Catholic church feels cold?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jerel5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
^This 👍

Yes, with what they know, they do a lot with it. We, however have a depth of truth that they do not. It’s like going to swim in the kiddie pool vs. the deep end. When you first start out, it’s lots and lots of fun playing around in the kiddie pool, but after you get used to it, you yearn to delve into the deep end of the big pool. You will always want more.
👍👍
 
Wow, thank you everyone for your responses. I have to admit that I have never felt closer to God then coming out of confession and I love the eucharist. I have just had a hard time finding other catholic young people that take their faith serious. I have tons of protostant friends and one Catholic friend who is culturaly catholic. This could be just an isolated situation but I just see more protestants taking their faith seriously and its been bothering me. Any thoughts?
 
Through the years I have known a few friends/family who have fallen away from the faith and started attending a Protestant church. They will go on and on about how “vibrant”, “lively”, or some such adjective their new “church” is. Withou fail, it seems like within 2 or 3 years they have found another new, vibrant Protestant church, and then again and then again.

Maybe cradle Protestants can stay at the same church for a long period of time, but not former Catholics. Me thinks they don’t know what they left, but their soul does.
 
Wow, thank you everyone for your responses. I have to admit that I have never felt closer to God then coming out of confession and I love the eucharist. I have just had a hard time finding other catholic young people that take their faith serious. I have tons of protostant friends and one Catholic friend who is culturaly catholic. This could be just an isolated situation but I just see more protestants taking their faith seriously and its been bothering me. Any thoughts?
I have no Catholic friends. My friends are Protestants, atheists and agnostics.

I look at it this way: I’m not here for me. I’m not here for those who are saved. I am here for the lost, just as our Lord was.

It’s more important for me to be friends with those who don’t have truth, then it is for me to have friends who think like I do.

Perhaps you are surrounded by Catholics who seem to not take their faith seriously is because YOU are the one who is supposed to show them a better way to be. Maybe your presence is needed in their lives…

that said, I know plenty of Catholics who take their faith VERY seriously!!! (I’m just not friends with them for reasons that have nothing to do with their faith).

There are just as many lukewarm, Sunday Protestants as there are Catholics. But it’s okay. Go out there and be the light!!!
 
Wow, thank you everyone for your responses. I have to admit that I have never felt closer to God then coming out of confession and I love the eucharist. I have just had a hard time finding other catholic young people that take their faith serious. I have tons of protostant friends and one Catholic friend who is culturaly catholic. This could be just an isolated situation but I just see more protestants taking their faith seriously and its been bothering me. Any thoughts?
Newman Centers are usually located on college campuses, they would be a gathering spot for young Catholics.

Yes, sometimes it seems that there are more protestants taking their faith seriously than Catholics. Remember, looks can be deceiving. Reach out to other Catholic youth through message boards, online sites, Newman Centers or maybe talk to your priest. The priest usually knows which Masses have more young people at them. Maybe see if your dioceses has any youth programs, they could be located at other parishes.

Just a few ideas:shrug:
 
There was so much that was missing. Mass is a celebration but a very sacred, serious one. We are partaking of the actual Body and Blood of God. That is amazing. I don’t know about the joy present in Protestant churches but I do know one thing. **When I receive the Body and Blood of Jesus I cry for joy. I’m quiet about it but I can’t help it. I feel a type of ecstasy and I want to die right then and there and be with God for eternity.
**
👍 Glad I’m not alone in that! Sometimes I become overwhelmed in Mass and just want to prostrate myself…but that would cause a scene…I cry at times…(and not because the homily is too long 😉 ) I have to pinch myself to stop it when my husband is there, he is rather mortified when I tear up. In adoration, I just let go with it if not many people are there. I mean, not sobbing out loud crying but quiet tears of joy and love.
 
Hello,

I have been going to a plant church with my girlfriend and she has been going to mass with me occasionally. I am no stranger to protestant services or protestant spirituality because most of my family and friends are protestant. My experience in attending these two churches is that the plant church is very active and vibrant and I am encouraged by everyone’s passion and excitement they bring to church. Mass is different, and the protestant services are just bible studies and entertainment but I do feel attracted to their passion and discouraged by my fellow Catholics lack of zeal. Has anyone else had this experience?

thanks
I grew to know both. I never felt pentacostal or evangelical services were church but I never denied gods presence there in the holy spirit or in my bedroom during evening prayer. With that in mind it is nice to praise god, Jesus and spirit.

My advice is to look for the same in catholic church. Catholicism at it’s base is the mass but upon that grows dozens, hundreds, thousands of ministries in your area. Seek out guidance and revelation of your role in mass and in ministry. The reason its best to do this in the catholic church (not necessarily the mass), is because these ministries are served by stewardship, discipleship, and extremely explicit while somewhat detailed doctrine. The catholic doctrine and theology is part of what allows and guides priests in their pastoral and interpretational duties.
 
Of course. Before my call to conversion I found Mass to be a very dour and empty experience…

But after I was called to convert I wouldn’t trade any level of entertainment and fun for the Mass.

The Mass is how it is for a reason… we are participating in the sacrifice of our Lord at Mass. It is a very sober thing. It’s not a time for joyous music and dancing in the aisles. The crucifix has pride of place for a reason.

That said, I do miss Protestant services every now and then. It was fun to have that upbeat music, to clap your hands and laugh with your friends… to participate in worship and just uplift your heart to God… but it was empty. It lacked something. Something I never understood then but something I understand completely now.

Furthermore, how do you know your fellow Catholics lack zeal? They may not be clapping their hands and shouting to the Lord but that doesn’t mean they are not on fire for the Lord!!! You cannot judge the state of anyone’s heart simply by their actions.

In the Protestant churches I attended, the kids who were the most zealous within church were the same kids who went out and partied with their friends with drugs, alcohol… the same kids who went out in the week and slept around with multiple partners…

you cannot judge someone’s heart by their actions within church or within Mass. You just can’t. Some people put on a show, some don’t…

I’d encourage you to stop seeking what ‘feels good’ and focus on the Lord and the Lord alone.
Good answer!
 
Hi there,

I know that one thing that many Catholic parishes do have to get better at (at least, where I live), is welcoming individuals to their Church. At our parish, for example, we have had one or two people speak to us, but the vast majority don’t know us or seem to know eachother, with the exception of a few cliques, and everyone seems to rush out after Mass. One thing that some Protestant churches seem to do better than we do is the welcoming and socialization portion to church. It is something that we need to work on (at least, to my experience, but that may vary) and I’m sorry that you have picked up on this, too, in your Catholic experience.

However…

Where the Catholic Mass differs from many Protestant services is that the service is not structured for us, we are expected to be structured for the service, if that makes sense. The Mass may have different music and a different “flavour” at times, depending on who the celebrant is or how the music is (and I have my own opinions on the music thing…), but the Mass is always the Mass, never changing. We are at Mass to celebrate the Eucharist. We are not there to “get something out of” the service or to hear great music (certainly not at my parish…LOL) or to hear a great orator. We’re there to celebrate the Mass. The more you study Catholic theology, the more sense that will make.

We also aren’t there for socialization or to make friends. Those things are nice and it’s great when we find a good, solid foundation of people to rely on in our parish community, but it isn’t a coffee klatch or an interest group. There are many groups we can join, like the Knights of Columbus, the Catholic Women’s League, Bible studies, etc for fellowship, but going to Mass is not for the purpose of networking or “hanging out” with people we have things in common with. We can do that at a coffee shop. I don’t mean to sound trite, but sometimes, church gets mixed up with a social club. It’s fine to meet people that we have things in common with and it’s great to make friends through our church and we should form community-but that’s not why we are there.

Therefore, it shouldn’t matter whether you attend Mass at a parish with great music, poor music, a great speaker for a priest, or a priest that can barely deliver a homily; Mass is Mass and will always be the same. There will be some Masses that may touch your soul more deeply, perhaps, but the great Paschal Mystery of the Real Presence (the Eucharist) is always the same.

I keep thinking of what Michael Coren said (author of “Why Catholics are Right”) when I saw him interviewed on EWTN. Michael was a convert to Catholicism as an adult from a secular upbringing in England, then left the Church for a while to be an Evangelical Protestant. He said one Sunday, he had gone to his Evangelical service and his wife had returned from Mass. He asked her how Mass was and started talking about how great the music and pastor were at his service. His wife shrugged and said simply, “Mass was Mass, it was the Body of Christ”. Michael realized that he was measuring his services in terms of how good the speaker was, the music, etc,…wheras Mass was eternal, always the same, and was not there to entertain you (I’m paraphrasing here.). Michael said that when he goes to church, he’s not there to eat popcorn or to watch a big screen TV, he’s there to worship Christ.

The evangelical churches often are flashier and have more “stuff” then the Catholics do: they tend to have lots of outreach groups, activities, etc. They also have alot of music and fun and accomplished speakers. But the Catholic Church has the Real Presence, the Sacred Tradition handed down from the Apostles, and the Sacraments. We may not be the flashiest, but we have the same Truth we’ve had for over 2000 years. Could we improve at the welcoming bit? Yes. But are we there to be entertained or to have the Mass “work for us”? No. There will be times when we feel empty at Mass, but the more we pray and meditate on the Real Presence, the more we will realize that Jesus is profoundly Present at each and every Mass and in each and every Catholic Church in a way that no other Church can claim.

God Bless You.
 
You are so right. I was in Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris on Sunday for the Mass and I had to wear my coat the whole time. You’d think they could install central heating or something.

😉
:rotfl:
WHAT! Paris! I’m jealous, God bless you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top