Catholics shouldn't listen to Protestant objection

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mannyfit75
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
First one should be very careful when identifying who is closed to the Truth. Manny is right, verbal evangelizing may well be ineffective:

Titus 3:10 Warn a divisive person once, and then warn him a second time. After that, have nothing to do with him.

Matthew 7:6 Do not give dogs what is sacred; do not throw your pearls to pigs. If you do, they may trample them under their feet, and then turn and tear you to pieces.That being said, no one knows whose hardened heart God might soften. So therefore, always preach the Gospel and sometimes use words. That’s what I recommend! 🙂
 
When someone comes saying, “You worship Mary!” And we say “No we don’t.” And they say "Yes you do!
Yes you do! Yes you do!" what are we to do? Many of us will keep trying to knock some sense into them,
:yup:

I am, quite simply, a stubborn person. Some of what I read makes sense, but I can’t let go of my old beliefs. Fear is usually the reason I suppose.

I think the main reason not to get impatient, discouraged, or quit is b/c of the lurkers. Me included. I’ve decided to back out of a lot of the conversations and just read for a while. Please don’t forget about people like me you don’t hear from very much, but who value your insights 😃
 
First one should be very careful when identifying who is closed to the Truth. Manny is right, verbal evangelizing may well be ineffective:

Titus 3:10 Warn a divisive person once, and then warn him a second time. After that, have nothing to do with him.

Matthew 7:6 Do not give dogs what is sacred; do not throw your pearls to pigs. If you do, they may trample them under their feet, and then turn and tear you to pieces.That being said, no one knows whose hardened heart God might soften. So therefore, always preach the Gospel and sometimes use words. That’s what I recommend! 🙂
Well stated, my friend.
 
Manny,

Ignorance sometimes comes across disguised as arrogance.

Ignorant “Arrogance” is many times the defensive barrier the anti-Catholic has put up against Catholic education to avoid a fear of potential embarassment, either public or private from misunderstanding or misrepresenting the faith.

The “Arrogance” against the Catholic Church, may or may not come from their reading a book or two, or even parts in a sermon against “religious” people, then accepting that anti-Catholic propaganda without actually asking a Catholic what the Church officially teaches, and writing of the Church as a whole, as just another denomination, or something worse.

Please keep in mind that charitably correcting error of a “pick and choose” or “cafeteria” Catholics (defined as not accepting ALL Catholic teachings e.g. anti-abortion, anti-birth control ect…,) can be just as difficult to have a disscussion with as a closed-minded Protestant.

Since the Catholic Church was established by Christ Himself on St. Peter the first Pope, the Truth is on your side.

Being outright Catholic is a great thing. It could be as simple as praying before a meal at a resteraunt and making the sign of the cross in public to the disdain or amazement of nearby Protestants, who find it offensive, because they are evangelizing nearby non-believers.

(This just happened to me yesterday while I was about to eat at McDonalds)

What I have discovered from personal experience is that most of the “typical” anti-Catholic discussions follow the same pattern of anti-Catholic bias or propaganda, and having a charitable discussion to educate the person about the true Catholic doctrince is largely a matter of having the education to refute their misconceptions with ease.

Whats at stake in these disscussions is not just a convert, but potentially the person’s refusal to admit that they have been wrong/misinformed/not educated on a particular Catholic doctrine or belief.

To me, success in a typical religous debate is more a matter of being educated for oneself on Catholic beliefs/doctrine, and charitably meeting the other person at their point of misunderstanding, with the hope that they could be removed from their ignorance. Frustrating, Yes. Impossible? No.

And hey, even if you don’t convert a person on the spot, the next time they say something ignorant against the Pope, for example, they will probably think next time. (Hopefully 😉 )
 
You’re right, HannahLisa, but it seems to me as if the OP is really just venting some frustrations with the hardheadedness of many who come onto these forums to preach to us. We are all hardheaded at times, yes, but many of these people are not interested in a discussion. They’re here to shout. We’ll respond to their objections, and rather than replying to those objections, they’ll repeat what they said before, but more forcefully. What more can we really do?

When someone comes saying, “You worship Mary!” And we say “No we don’t.” And they say “Yes you do! Yes you do! Yes you do!” what are we to do? Many of us will keep trying to knock some sense into them, but it gets frustrating when the argument never moves anywhere at all.

Your profile says you go to school in TX. Either you to to A&M or you know about the weirdness there (I went there). I remember there were two male dorms where the guys would sit outside and yell, “Hey, we’re better than you!!” == “No, we’re better!” Then it would quickly dwindle to “@!$% you!” == “@!$% you more!” That’s how I see these these conversations, at least the futility of them, if not the content.
That’s very true. I don’t think I completely understood the original post – there is a distinction being made but it is not as clear as it could be. At some point you have to and should end the argument. I guess I just feel like that point should be after it’s clear that they’re being ridiculous and willfully refusing to understand.

I actually don’t know anything about weirdness at A&M…I go to University of Dallas (small liberal arts private Catholic college) and love it. 🙂

Manny – I listen. I don’t agree with everything, but I still listen. Otherwise I wouldn’t be on these forums. I want to listen, so I will know what Catholics actually believe. I also was blessed to grow up in a church which did not tell the absurd lies about the Church, so I didn’t have any of these negative preconceived notions which too many Protestants come in with.
 
I think seeds of truth can be planted during debates as well as other times, in people who are seeking truth as well as those who think they already know it.
 
There is a distinct difference between “discussion” and “argument”, and I share Manny’s frustration with the hard-headed Protestants who won’t even consider “our side”.

So, yes, there are times when it’s prudent to disengage, with charity, from a pointless argument. Sometimes it’s difficult, as evidenced by the occasional baiting over in the Scripture forum for things like “Sola Scriptura”, where someone clearly fits Manny’s catagory of those Protestants who won’t listen.

I look at these “hard-heads” as a challenge; a way to hone apologetic skills. And you never know, what seeds the Almight might plant through us may take hold later on…🙂
 
Of course, tell me does this really pertain to you? I mean if you are one of those Protestants who doesn’t grasp the Catholic faith, then you have a problem.
I grasp it far better than I did a year ago. But again, there’s a difference between understanding the beliefs and agreeing with them.
It is one or the other. Someone here claim we Catholics give thanks to statues.
Correct – it is one or the other. But that I say it’s “one” doesn’t mean that I don’t understand that you believe, and why you believe, the truth is actually “the other”. Understanding and agreement are simply not the same!

You seem to have the view that anyone who truly understands Roman Catholicism will automatically agree with it, or is openly rebelling against God. There’s another option – understanding, but because of different upbringing, preconceptions and/or other life factors, coming to a different conclusion.
I call them "proud"estants
This sort of bias would be no better than me calling you a “papist” or a heretic, etc. I sincerely hope those words were “spoken” in the heat of the moment without thinking, and don’t reflect your true feelings.
I wish more people were like him with whom we dialog here, it would make things a whole lot easier. 🙂 Thank you PCM. 👍
I wish more people were open-minded…on both sides of the fence.
And I agree when he wrote that many times people have cultural barriers (at least that’s how I read your comments) to accepting the Catholic faith. Catholicism isn’t just a set of beliefs, it’s an entire “worldview” with sub-cultures all its own.
What I meant relates not only to cultural barriers, but religious, and most importantly moral ones. In short, our entire upbringing is to blame to some degree – it shapes our thinking process. This is not only the reason that individuals come to faith for differing reasons, but it’s also the reason we disagree so often.
Other Protestants, who keep on denying what Catholics say about our own faith, are often speaking more from emotion than from reason.
There’s a difference between denying what you say is the truth, and denying that you believe it.
The very idea of being wrong scares them because if the Catholic Church is right they would have to reverse themselves completely on several issues or give up some of their own most cherished beliefs, such as being assured of salvation by means of having a “personal relationship” with Jesus. They simply can’t seeing themselves doing those things.
I’d say you’re right – but the very same thing can (and certainly does) apply to many Roman Catholics. To many, sacraments, rituals, confession, rosary prayers, liturgy, and such are very appealing. The thought of being wrong about these things is very unappealing. No one, Roman Catholic, Protestant, or other, wants to be wrong, and I think sometimes it’s as much of an issue of self-pride as it is of objective truth, even for those of us who claim to be open-minded.
I think seeds of truth can be planted during debates as well as other times, in people who are seeking truth as well as those who think they already know it.
Absolutely!
There is a distinct difference between “discussion” and “argument”, and I share Manny’s frustration with the hard-headed Protestants who won’t even consider “our side”.
I share it too…but I also have some frustration with the Roman Catholics who are equally closed-minded.
 
This sort of bias would be no better than me calling you a “papist” or a heretic, etc. I sincerely hope those words were “spoken” in the heat of the moment without thinking, and don’t reflect your true feelings.
I forgot to throw in one of these: 😉 at the end of my post. No, those are not my true feelings, no worries there.

It was a reflection on the minority group that I have had experiences with that you can’t even have a conversation with. They are a minority as well. I’ve only run into 1 or 2 people to date who were truly militant, and even then they were semi-charitable.
 
40.png
Della:
I wish more people were like him with whom we dialog here, it would make things a whole lot easier. Thank you PCM.
PC Master:
I wish more people were open-minded…on both sides of the fence.
Well, that depends on what you mean by “open-minded,” doesn’t it? If you mean we each stick to our own beliefs because we firmly believe them, I’m with you. But, I think Manny is trying to say that there are those who will not admit that what Catholics (and some Protestants) say about their own beliefs is what they truly believe/practice. There are Protestants who consider liturgical Protestants just as “deceived” as Catholics, and believe such Protestants are just as doomed as Catholics, according to their way of thinking. Does that make sense? 🙂
40.png
Della:
And I agree when he wrote that many times people have cultural barriers (at least that’s how I read your comments) to accepting the Catholic faith. Catholicism isn’t just a set of beliefs, it’s an entire “worldview” with sub-cultures all its own.
PC Master:
What I meant relates not only to cultural barriers, but religious, and most importantly moral ones. In short, our entire upbringing is to blame to some degree – it shapes our thinking process. This is not only the reason that individuals come to faith for differing reasons, but it’s also the reason we disagree so often.
So true!
40.png
Della:
Other Protestants, who keep on denying what Catholics say about our own faith, are often speaking more from emotion than from reason.
PC Master:
There’s a difference between denying what you say is the truth, and denying that you believe it.
Yes, but the Protestants to whom I am referring can’t/won’t/don’t make that distinction. These sort think with their emotions not their brains. Of course, there are Catholics who don’t know why their own Church teaches what it does, whose feelings are what they base their faith on, as well. Such Catholics need better catechises not to be prosyletized out of their faith, as some Protestants clearly try to do to them.
40.png
Della:
The very idea of being wrong scares them because if the Catholic Church is right they would have to reverse themselves completely on several issues or give up some of their own most cherished beliefs, such as being assured of salvation by means of having a “personal relationship” with Jesus. They simply can’t seeing themselves doing those things.
PC Master:
I’d say you’re right – but the very same thing can (and certainly does) apply to many Roman Catholics. To many, sacraments, rituals, confession, rosary prayers, liturgy, and such are very appealing. The thought of being wrong about these things is very unappealing. No one, Roman Catholic, Protestant, or other, wants to be wrong, and I think sometimes it’s as much of an issue of self-pride as it is of objective truth, even for those of us who claim to be open-minded.
Our sacraments, etc. are meaningful to us because we understand what they are and why we have them. The sacraments are means of grace and the other things helps to prayer. We know this, but many Protestants of the kind we are bemoaning will not see that but insist, idiotically, that we have to agree that they are what they say they are and give them up. 🤷

I was such a Protestant at one time, which is what I was talking about–not that you would know that, nor were my remarks directed at you personally but at Manny and others who are frustrated with those Protestants who are not only close-minded but will not acknowledge that Catholics do not need them to tell us what we believe/practice.

Their skewed ideas are just plain laughable to anyone who is willing to understand what the Church says about its own beliefs/practices. You are not the sort of Protestant Manny is frustrated with. And as such I imagine you would find such Protestants frustrating too if they came to you and told you your denomination was deceiving you and that what you claim you believe/practice isn’t actually what you say. Do you see what I mean with all my poor words? 😊 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top