptural example of this, see the Book of Tobit. Seven men were killed by the demon Asmodeus (Tobit 3:8).
This is not entirely clear.
The Book of Tobias relates that the virgin Sara, the kinswoman of Tobias, had been given successively to seven husbands; but they had all been slain on the night of the nuptials, before the consummation of the marriage. From this fact, a superstition had arisen that the demon loved the maiden and slew her husbands through jealousy. In the Greek text of Tobias, it is stated that the younger Tobias himself was moved by this superstition. The inspired text in no way approves the superstition (Source).
 
This is not entirely clear.
The Book of Tobias relates that the virgin Sara, the kinswoman of Tobias, had been given successively to seven husbands; but they had all been slain on the night of the nuptials, before the consummation of the marriage. From this fact, a superstition had arisen that the demon loved the maiden and slew her husbands through jealousy. In the Greek text of Tobias, it is stated that the younger Tobias himself was moved by this superstition. The inspired text in no way approves the superstition (Source).
The superstition was that the demon was in love with Sara. The New Advent entry doesn’t dispute that a demon killed the men; if you’d copied one more line from the entry, you’d have this:
“God allowed the demon to slay these men because they entered marriage with unholy motives.”
 
The superstition was that the demon was in love with Sarah.
Haha, yes, *and *that the demon “slew her husbands through jealousy” if you keep reading that very same sentence.
New Advent doesn’t dispute that a demon killed the men. If you’d copied one more line from that source, you’d have this:

“God allowed the demon to slay these men because they entered marriage with unholy motives.”
That line follows from the assumption of the superstition, although the way the piece was written it wouldn’t appear that way. I excluded it to prevent the very confusion we have right now.

The Wikipedia article on Asmodeus demonstrates yet another understanding–that Sarah killed the husbands herself"The Asmodeus of the Book of Tobit is attracted by Sarah, Raguel’s daughter, and is not willing to let any husband possess her (Tobit, vi.13); hence she slays seven successive husbands on their wedding nights, thus impeding the sexual consummation of the marriages (Source).
 
The superstition was not that a demon killed the men. The superstition was the motive behind the killings being the jealousy of a love-struck demon.
That line follows from the assumption of the superstition, although the way the piece was written it wouldn’t appear that way. I excluded it to prevent the very confusion we have right now.
You’re misinterpreting the article. It’s clear that God allowed the demons to kill the first seven husbands:
God allowed the demon to slay these men because they entered marriage with unholy motives. The pious youth, Tobias, acting under the instructions of Raphael, takes Sara to wife, and Raphael expels the demon. The exemplary chastity and temperance of Tobias and Sara save them from the demon, and offer an example for mankind. In fact, the permission given by God to the demon in this history seems to have as a motive to chasten man’s lust and sanctify marriage.
 
Getting this thread back on topic…

Demons cannot kill. They could kill before Christ came, but not now. The reason is because they’ve lost their dominion over man, thanks to the death of Jesus. The new Adam reversed the curse of Adam.
 
All events ultimately depend on God’s Providential decisions. 🙂

A demon can kill a human being if God allows the demon to do so. A demon can rarely do so however, directly or physically – that would be an especial loosening of the restrictions God places on demons normally. These restrictions are quite great, preventing a great deal of disaster.

God also restrains his good angels from intervening as greatly as they could. One always has a guardian angel at one’s side. And these angels of course have the Lord and they constantly protect us – the degree they are permitted to do so depends on the Lord’s will.

The spirits are en mass restrained to a degree from intervening in our lives however, both angels and devils from exercising their full abilities, which are tremendous.

The demon works through mediation – i.e., he (rarely) possesses or (normally) offers the temptation to a human being. So it is simple for a demon to offer the temptation for one human being to kill another human being, or for that human being to kill himself.

The demons in fact favor murder-suicides, when you read about these events in the newspapers you often read about that same person talking about demons (which are in the secular papers always ascribed to mental illnesses). Drugs-murder-rape-suicide these are the baliwick of devils.

For example while you are driving on the highway the demon could have tempted an alcoholic to drink to much, and then try to tempt him to swerve the car into yours – or he could try to tempt you personally to turn the wrong way off a cliff’s edge, or similar.

However at the same time all this is happening God and the angels involved are offering the good choice to those involved.

The demons are often more directly persuasive on these matters because they do not care about the human freedom of the person being persuaded in the slightest.

Whether you will be harmed or not by a devil depends on the interaction between sin and Providence in the particular situation.

Generally the best method for a safe and protected life with beneficial Providential interaction and minimum sinful interaction is to be as holy and saintly as possible. 🙂

Even the worst of sinners who suddenly turns to the Lord in the darkest situation is in good hands. 🙂 But do avoid them lest you reap what you sow.

‘Above all we ought at least to know that there are three origins of our thoughts, i.e., from God, from the devil, and from ourselves. . . We ought then carefully to notice this threefold order, and with a wise discretion to analyse the thoughts which arise in our hearts, tracking out their origin and cause and author in the first instance, that we may be able to consider how we ought to yield ourselves to them. . .’

St. Moses the Black Hermit
 
Thank you, Shin, for that thorough and correct explanation.
 
Hello all, I have wondered about this question for quite some time. I have read of demonic possession but the possessed person lives, although a very tormented life. Movies almost always show the possessed person being killed by the demon. Just curious to see different opinions on this.
Read the Book “Interview with an Exorcist” by Fr. Jose Antonio Fortea, It explains alot on this subject
 
Dear friend

They are still angels and immensely superior to us and could pulverise us in an instant. But they cannot move one dot without Gods permission so don’t worry.

God bless you:thumbsup:🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top