Here’s a super-duper, all in one place, great resource for you: A Landscape with Dragons by Michael D. O’Brien, published by Ignatius Press.
I’ve given away so many copies of this book that…I don’t have a copy anymore. But before I gave away my last copy, I photocopied the book list from the back of the book. It was compiled by the people at Bethlehem Books (more on them later) and gives probably hundreds of books ranging from ‘read-to-me/picture book’ level through young adult. Not every book is ‘Catholic,’ but all the books promote timeless moral/family values.
You could use that list for years. My favorite suggestion is to make copies of the list and give them to grandparents and godparents - anyone who needs to know what to get your kids for a present. Tell them ‘anything on this list for their age level’ and you know that you are safe. Also great if you take your kids to the public library and are clueless about the value/content of what they are reading. Tell the kids they can borrow and read anything on the list, but anything that’s not on the list, you have to read first and pass. A Landscape with Dragons, by the way, will give you great insights into what’s wholesome and what’s not wholesome reading for Catholic kids.
It’s terrific to have a reliable list of books that your children can safely read. I can’t recommend A Landscape with Dragons enough for every parent and librarian.
Bethlehem books are available through Ignatius press - either their website or their print catalogue. BB started out as a group of Evangelicals, I think, or Baptists, living a communal life ‘as they did in the early church’ (at least as they imagined it). The ‘commune’ converted wholesale to the Catholic Church at some point. Meanwhile, a couple of things happened: they needed a business to support the commune, and as they had children, they noticed the steady erosion of both quality and moral values in recent children’s literature. They decided to go into publishing and bring back into print classic character-forming children’s literature and to publish new books that fit that description.
Try Bethlehem books for all ages. Can’t go wrong.