Co-thread Tolkien movies

  • Thread starter Thread starter ETEXAS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh boy. I loved Tolkien but not Jackson. Yes, Jackson truly mangled the stories. First off, the kindly English pubs which were portrayed by places such as the Green Dragon, which overflowed with hospitality and warmth were completely redone by Jackson. It looked more like the Wild Wild West than Middle Earth. It was only mid way through the first movie that I suddenly realized that Jackson had entirely omitted the chapter called Fog on the Barrow Downs as well as the character Tom Bombadil(really wanted to see what they were going to do with him and was undoubtedly disappointed).
Gimli was portrayed as a meanspirited and violent drunkard. Tolkien never specifically alluded to getting drunk at all. Certainly Samwise said goodbye to the beer barrel in the cellar before leaving Bag End but he did not stagger away from it as Jackson portrayed them doing in the movie after Bilbo’s party.
Aragorn was the worst. Aragorn in the novel knew who he was, with only a vague reference to any moments of self-doubt. Aragorn according to Jackson was a complete wimp who could never seem to make up his mind about anything.
Legolas according to Jackson was little more than a rebellious skater kid.
Nobility and virtue in most of the characters as written by Tolkien was completely lacking in Jackson’s variation of the story.
One of the great appeals in the books is the constant back and forth between home and security and danger and the unknown. Hospitality of strangers is abundant in the books but absent from the movies. I would like a chance to visit Tolkien’s Middle Earth. Jackson’s Middle Earth has no romantic appeal whatsoever.
I could say much more than this. Including the praises. Gandalf and Gollum were particularly well done by their respective actors. Saruman also was very well done, as likewise were the portrayals of Theoden and Eomer and Eowyn.
The agape love between Frodo and Sam was severely undermined by the actor playing Frodo who was so emotionally dry and lacking in enthusiasm that he may as well have never left Bag End, had he been an actual hobbit.

But sheesh. The CG was brilliant and beyond all my complaints it was a valiant effort. I only wish they had been more true to Tolkien’s original vision.
Ditto Thank you! You summed up many of my own regrets! I think Jackson was…a horrid choice to do this project…just me though!🙂
 
Oh boy. I loved Tolkien but not Jackson. Yes, Jackson truly mangled the stories. First off, the kindly English pubs which were portrayed by places such as the Green Dragon, which overflowed with hospitality and warmth were completely redone by Jackson.
What are you talking about? Jackson’s Green Dragon looked pretty close to the description you gave.
It looked more like the Wild Wild West than Middle Earth.
What is?
It was only mid way through the first movie that I suddenly realized that Jackson had entirely omitted the chapter called Fog on the Barrow Downs as well as the character Tom Bombadil(really wanted to see what they were going to do with him and was undoubtedly disappointed).
See posts above as to why they couldn’t include Tom Bombadil he completely stops the narrative momentum, and Tolkien himself hated him.
Gimli was portrayed as a meanspirited and violent drunkard. Tolkien never specifically alluded to getting drunk at all. Certainly Samwise said goodbye to the beer barrel in the cellar before leaving Bag End but he did not stagger away from it as Jackson portrayed them doing in the movie after Bilbo’s party.
I believe they show Gimli getting drunk once, and it was in the extended edition of ROTK. There is no such scene that shows Sam “staggering” away from Bilbo’s party, and even if so, so what? There was undoubtedly alcohol at the party, and Hobbits are not renowned for their temperance.
Aragorn was the worst. Aragorn in the novel knew who he was, with only a vague reference to any moments of self-doubt. Aragorn according to Jackson was a complete wimp who could never seem to make up his mind about anything.
As with this entire post, you are greatly exaggerating. Would you prefer Aragorn to be a static character through 9 hours of film?
Legolas according to Jackson was little more than a rebellious skater kid.
And on what do you make that statement? The one 5 second clip (albeit stupid) of him using a shield to slide down stairs in Helm’s Deep? Where do you get “rebellious” from? What did he ever do that was rebellious?
Nobility and virtue in most of the characters as written by Tolkien was completely lacking in Jackson’s variation of the story.
One of the great appeals in the books is the constant back and forth between home and security and danger and the unknown. Hospitality of strangers is abundant in the books but absent from the movies. I would like a chance to visit Tolkien’s Middle Earth. Jackson’s Middle Earth has no romantic appeal whatsoever.
What do you mean it’s absent? The Hobbits seeking refuge in Rivendell, the Fellowship seeking refuge in Lothlorien, Merry and Pippin being helped by Treebeard, the Hunters being given horses by Eomer and then shelter by Theoden? If they stopped every three minutes to have a stranger hand them a bowl of soup and a blanket, a lot of the dramatic tension would be gone. I really feel you’re grasping at straws here now.
I could say much more than this. Including the praises. Gandalf and Gollum were particularly well done by their respective actors. Saruman also was very well done, as likewise were the portrayals of Theoden and Eomer and Eowyn.
I actually agree here, with the exception of the praise of Eowyn. She was abysmal.
The agape love between Frodo and Sam was severely undermined by the actor playing Frodo who was so emotionally dry and lacking in enthusiasm that he may as well have never left Bag End, had he been an actual hobbit.
 
Yuck thanks to the prior poster for at least agreeing on the HORRID Jacksons Eowyn!:eek: What was Jackson smoking…🤷
 
Yuck thanks to the prior poster for at least agreeing on the HORRID Jacksons Eowyn!:eek: What was Jackson smoking…🤷
Tolkien Eowyn isn’t that good either. Seriously, she falls in love with Faramir in like 2 pages. The line is literally “her feelings for Aragorn melted away and were replaced with Faramir”. Worst written and most unrealistic romance ever. It sounds more like Stockholm Syndrome.
 
Tolkien Eowyn isn’t that good either. Seriously, she falls in love with Faramir in like 2 pages. The line is literally “her feelings for Aragorn melted away and were replaced with Faramir”. Worst written and most unrealistic romance ever. It sounds more like Stockholm Syndrome.
LOL…in fairness to Tolkien … he never built her up as much as Jackson…she “thought” she loved Strider as she had seen in him a possibility of renewal of life it as if she sensed in him a latent power , but Tolkien…keeps her farther “emotionally” from Strider! Jackson has poor Eowyn in an “I almost have him!!!” State… at best…at worst he turns her into an obsessive Boader-line Stalker! :eek: LOL…poor Eowyn…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top