I can’t emphasize enough that looking outside of your immediate area is vital on Catholic dating sites. I think there were three guys in my area on AMS, and I wasn’t at all interested in any of them. My boyfriend–who I met on AMS–lives almost five hours from me. It’s hard (and as we get fonder of one another, the distance gets tougher), but thus far, we’ve made it work. I doubt I’d ever have met him in “real life,” and I’m grateful daily for AMS.
Broaden your search to include all geographic areas, adjust it by age and appropriate answers to some questions, and maybe throw in a keyword or two. See what happens. If she’s Miss Right, you’ll be willing to fly across the country to meet her, and vice versa.
God bless you in your search!