J
Justin_Swanton
Guest
I have read the Ainulindale many times, and never saw in it a predetermination of how the various races would act, but rather an image of the Middle Earth to come. The most one can see in the great music is a fantasy version of predestination, which, in the context of Catholic theology, does not override the free will of any individual. Incidentally, if the elves do not have free will, then their wills are fixed - there is no via media.Not even the Ainur appear to have fixed wills. Consider Saruman’s fall and Osse’s repentance, and also Manwe’s belief in Melkor’s feigned repentance. I’ve worked out a way to reconcile these things with the idea of angelic fixed wills, via a combination of an idea in Lewis and a statement by Tolkien in The Silmarillion, but certainly the idea of fixed wills does not seem to be prominent in Tolkien. Free will is another matter- it would appear that Elves may not have it since the Great Music functions as fate for them, and if that’s so then if the Orcs were indeed bred from them (which does not appear to be certain) then it may follow that they too have no free will. This line of thinking obviously opens up new grounds for potential criticism though.
The Nazgul became evil by choice, corrupted by their lust for power. Orcs, trolls and other creatures who began their existence as evil are a special case in Tolkien’s world, and are clearly not meant to be analysed in the context of moral theology. Again, they are concrete depictions of evil, not a theology of it. I can see Tolkien getting impatient with this question. Would you say that Beowulf is morally problematic for Catholics given that Grendal begins and ends his days in evil?