Canadian vs US Catholic Church

Status
Not open for further replies.

GospelOfMatthew

New member
What are the differences between the Catholic Church of Canada and the United States Catholic Church? Obviously very similar but each are different as their conferences of Bishops have decided different things. What are the noticeable differences?

I am considering moving to Canada post-graduation and am curious about this aspect
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There are fewer Holy Days of Obligation in Canada.

And they sell milk in bags.

OH, Church related, they can have Tim Horton’s for Coffee and Donuts after Mass.
 
Last edited:
And they sell milk in bags
And boxes. How cool to keep in the cupboard unrefrigerated.

As above, haven’t seen much difference on visiting. You could always look at the diocese web site to try to get a feel.
 
When I was a kid and we used to go to Ontario across from Buffalo every year, there seemed to be a stronger French influence in the Canadian churches there, and some of the priests were a bit more harsh. However, I suspect that the further you get away from Quebec, the less French influence you get, and I have no idea what it’s like now, decades later.
 
Following this with great interest. In moments of great job stress my husband threatens to either move us all to Canada or open a breakfast shop. Both outcomes are terrifying and exciting.
 
I am Canadian but have lived in the US and did not notice any big difference in liturgy or practice. My observation is that there is more of a culture of activism in the US which translates into more Church-driven activities related to pro-life whereas in Canada it is less so. I also remember hearing more about guns and gun-related issues in homilies whereas in Canada it tends to be a non-issue.
 
Even though there’s one conference of bishops, one set of adaptations of the General Instructions, etc, there are really two Churches in Canada, a Francophone one, largely made up of cradle Catholics, and an Anglophone one. Both have a significant (name removed by moderator)ut of immigrants.

But there are subtle differences. The Quebec Church, in a backlash to its Jansenist past where even in the '50s you could be refused absolution for practicing NFP, has become distinctly liberal. There are cultural differences too, some subtle, some not so much. I’ve never heard an announcement barring non-Catholics from communion in a Quebec church for example. The first time I ever attended Mass outside of French Canada, there was such an announcement. We (Francophones) tend to be more Latin in our approach to the Law, and not so rigorous its application, especially since the Council broke the chains of Jansenism. Perhaps things have swung too far, but the backlash is perfectly understandable given the clerical excesses of the pre-Conciliar era.

Another difference, is that the calendar of saints is different for French Canada, for optional memorials. And yes the calendar differs from the US.
 
I would add that in several Canadian provinces, Catholic schools receive government funds and are therefore available to anyone and this is something (I think) unthinkable in the US. In the US when someone says they went to Catholic school it means private school that only some can afford.

Even with the drawbacks that you mention, my opinion is Quebec feels great for a Catholic. When I visit, I can freely talk about the Church and the saints it is almost part of daily life there. Whereas in English Canada because it has always been majority Protestant people are overly critical of the Church.
 
The best I can offer is spelling differences as I’m not Catholic. Oh, and we don’t all say eh at the end of every sentence and I would assume the bishops are no different.

But @twf is another Catholic in Canada who is quite knowledgeable in these matters.
 
Last edited:
In Quebec and Newfoundland, public Catholic school boards have been abolished. In Quebec school boards are now organized according to language, not religion. In Ontario, Catholic (aka “Separate”) school boards still exist. Not sure about the rest of the country. In Quebec religious instruction of any kind is forbidden in all schools.

To be honest the last place I worked before retiring, most Francophones were very hostile to the Church/religion. Only one was practicing in our department, and the only other person who was very respectful of my faith was herself… Muslim.

I did go to a Catholic (public) school when I grew up.
 
Saskatchewan is also part of the club with Ontario and Alberta.
 
Last edited:
Oh, and we don’t all say eh at the end of every sentence and I would assume the bishops are no different.
Isn’t that “bishoup” in Canadian English? 😱:crazy_face:🤯

Or would that be, “Caunaudian Eunglisush?” :confused:😖

hawk
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top