Catholics and Nazism

  • Thread starter Thread starter Fidei
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

Fidei

Guest
How do i respond to anti-catholics showing pictures of bishops attending Nazi ceremonies and saluting the “Sieg Hail” and shaking hands with the Fuhrer?

How do i refute these photos?

Its really getting annoying seriously…
 
I’ve seen the photo with Vatican officials and Nazi representatives. But what you will never see from these hate sites is the context of the photo. What I find ironic is the color theme of these web sites, white, black and red: the colors of the Third Reich.

*Pope Pius XI signed a concord with Germany to secure the rights of Christians in the country, because the Vatican recognized what a threat Hitler and his henchmen were to religious liberty. This was not an endorsement of the Nazi Party or its philosophy (it may be remembered that America also had treaties with Germany before the war broke out). *

*When Hitler went back on the deal and began abrogating the civil rights of Christians, the Vatican responded by issuing the only encyclical ever written in German (Mit Brennender Sorge or “With Burning Anxiety”), concerning the horrors of the National Socialist German state. This encyclical was smuggled into Germany (it would never have been allowed in, had the Nazis known it was coming) and read at all the parishes on the same day. *

*The Encyclopedia of Catholic History (by Matthew Bunson) notes: “the encyclical was a strong denunciation of Nazism, noting that the Nazis had broken several points of the concordat and were actively involved in anti-Catholic and anti-Christian programs, such as the removal of the OT [Old Testament] from schools and the promotion of the so-called German National Church. The encyclical was read from the pulpit of every German church on March 21, 1937” (p. 563). *
cin.org/users/james/questions/q058.htm

If they don’t give you an apology for malicious slander against your Church, you are wasting your time. Demand it nicely and leave if they don’t.
 
In addition, I have never seen photos of bishops shaking hands with the Fuhrer. There is one with Cardinals signing the Concordat with Nazis, but Hitler was not in it, and it was before the war broke out. If there was such a photo, it would have been a well circulated scourge among anti-Catholic web sites.

There is sufficient evidence of Hitler plotting to kill or kidnap the Pope, so making the Church out to be a collaborator with Nazism is just crazy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top