Communion at Episcopal liturgy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaughterSorrow
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Whether or not a particular group of non-Catholics believe in the Real Presence isn’t the point.
  1. Think about what “communion” means…that you are in communion with that group. If someone is Catholic, then by definition they’re not in communion with Episcopalians, Methodists, Presbyterians, or some other Christian community. Perhaps someday there will be unity, but it’s not there now.
  2. Catholics are obligated to obey the teachings of the Church and one of those teachings is that we are not to receive communion in other Christian communities. Non-Catholics can tell us to ignore the teaching, but why should we listen to them rather than our own Church?
On this, as on all things taught, you should listen to your Church.

GKC

Anglicanus Catholicus
 
Not so.
To support ‘protestantism’ is to support something whose origins are in a movement in opposition to the truth.
i.e. you cannot have a firm belief in the one true church and at the same time in a movement opposed to the same one true church.
At least have the courage of your convictions and believe in your own faith, as the dalai lama once said.
Wow.

Best of luck to you.
 
40.png
Theolog:
Your presence, and therefore “support” should be in favor of common Christian mission and common Christian belief which unites and doesn’t destroy.
Well Theolog, if you think we are united why don’t you be Catholic.
In fact, why does’nt everyone be Catholic.
Its because…
 
The scriptures say that whoever does not discern the body of the Lord brings condemnation onto himself.

So if you believe God’s word you couldn’t take part in a so called communion where not only was the body of the Lord not discerned because noboby believed in the body of Christ being substantially present there

Bu

the Body of Christ actually not being there becasue there was no valid priest to consecrate the accidents.

Attending such a service makes one guilty of many sins!
 
The scriptures say that whoever does not discern the body of the Lord brings condemnation onto himself.

So if you believe God’s word you couldn’t take part in a so called communion where not only was the body of the Lord not discerned because noboby believed in the body of Christ being substantially present there

Bu

the Body of Christ actually not being there becasue there was no valid priest to consecrate the accidents.

Attending such a service makes one guilty of many sins!
It’s not attending the service that is sinful; it’s partaking of their supposed “Eucharist”.

Peace,
Dante
 
Your initial post - #29 - seems to not be limited to an understanding of the Eucharist, which doesn’t really differ as much as some Roman Catholics like to pretend it does. We’re all talking about Real Presence, at least in the mainline denominations, you use transubstantiation to explain how that presence takes place - but the immensity of belief is the same. To exclude yourself from the worship of others by your own choice is obviously your own decision, however sad it might be to me. But your sweeping indictment of the beliefs of others is what creates anti-RC sentiment, even among Catholic-minded, (and Catholic-educated) so-called “protestants” like myself.

For instance, you said, “To avoid giving the impression that their mistaken beliefs and objections were valid.” This presumes all protestant beliefs to be invalid, and that there are blanket objections in the first place.

Your presence, and therefore “support” should be in favor of common Christian mission and common Christian belief which unites and doesn’t destroy.
The difference however is Christians accepting the doctrine of the Real Presence. The possibility of the bread and wine actually becoming the Body and Blood of Christ.

and

The actuality of the Real Presence in a particular place and circumstance.

I agree that many Christians believe that the transformation into the Body and Blood of Christ is possible, but many do not understand that it does not occur outside of the Catholic Mass or Eastern Divine Liturgies (including Orthodox) without a validly Ordained Priest.
 
It must feel pretty good to have cornered the market on Jesus, grace and Eucharistic legitimacy! 😃

Of course, I wouldn’t know. I invalidly worship several times a week in an invalid church with invalid Christians hearing an invalid gospel invalidly preached while receiving an invalid “supposed” Eucharist ministered by an invalid priest who is in invalid orders. 😦

Funny how all that illegitimacy brings me closer to God, builds my faith and makes me love my neighbor more and more. They should burn in hell for that! :mad:
 
It must feel pretty good to have cornered the market on Jesus, grace and Eucharistic legitimacy! 😃
It must feel pretty good to use hyperbole rather than try to understand what’s going on. 😉
Of course, I wouldn’t know. I invalidly worship several times a week in an invalid church with invalid Christians hearing an invalid gospel invalidly preached while receiving an invalid “supposed” Eucharist ministered by an invalid priest who is in invalid orders. 😦
Worship of God is not “valid” or “invalid”. Christians are not “valid” or “invalid”. Gospel preaching is not “valid” or “invalid”

Again. It’s easy to use hyperbole to try and make a point. Much more difficult (and, in the end, rewarding) to try to LEARN what ‘valid’ or ‘invalid’ mean,to what they apply, and why.
Funny how all that illegitimacy brings me closer to God, builds my faith and makes me love my neighbor more and more. They should burn in hell for that! :mad:
Nowhere in Catholic teaching does it say that God’s Grace is limited to valid sacraments or orders. Again: hyperbole isn’t helpful.
 
It was actually intended to be sarcasm.

Condescension doesn’t help either, but that seems to be the norm here!
 
It was actually intended to be sarcasm.

Condescension doesn’t help either, but that seems to be the norm here!
Ok, sarcastic hyperbole, then 😉

I completely (and sadly) agree with you about the tone that’s often found here (or anywhere religion is discussed online). I hope you didn’t take my response as condescension as it wasn’t intended to be.

You’re obviously smart enough to do the research as to why the Catholic Church teaches what it does regarding the validity/licity of orders and sacraments and I’d encourage you to do so rather than take to heart the explanations of certain triumphalistic internet Catholics who may become an occasion for sin for you.

Again, I apologize if I came across negatively. I intended my comments to be aimed at constructive dialogue and not polemics. (although I do enjoy the occasional snarky ribbing 😃 )
 
Granted. May I PM you for occasional snarky ribbing so that we might both get our fix? :o
For the most scholarly account of the RC position on Anglican orders (and all orders, by implication, Francis Clark’s ANGLICAN ORDERS AND DEFECT OF INTENTION (Clark was in orders when he wrote it, was laicized shortly after).

For the best presentation of the Anglican case, Fr. J. J. Hughes’ two books ABSOLUTELY NULL AND UTTERLY VOID and STEWARDS OF THE LORD. (Fr. Hughes had an interesting history, himself).

I hope someone reads these books, some day.

GKC
 
It must feel pretty good to have cornered the market on Jesus, grace and Eucharistic legitimacy! 😃

Of course, I wouldn’t know. I invalidly worship several times a week in an invalid church with invalid Christians hearing an invalid gospel invalidly preached while receiving an invalid “supposed” Eucharist ministered by an invalid priest who is in invalid orders. 😦

Funny how all that illegitimacy brings me closer to God, builds my faith and makes me love my neighbor more and more. They should burn in hell for that! :mad:
An invalid “church” yes, and an invalidly Ordained priest, consecrating an invalid “Eucharist”, yes.

An invalid Gospel, no, and invalid Christians, of course not!

God’s grace does work outside the Catholic Church and the Spirit is found in other Christians.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top