B Br.Rich_SFO Guest Sep 27, 2008 #21 redrosetea said: I understand but the could uses lots of water and little wine …the wine is watered Click to expand... Lots of water and little wine invalidates the matter.
redrosetea said: I understand but the could uses lots of water and little wine …the wine is watered Click to expand... Lots of water and little wine invalidates the matter.
D Digitonomy Guest Sep 28, 2008 #22 Seatuck said: Wine is required matter for a valid consecration. Click to expand... Wine is only required for valid consecration of itself. The absence of wine does not affect the validity of consecration of the bread. Seatuck: If anyone only received from the chalice they would not receive communion. Click to expand... This is correct for the example given. Nonetheless, there would still be a Holy Sacrifice of the Mass assuming bread was consecrated.
Seatuck said: Wine is required matter for a valid consecration. Click to expand... Wine is only required for valid consecration of itself. The absence of wine does not affect the validity of consecration of the bread. Seatuck: If anyone only received from the chalice they would not receive communion. Click to expand... This is correct for the example given. Nonetheless, there would still be a Holy Sacrifice of the Mass assuming bread was consecrated.