Could man be happy without God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter marica_mandic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If I recall right from what I’ve been reading, humans are created to seek happiness. While humans are given free will, they are not created to choose unhappiness. Even when a choice leads to being unhappy, it is always because the choice was perceived as leading to happiness (this is what the devil takes advantage of to tempt us into sin).

The greatest happiness humans can seek out is God. Hence, humans must seek out God or they will not be happy… as any lesser happiness cannot be equated to God.
Freuds theory of the ID, basic instincts. “Seek pleasure and avoid pain”.

Im not sure, even though I’ve found God im still unhappy and angry alot (not at God, just in general). As I see it you cat really define ‘happiness’ as needing to come from God. We all have two sides of happiness, the lighter side (the feeling of happines when helping others or doign the right thing) and the darker side (the feeling of joy from destruction ie. Like a child may get by destroying another childs sand castle).
 
Freuds theory of the ID, basic instincts. “Seek pleasure and avoid pain”.

Im not sure, even though I’ve found God im still unhappy and angry alot (not at God, just in general). As I see it you cat really define ‘happiness’ as needing to come from God. We all have two sides of happiness, the lighter side (the feeling of happines when helping others or doign the right thing) and the darker side (the feeling of joy from destruction ie. Like a child may get by destroying another childs sand castle).
I’ve heard that it’s our own defects that make us unhappy and irritable.

What I’ve been told and what has helped is we need to learn to see all things that happen to us as occasions for our growth in the virtues. From red lights, bad traffic to tough courses, irritable people, tiredness, “friction” in the daily life. Patience, fortitude, courage, cheerfulness.

All of these things - if viewed with a supernatural perspective - can become opportunities for growth and union with God.
 
I think an atheist can think they’re happy, but if you ask one who finds God later in life, they will often tell you how much happier they are now. 😃
 
Freuds theory of the ID, basic instincts. “Seek pleasure and avoid pain”.

Im not sure, even though I’ve found God im still unhappy and angry alot (not at God, just in general).
I think you misunderstood my train of thought. What I was referring to was the Beatific Vision.

I’m taking from my notes, as I have been reading up about the intellect, the will, appetites, and other theological information. I’ll just lay these points out, and you’ll have to explore these articles yourself. I won’t have time to debate or clarify. So, keep this mind when you read my post.

“Men cannot will evil as such, but they can will what is actually evil as long as it appears good in some way.” - 1965 Catholic Encyclopedia Articles on Will and Intellect.

The will is concerned with good itself or the good of the person. Free act of the rational appetite (the will) is known as choice.

The human will seeks the highest obtainable good which is known as happiness. The desire for happiness underlies all other desires. We are free to desire or not desire particular goods (freewill), but we’re not free to desire or not desire happiness. Man acts freely when he uses intellection along with his rational appetite (the will) to choose an action.

The highest obtainable good is happiness. The highest obtainable happiness is from God (Beatific Vision). Beatific Vision occurs when we are finally united with God in Heaven.

Since any other happiness (other than that which is God) is imperfect and temporary, it cannot be equated to God as it is lesser than it’s creator. hence, we cannot expect to be happy (in this life) until we are finally united with God (Beatific Vision) in Heaven.
 
“Men cannot will evil as such, but they can will what is actually evil as long as it appears good in some way.” - 1965 Catholic Encyclopedia Articles on Will and Intellect.

The will is concerned with good itself or the good of the person. Free act of the rational appetite (the will) is known as choice.

The human will seeks the highest obtainable good which is known as happiness. The desire for happiness underlies all other desires. We are free to desire or not desire particular goods (freewill), but we’re not free to desire or not desire happiness. Man acts freely when he uses intellection along with his rational appetite (the will) to choose an action.
This part seems a lot like Freuds theory on ID (our basic instinct ‘seek pleasure, avoid pain’), Super-ego (our selves molded by outside influences aka parents, teachers, friends. Basically what is socially correct) and the ego (what tries to monitor both and keep them happy but never indulge one side. That voice when you were a child that told you to eat your veggies because you knew you wouldnt get dessert afterwards :p).

Im not trying to start an arguement or debate, simply remarking on the similarities between the two. The difference between the two is Freud used his model in the ‘physical world’ and not the ‘spiritual’ thus Freud couldnt connect his model and ideal of ‘pleasure’ (this isnt nessacarily sexual pleasure, but pleasure of eating something sweet etc.) to God as he was a non-believer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top