Catholicism to Atheism

  • Thread starter Thread starter Haborym
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Aleii,

If God manifested himself to man in a sufficiently explicit way to convince all men of all time that he exists, then there would be no choice but belief. In that sense one might be able to suggest a loss of free will on that score.

My problem with your demand for explicit evidence sufficient to convince all men of all time does not “directly” involve free will in and of itself. Man could still choose to turn from the Creator just as Lucifier did. My problem with your demand is what it does to the relationship of man and God.

Fallen man is not prepared for such a relationship with God in this life. Man would believe in God without faith, but would do so with great fear. The fear would not be generated by God threatening man, but simply the natural and appropriate fear man would feel in the presence of the Creator. This is not part of the plan that God has for man. God’s plan is that man comes to know, love, and to serve Him in this life so as to be eternally happy with Him in the next. Under God’s plan you get what you want.
 
No, I would simply like to know how to best study for the crucial exam. Would you be OK with getting a physics exam one day in your art class that determined your graduating status?

I responded to a person stating that if God revealed himself to us in a crystal clear way, our free will would be compromised. This is what I did not understand. I do not see how these points address how knowledge compromises free will.And how would this betray free will?

Simply because a lot of people do something, does not make it right. Fallacy: Appeal To Widespread Belief (Bandwagon Argument, Peer Pressure, Appeal to Common Practice)

I don’t know about you, but I can not choose to believe in Zeus right now even if I wanted to, nor can I choose to believe in the Catholic God. Faith is not a light switch.
 
Actually we are not having to prepare for 2 subjects like a physics test in art class. The subject is religion. You have the information in front of you: Islam, Judaism, Christianity etc… It is like studying for an algebra test. You have solving equations, story problems, etc… In any one subject there are many facets. All you have to do Aleii is study. YOU HAVE THE INFO. If you are unwilling to study you will flunk. Don’t try to escape the situation by saying there is too much to know. I don’t mean to sound harsh but I am truly concerned for you. You sound like a smart person Aleii. What you need to do now is open your heart. Too many atheists are only willing to rely on science. I understand the notion to rely on science as the end all to finding answers. I work in the healthcare field and have had to use science all through my academics.

I find it interesting that atheists will deny there is a God on lack of proof when there is no proof suggesting God doesn’t exist. Even modern science today isn’t sure how things began. I believe this is called the moment of singularity if I’m not mistaken in which physicists can mathematically calculate the history of the earth up until the very beginning. Then their theory evaporates into thin air.

I guess what i’m trying to get at Aleii is that faith and reason go hand in hand. I choose to believe in Christ because I believe that if there is a God who created us, Christ’s message of love is what that God would want to be taught. He made us in his image and considers us his children. Coming from a father’s perspective the way God is with us is exactly how I want to be with my kids. I want to be loving but with rules. Strict but willing to let them learn.

As for the free will point you were getting at. I understand it. If God did reveal himself to us fully how would that take away our free will? I see how you are right that we could still choose to sin etc… I guess I should have maybe been a little more specific. If God were to reveal himself to you fully right now it does take away the choice to believe. That choice to believe is part of free will (the free will to believe or not). Once he reveals himself there really isn’t a decision to be made. We know he exist and our free will to believe or not is gone.

Why does that matter you ask? Why doesn’t God just reveal himself so we all believe? Because God wants to know we love him not from our minds but from our hearts. In order to do that a greater manner than knowledge is necessary…faith. I know God revealed himself to some in the old testament and to the apostles as Christ so why not everyone. These men were the messengers of God’s word. We are here to either accept that message or deny that message.

I pray you accept it.
 
Aleii,

You’re welcome…discussing things with you is always easy because of your courteous approach.

God Bless.
 
Unfortunately I do not have the money to pick up the entire list - which do you think, out of those, provides the best defense?
That’s why there are things called libraries–and inter library loans
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top