Courting not Dating?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gregory24
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Gregory24

Guest
My cousin attends a “non-denominational” church and there the pastor has them read some book about courting. Basically they are instructed not to just date but “court” now he is in college and his now fiance’ is too. He told me that her parents believe that it is wrong to causually date someone and at any moment they feel that they would not marry this person that should be the end of the relationship. Does anyone know about this?
 
40.png
Gregory24:
My cousin attends a “non-denominational” church and there the pastor has them read some book about courting. Basically they are instructed not to just date but “court” now he is in college and his now fiance’ is too. He told me that her parents believe that it is wrong to causually date someone and at any moment they feel that they would not marry this person that should be the end of the relationship. Does anyone know about this?
Its all semantics. Dating and courting colloquially mean about the same thing, although there seems to be a greater influence in courting in seeking the approval of the woman’s family, where as dating is simply the act of going out on a social event together. Essentially, if you are courting a woman, you will eventually be dating her. If you are trying to court a woman and never take her on a date, she will drop you like a piece of seasoned hardwood, dry and uninteresting.
 
I’ve seen something on it.

I believe the ‘difference’ is this. With dating, it’s more casual. You date someone, if it doesn’t work out you move on to the next train wreck.

With courting, you’re ‘dating’ this person with the intent of marrying them. There seems to be more of a commitment with this idea of courting.
 
40.png
Dandelion_Wine:
I’ve seen something on it.

I believe the ‘difference’ is this. With dating, it’s more casual. You date someone, if it doesn’t work out you move on to the next train wreck.

With courting, you’re ‘dating’ this person with the intent of marrying them. There seems to be more of a commitment with this idea of courting.
On a similar line, casual dating can tern into courtship. There is nothing materially wrong with going out casually with someone to see if they are even worth the time and effort of courting. A simple social date with some light conversation can weed out a lot of potential train wrecks.
 
Basically they are instructed not to just date but “court” now he is in college and his now fiance’ is too.
There is something good about the idea. I don’t do the ancient courting routine, but there’s lots of it in my dating.
He told me that her parents believe that it is wrong to causually date someone and at any moment they feel that they would not marry this person that should be the end of the relationship.
Of course. Dating someone you know you have no intention of ever marrying is problematic to say the least. It defeats the purpose of marriage and human relationships of the romantic kind are supposed to lead to marriage. The moment you know the person you are dating is not the person you want to marry, he or she should be out. That relationship is pointless. How could anyone claim it’s right and proper to date someone one already knows one isn’t going to marry?

I must point out that even though differences apply, I believe both courting and dating should be exclusive. Hanging out with a friend is one thing and dating is not it. I believe non-exclusive courting is intrinsically wrong (and probably objectively evil) and non-exclusive dating doesn’t fall much short of that. In this, I’m aware that many Catholics disagree with my opinion (in the poll I made in The Water Cooler, the vote is 8 to 5 in favour of non-exclusive dating being OK for Catholics, which saddens me deeply).
 
I grew up in a conservative Protestant homeschool crowd, where courting was a VERY serious matter. I knew a lot of families that wouldn’t let their daughters go anywhere with a guy, so courting was done only in the company of her family. This is a very strict version. The rest of the time when I hear people talking about courting I think they are just reacting to what dating has become in our society, and they mean you should only go out with people whom you could possibly marry. So it really isn’t that different. I dated (we did call it dating, not courting) a great guy for a little over a year, with both of us knowing that we want to be married in the near future, and not just dating for recreation. It worked for me–we just got engaged a couple of weeks ago. 🙂

I think that the people who advocate courting, like the book I Kissed Dating Goodbye, have very good points, especially in regards to the dangers of people who are too young/unable for some reason to marry spending a lot of time paired off. I think that is not a good idea. I liked what Elisabeth Eliot said, that a young man who has no way to support a wife and is not ready for marriage has no right to demand the exclusive attention of a young woman.

:cool:
 
I liked what Elisabeth Eliot said, that a young man who has no way to support a wife and is not ready for marriage has no right to demand the exclusive attention of a young woman.
Until married, one has no right to demand any attention at all, and even when married it still depends on our definition of “demand”. The idea is not that a man gains such a right when he becomes ready for marriage and has a way to support a wife. The idea is that marriage creates such a right and when marriage is intended, a serious person won’t have any side-affairs (not like a side-affair is tolerable in the presence of a promise of exclusivity - in such an instance, it is plain old cheating).

At any rate, with the other person unwilling, one surely has no right to demand anything exclusive. But note that one doesn’t have to agree to a non-exclusive relationship. Right? Anything romantic which isn’t exclusive is promiscuous. I will repeat this over and over till I die.

If we take a classic dating scenario, it starts with the guy showing up at the girl’s door. Some flowers, some sweet talk, they go to the theatre or diner or dancing club or whatever. He walks her back and there is some little talk and a tiny little goodbye kiss. While this is far from engagement or marriage, let alone a sexual relation, one is not telling me that it’s OK to have this with multiple persons. Promiscuity is the only word I have for that.
 
Personally, I think dating someone who you wouldn’t marry is stupid. I figure, you never know when you’re going to meet “the one” so why be tied down to a dead-end relationship when you could be out meeting the love of your life?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top