Catholic Dogma -- help me on Immaculate Conception

  • Thread starter Thread starter otrrl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jesus didn’t sin or fall short of the glory of God.

Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses, even in those that did not sin after the manner of the rebellion of Adam, who is a figure of him that was to come. Romans 5:14
This verse implies that there were some who did not sin.
 
Last edited:
Mary wasn’t sinless so like everyone else was in need of a Savior.
Catholics don’t deny that Mary need a savior. Her Immaculate Conception wasn’t because she deserved it, but to glorify God. The sacrifice of Christ was applied to her at the moment of her conception, so she still benefited from Christ’s sacrifice.
 
Last edited:
Just to touch base on Thomas Aquinas…

First, he always believed that abortion is immoral, even in early stages. He just did not believe that there was another human person present in the womb until 40 to 80 days after conception. This was not in itself just a metaphysical principle or a theological principle, but was based on outmoded embryology. He didn’t have the modern scientific understanding of how fertilization and conception occurred. He didn’t have a modern understanding of embryonic and fetal development (or of cells and genetics and DNA). The understanding of embryo development he had at the time is the reason why he did not believe that an embryo had a rational soul. If he had a modern understanding of when it became a unique being, his conclusions may have been different, and he certainly would submit to the Church’s views on the matter. But even if he didn’t think aborting a new embryo was killing a human person, he still thought it immoral and contradictory to the natural law.

As for the Immaculate Conception, his views on that were also influenced by his understanding of embryology and the development of the soul from vegetative to sensitive to rational in the womb. An immaculate conception didn’t make sense in that context, though he did think that Mary was graced and purified of original sin pretty much immediately after the rational soul appeared (which again, was based on an outdated embryology and theory of ensoulment). Given a modern understanding of conception, again, his views on the Immaculate Conception may have been different. Certainly, applying his metaphysical principles to the modern science can lead us to conclude that it is certainly possible (without needing to refer to defined doctrine.

What’s wonderful in east and west is that we both hold that the Blessed Virgin Mary, the Theotokos, the All-Holy, was without sin.
 
Last edited:
The Bible says nothing about Mary the Mother of Jesus coming from immaculate conception
Explicitly, and in those exact words, no. However, the Bible that the Catholic Church compiled and safeguarded for centuries, is full of implicit and material sufficiency for this Dogma.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top