Catholics, if you found yourself on an all-Protestant planet, what would your church choice be?

[CleverUserName]

Ok CleverUserName which one would you be joining based on the responses.
http://forums.catholic-questions.org/member.php

WELS Lutheran

 

[CleverUserName]

Yes, I would find that subtly insulting. As a practicing Catholic, if I am to lead others to what I believe is the fullness of Christian faith, I do so through example and attempts to get the two churches to see eye-to-eye on certain things (for a start, and for my part).

Protestants are protestants because they want to be, whether or not that changes in the future. Completely invalidating all of their choices up to the present, and presenting them a scenario in which they should choose anything but what they currently believe and practice “just because”? I cannot see the value, sorry. Many of the responses here seem to concur.

And further, to say it was done in order to lighten the “anti-Protestant mood” on the boards, after the above explanation? This is why I think it could simply be naive…I don’t know Clever User Name enough to know if there’s anything else behind the idea, and I choose not to believe so without good reason. Clever’s, rather snippy little comments in the first of the thread, to those who didn’t think highly of the whole thing, don’t seem to me to be in the spirit of reducing “anti-Protestant mood” on the board, however.

I simply don’t understand why someone who doesn’t care for the question feels the need to come to the thread and leave a negative comment. I simply said if you dont like it, dont participate. I don’t think that’s “snippy”. I think that’s good advice.

I mean, if I don’t like the topic of a thread, I move on. I don’t stop and say “you made a bad topic, I dont like it”. Your persistent and repetitive slams in this vain speaks volumes for your character. “I dont like it so I’m going to stay here and stomp my foot and keep saying I don’t like it! I need someone to agree with me that this is unlikable!! I dont like it! Whaaaah! Whaaah :crying:”

Just for clairify THAT ^ was a tad snippy.

The fact that you are STILL HERE in this thread that YOU DON’T LIKE says that you are looking for attention and just trying to start trouble. Your kind is easy to figure, really.

See watch this: I can control you completely. You are at my command.

I command you to comment on this thread again.

Do it.

(You won’t be able to help yourself…like I said, your type is easy).

Prove me right.