Manny,
Ignorance sometimes comes across disguised as arrogance.
Ignorant “Arrogance” is many times the defensive barrier the anti-Catholic has put up against Catholic education to avoid a fear of potential embarassment, either public or private from misunderstanding or misrepresenting the faith.
The “Arrogance” against the Catholic Church, may or may not come from their reading a book or two, or even parts in a sermon against “religious” people, then accepting that anti-Catholic propaganda without actually asking a Catholic what the Church officially teaches, and writing of the Church as a whole, as just another denomination, or something worse.
Please keep in mind that charitably correcting error of a “pick and choose” or “cafeteria” Catholics (defined as not accepting ALL Catholic teachings e.g. anti-abortion, anti-birth control ect…,) can be just as difficult to have a disscussion with as a closed-minded Protestant.
Since the Catholic Church was established by Christ Himself on St. Peter the first Pope, the Truth is on your side.
Being outright Catholic is a great thing. It could be as simple as praying before a meal at a resteraunt and making the sign of the cross in public to the disdain or amazement of nearby Protestants, who find it offensive, because they are evangelizing nearby non-believers.
(This just happened to me yesterday while I was about to eat at McDonalds)
What I have discovered from personal experience is that most of the “typical” anti-Catholic discussions follow the same pattern of anti-Catholic bias or propaganda, and having a charitable discussion to educate the person about the true Catholic doctrince is largely a matter of having the education to refute their misconceptions with ease.
Whats at stake in these disscussions is not just a convert, but potentially the person’s refusal to admit that they have been wrong/misinformed/not educated on a particular Catholic doctrine or belief.
To me, success in a typical religous debate is more a matter of being educated for oneself on Catholic beliefs/doctrine, and charitably meeting the other person at their point of misunderstanding, with the hope that they could be removed from their ignorance. Frustrating, Yes. Impossible? No.
And hey, even if you don’t convert a person on the spot, the next time they say something ignorant against the Pope, for example, they will probably think next time. (Hopefully

)