CS Lewis or JRR Tolkien

  • Thread starter Thread starter mro
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Not even the Ainur appear to have fixed wills. Consider Saruman’s fall and Osse’s repentance, and also Manwe’s belief in Melkor’s feigned repentance. I’ve worked out a way to reconcile these things with the idea of angelic fixed wills, via a combination of an idea in Lewis and a statement by Tolkien in The Silmarillion, but certainly the idea of fixed wills does not seem to be prominent in Tolkien. Free will is another matter- it would appear that Elves may not have it since the Great Music functions as fate for them, and if that’s so then if the Orcs were indeed bred from them (which does not appear to be certain) then it may follow that they too have no free will. This line of thinking obviously opens up new grounds for potential criticism though.
I have read the Ainulindale many times, and never saw in it a predetermination of how the various races would act, but rather an image of the Middle Earth to come. The most one can see in the great music is a fantasy version of predestination, which, in the context of Catholic theology, does not override the free will of any individual. Incidentally, if the elves do not have free will, then their wills are fixed - there is no via media.

The Nazgul became evil by choice, corrupted by their lust for power. Orcs, trolls and other creatures who began their existence as evil are a special case in Tolkien’s world, and are clearly not meant to be analysed in the context of moral theology. Again, they are concrete depictions of evil, not a theology of it. I can see Tolkien getting impatient with this question. Would you say that Beowulf is morally problematic for Catholics given that Grendal begins and ends his days in evil?
 
Honestly it’s not so much time as being tired and lazy after a day of work. When/if I’m feeling up to really digging in to a difficult yet relatively trivial topic I’ll get going on this.
I can relate to this. It’s tragic the extent to which working for a living can get in the way of the more important things in life.
 
Those that come to mind off the top of my head:

-The idea that Frodo ultimately has permission to use the Ring, and especially the moment when he tells Gollum that if Gollum were to try to take the Ring he, Frodo, would put it on and order him to slay himself, and Gollum would have to do it. This is portrayed as a great, noble moment for Frodo but really it is positively Satanic. Not that I’m at all saying Tolkien was Satanic, but he had a definite laps of moral judgment when he wrote that passage, and there are other lesser ones along that line.
Do you mean the ending, when Frodo puts on the ring, in Mount Doom? That’s actually not portrayed as a noble moment, Tolkien talked about it as “Frodo’s fall”. Essentially, Frodo failed his mission, by putting on the ring. He never had the permission to use it, it is evil and can’t be used for good. Even in the movie, it’s not shown as a great moment.
-The idea that the kings of Numenor had the power to choose the moment of their death, and so they chose to die while still in control of their minds and bodies and let their sons reign before they too began to grow old. As the Numenorians degenerated the kings began to “cling to life” even into feebleness, and this is seen as a bad thing. If I recall Aragorn appears to have had this power and did the same thing, chose to die early to avoid old age and to let his son have a longer reign.
I don’t remember much of the background of Numenor, but maybe the whole point is how the later kings began to fear death or cling to their lives instead of wanting Heaven… I don’t know.
-The casual, probably unconscious racism in his works, especially LOTR. Consider for example the black-skinned, red-tongued “troll-men” of the far South and the squint-eyed, flat-faced men who were apparently hybrids between Men and Orcs.
I don’t know about this. I think we should also be careful about accusing the author of anything like that cause we don’t know his intentions of where the ideas are from. For example, there were people who thought that the Orcs symbolized Communists, or Nazis, etc, and Tolkien said that it’s not allegorical at all. (He was not fond of allegory).
-Arguably, the suicides of Turin and the pregnant Nienor, and in general that whole story whose point seems to be the impossibility of avoiding fate and the triumph of evil. Perhaps Tolkien would have had something to say in defense of the story, like that it is to his corpus of works something like what the book of Ecclesiastes is to the Bible, and indeed the ethic of the story is contradicted especially by LOTR, but still taken by itself it is potentially problematic.
I think it was their choice to kill themselves… they could have chosen not to do it. When I read this story, I thought mostly about how Turin fell into despair and this was the cause of his later actions.
-Arguably, the way lives of Orcs and Trolls seem to have no intrinsic value and should be ended in principle, and that there seems to be no hint of possible redemption for them, though it could be countered that after all they are not supposed to be human or derived from humans, with the possible exception of the Uruk-hai.
The orcs are not part of creation in Tolkien’s world… they were made by the dark lord, when he tortured elves. They are shown somewhat simplistically, I agree, but I don’t think there is much theological speculation on them except that they were made by the dark lord. (not created from nothing, but by misusing creation for his own purposes… because of course the devil can’t create). I think that orcs were never meant to be complex characters, there are other evil characters that are, like Gollum.
-Arguably, an overly fond depiction of drunkenness.
I think it’s more about having a drink in a pub… maybe something common in Tolkien’s day, in his culture… rather than being drunk.
I’m sure I’ll think of others later. Don’t get me wrong, I love Tolkien overall, but you did ask for what I thought was morally problematic in his works. Again, I’m not aware of anything close to this in Lewis, though I think Lewis was sometimes a bit too much of a Platonist.
I am not familiar with Platonists… could you elaborate on what you mean? I remember Platonists being mentioned somewhere, i think in the Space Trilogy.
 
Those that come to mind off the top of my head:

-The idea that Frodo ultimately has permission to use the Ring, and especially the moment when he tells Gollum that if Gollum were to try to take the Ring he, Frodo, would put it on and order him to slay himself, and Gollum would have to do it. This is portrayed as a great, noble moment for Frodo but really it is positively Satanic. Not that I’m at all saying Tolkien was Satanic, but he had a definite laps of moral judgment when he wrote that passage, and there are other lesser ones along that line.

-The idea that the kings of Numenor had the power to choose the moment of their death, and so they chose to die while still in control of their minds and bodies and let their sons reign before they too began to grow old. As the Numenorians degenerated the kings began to “cling to life” even into feebleness, and this is seen as a bad thing. If I recall Aragorn appears to have had this power and did the same thing, chose to die early to avoid old age and to let his son have a longer reign.

-The casual, probably unconscious racism in his works, especially LOTR. Consider for example the black-skinned, red-tongued “troll-men” of the far South and the squint-eyed, flat-faced men who were apparently hybrids between Men and Orcs.

-Arguably, the suicides of Turin and the pregnant Nienor, and in general that whole story whose point seems to be the impossibility of avoiding fate and the triumph of evil. Perhaps Tolkien would have had something to say in defense of the story, like that it is to his corpus of works something like what the book of Ecclesiastes is to the Bible, and indeed the ethic of the story is contradicted especially by LOTR, but still taken by itself it is potentially problematic.

-Arguably, the way lives of Orcs and Trolls seem to have no intrinsic value and should be ended in principle, and that there seems to be no hint of possible redemption for them, though it could be countered that after all they are not supposed to be human or derived from humans, with the possible exception of the Uruk-hai.

-Arguably, an overly fond depiction of drunkenness.

I’m sure I’ll think of others later. Don’t get me wrong, I love Tolkien overall, but you did ask for what I thought was morally problematic in his works. Again, I’m not aware of anything close to this in Lewis, though I think Lewis was sometimes a bit too much of a Platonist.
W…W…W…Wow. :eek: :bowdown:
 
Okay…to everyone that posted on this thread: I love you all, even the OP who was banned apparently.

I want to contribute but my brain isn’t quite cooperating. W…w…Wow. (and I mean those Ws to be pronounced with a hard breathing mark, like “hWu” Best Tolkien exegesis I’ve read for a long time.
 
I’m going to cheat and do this like everyone else did. Aelred Minor, you, sir, are a scholar.
Those that come to mind off the top of my head:

-The idea that Frodo ultimately has permission to use the Ring, and especially the moment when he tells Gollum that if Gollum were to try to take the Ring he, Frodo, would put it on and order him to slay himself, and Gollum would have to do it. This is portrayed as a great, noble moment for Frodo but really it is positively Satanic. Not that I’m at all saying Tolkien was Satanic, but he had a definite laps of moral judgment when he wrote that passage, and there are other lesser ones along that line…
Never thought of that moment as “satanic” but I see where you’re going and it makes sense. Now we all KNOW that Tolkien wasn’t writing an allegory, but the ring definitely was “applicable” to sin in general. Gandalf once admitted having “put the fire” to gollum to get information, and this moment could be seen as a kind of coercian method in the same light; essentially sometimes torture is warrented (I was re-reading FotR while all this waterboarding scandal was happening).
-The idea that the kings of Numenor had the power to choose the moment of their death, and so they chose to die while still in control of their minds and bodies and let their sons reign before they too began to grow old. As the Numenorians degenerated the kings began to “cling to life” even into feebleness, and this is seen as a bad thing. If I recall Aragorn appears to have had this power and did the same thing, chose to die early to avoid old age and to let his son have a longer reign…
This has always bothered me. That Aragorn did “choose” his moment to die and I felt it was vague about whether or not this was a kind of ritual suicide (as Denethor’s death seems to imply). I think it was part of the realism that he attempted to add, not that it was necessarily good that they did this, but that it was part of Numenorean/Gondor culture.
-The casual, probably unconscious racism in his works, especially LOTR. Consider for example the black-skinned, red-tongued “troll-men” of the far South and the squint-eyed, flat-faced men who were apparently hybrids between Men and Orcs…
Yeah I agree. But that was a different time. The Moors had always been the “bad guys” for him I suppose. But as was said somewhere else, the racism exists and yet Legolas and Gimli’s friendship stood against it.
-Arguably, the suicides of Turin and the pregnant Nienor, and in general that whole story whose point seems to be the impossibility of avoiding fate and the triumph of evil. Perhaps Tolkien would have had something to say in defense of the story, like that it is to his corpus of works something like what the book of Ecclesiastes is to the Bible, and indeed the ethic of the story is contradicted especially by LOTR, but still taken by itself it is potentially problematic…
I think Turin and the failure of Frodo are a further comment on the elves “fighting the long defeat.” I think Tolkien attempted to portray 1. Satan exists tangibly and attacks people, 2. Sometimes Satan wins battles 3. Our only real hope in the end is God. The victories are God’s, not ours. We participate, but in the end we cannot save ourselves. It also harkens back to the Song of the Valar, and no matter how Melkor attempted to dominate the song, Illuvatar always wove new themes around his chaos, saying “And thou, Melkor, shalt see that no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite. For he that attempteth this shall prove but mine instrument in the devising of things more wonderful, which he himself hath not imagined.”
It was said that Turin was going to return at the “final battle” and it was news to me when Jharek Carnelian said “Tolkien’s] notes show that he considered having Turin and Nienor cleansed by the Valar due to their great suffering and that Morgoth may have been slated to be destroyed at the hands of Turin wielding the black sword.” That would be consistent with the basic theology of the world.
-Arguably, the way lives of Orcs and Trolls seem to have no intrinsic value and should be ended in principle, and that there seems to be no hint of possible redemption for them, though it could be countered that after all they are not supposed to be human or derived from humans, with the possible exception of the Uruk-hai…
Tolkien made it pretty plain that the Uruk-hai were half orcs (half human/half orc) and the reality of that is extremely disturbing, as it must involve the rape of human women. But Tolkien went to war and I’m sure he saw a number of true horrors and knew that true horrors gave his fantasy world verisimilitude.
-Arguably, an overly fond depiction of drunkenness. .
Well of course.

Has anyone ever brought up that LotR has at least three (3) literary Christs? Frodo, the suffering servant, Gandalf, a kind of Markan Christ, always on the move “the Son of Man has no place to lay his head,” and Aragorn, the apocalyptic king, going down to the lands of the dead to release the “oathbreakers”? Alright, I’m not even going to check this for grammar errors. :eek: POST!
 
Rereading what I wrote, I’m embarrassed. So much to say, so little brain cells…:o
 
Has anyone ever brought up that LotR has at least three (3) literary Christs? Frodo, the suffering servant, Gandalf, a kind of Markan Christ, always on the move “the Son of Man has no place to lay his head,” and Aragorn, the apocalyptic king, going down to the lands of the dead to release the “oathbreakers”? Alright, I’m not even going to check this for grammar errors. :eek: POST!
I think that Fr. Barron brings this up in his discussion of LOTR (its on Youtube somewhere) I get the point, but connecting Frodo to Christ seems a bit problematic to me since Frodo ultimately does give in to the temptation of the Ring at the end.
 
I think that Fr. Barron brings this up in his discussion of LOTR (its on Youtube somewhere) I get the point, but connecting Frodo to Christ seems a bit problematic to me since Frodo ultimately does give in to the temptation of the Ring at the end.
A Literary Christ isn’t meant to be allegorical every time (like the overt allegory of Aslan and the stone table), but that a character functions in ways reminiscent of Christ. And of course Tolkien, in the forward to FotR explicitly says that the LotR is not an allegory, even though he admits in his letters that he meant it to be a “Catholic” story, even alluding that Galadriel was a kind of Virgin Mary figure, and yet Galadriel has very little in common with Our Lady’s story point for point.

Frodo gives into the ring, which then becomes a moment like Peter, James and John falling asleep during Gethsemane, in Christ’s darkest hour, a betrayal, but it’s the long arm of grace–“the Pity of Bilbo”–which reaches him then, that Gollum is still alive to steal the ring when Frodo couldn’t have destroyed it himself (further echoing the passage I quoted in my last post from the Silmarillion) and it becomes that specific grace, the Pity of Bilbo–that ends Sauron and the ring. And of course Gollum, my precious. gollum
 
Tolkien would probably be horrified by my post here. But I’m applying his symbolism, I think, in a very rational comparison. Quite applicable, yes my precious.
 
Well, that’s sure a different ending! How to reconcile that with Turin’s final murder, despair and suicide is hard to fathom though. Perhaps when he wrote this he had a slightly different version of the story in mind? In the more “canonical” accounts Turambar seems to be an ironic name, since his whole story was a long defeat at the hands of Fate. Here he turns it around in a much more Christian way (except we lack an explanation of what happened between his falling on his sword, which also breaks in an apparent suicide if it can be phrased that way, and Dagor Dagorath to make sense of the transformation).
 
I think that Fr. Barron brings this up in his discussion of LOTR (its on Youtube somewhere) I get the point, but connecting Frodo to Christ seems a bit problematic to me since Frodo ultimately does give in to the temptation of the Ring at the end.
An account I’ve read which, in broad strokes, seems to work is to view the Christological connections with the characters of LOTR in terms of typology.

In the Old Testament for example, Moses is a “type” of Christ, a prefigurement of sorts in salvation history. However, ultimately Moses was not Christ and fell short of what he was called to do, and was punished by not being allowed to enter the Promised Land.

In the case of Frodo, we could say we have a type of Christ the self-sacrificing priest. On the other hand we have Frodo’s failure at Mount Doom.

In the case of Gandalf, we have a type of Christ the prophet and wonder-worker, and a sort of hint at the idea of a ragged pilgrim who is actually divine in some way. But even Gandalf is not above error- his mistakes regarding Saruman for example.

In the case of Aragorn, we obviously have a type of Christ the King and Bridegroom (with Arwen as a type of the Church), but of course Arwen is not a Church and Aragorn has his moments of doubt, like his inability to decide whether to go to Mordor or Gondor, and when he declared in desperation that all his choices have proved ill.

In each case, or at least very clearly the cases of Frodo and Aragorn, there’s actually an interesting phenomenon of someone making the wrong choice, yet providence somehow making the best of it- a very interesting side issue.

There’s also a typological connection to be drawn between Lembas and the Eucharist (similar to the typological connection between Manna and the Eucharist in the Bible). The list could go on.

Anyway, my point is that there are many ways a character in a novel might be connectable to Christ, and in this case I think the lens of typology works pretty well.

I don’t know if Tolkien would approve, but he did see his fiction as a mythology he had invented, and he saw the life of Christ as basically the True Myth to which all other myths pointed somehow. I think it makes sense then that in making his own myths he would, whether fully consciously or not, use themes which could fairly easily be connected to Christ.
 
I’m just going to cherry-pick a few things from older posts.
Do you mean the ending, when Frodo puts on the ring, in Mount Doom? That’s actually not portrayed as a noble moment, Tolkien talked about it as “Frodo’s fall”. Essentially, Frodo failed his mission, by putting on the ring. He never had the permission to use it, it is evil and can’t be used for good. Even in the movie, it’s not shown as a great moment.
That’s not what I mean. Frodo’s failure on Mount Doom was obviously meant to be seen as a failure, but simultaneously it serves as the most prominent example of a constant theme of the book- providence bringing good out of evil. In retrospect we should have predicted that Frodo, who couldn’t even bring himself to throw the ring into his little fire at Bag End which couldn’t even melt regular gold, would not be able to throw the ring into the destroying fire of the Cracks of Doom in the heart of Mordor, and after bearing the ring so long and using it several times. But out of his virtually inevitable failure and the selfish treachery of Gollum providence still brought about the hoped-for victory. Very profound.

What I’m referring to is an earlier episode right near the beginning of the relationship between Frodo and Sméagol.
The orcs are not part of creation in Tolkien’s world… they were made by the dark lord, when he tortured elves. They are shown somewhat simplistically, I agree, but I don’t think there is much theological speculation on them except that they were made by the dark lord. (not created from nothing, but by misusing creation for his own purposes… because of course the devil can’t create). I think that orcs were never meant to be complex characters, there are other evil characters that are, like Gollum.
Just to be clear, it doesn’t seem that the account, mentioned in the movies, that the orcs were descendents of Elves who had been captured and tortured by the first Dark Lord, was ever the definitive answer to the question of where the orcs came from. An alternative theory was that they were descendents of ancient Drúadan (the Woses or Wild Men of LOTR) who had been twisted by Morgoth. In any case whether they had free wills or not, the idea of an apparently irredeemable intelligent race is potentially problematic, even if it’s pretty much a mainstay of Fantasy literature and to be expected.
I think it’s more about having a drink in a pub… maybe something common in Tolkien’s day, in his culture… rather than being drunk.
I’m not talking about some hobbits having a drink at the Green Dragon for example (in the book anyway; the movie’s brief clip of Sam staggering home from a night at the Dragon was obviously overboard, though not as bad as Legolas and Gimli’s drinking game at Edoras in the extended edition), more like the hobbits who inadvertently stayed behind at Bilbo’s party and had to be taken away in wheelbarrows, or even Bilbo’s song about the Man in the Moon. Or the drunk wood-elves in The Hobbit. Granted all three are ridiculous figures used for comic relief. You don’t have anything on the level of the drinking in the movies in terms of accepting drunkenness itself as wholesome. That’s why I said it’s arguable. Ultimately Tolkien’s own understanding of alcohol use may have been quite healthy (or it may not have been- I’m undecided), but I know for a fact that people who like going out and getting drunk (and smoking cigarettes and funkier things) have cited hobbits as an inspiration.
 
I didn’t think I was going to do this, but I actually went and found one of the actual passages in question in the book. I don’t think your interpretation of it eventually dominating Frodo holds with the whole tone of the speach.
‘I did not mean the danger that we all share,’ said Frodo. ‘I mean a danger to yourself alone. You swore a promise by what you call the Precious. Remeber that! It will hold you to it; but it will seek a way to twist it to your own undoing. Already you are being twisted. You revealed yourself to me just now, foolishly. Give it back to Sméagol you said. Do not say that again! Do not let that thought grow in you! You will never get it back. But the desire of it may betray you to a bitter end. You will never get it back. In the last need, Sméagol, I should put on the Precious; and the Precious mastered you long ago. If I, wearing it, were to command you, you would obey, even if it were to leap from a precipice or to cast yourself into the fire. And such would be my command. So have a care, Sméagol!’
Sam looked at his master with approval, but also with surprise: there was a look in his face and a tone in his voice that he had not known before. It had always been a notion of his that the kindness of dear Mr. Frodo was of such degree that it must imply a fair measure of blindness. Of course, he also firmly held the incompatible beleif that Mr. Frodo was the wisest person in the world (with the possible exception of Old Mr. Bilbo and of Gandalf). Gollum in his own way, and with much more excuse as his acquaintance was much briefer, may have made a similar mistake, confusing kindness with blindness. At any rate this speech abashed and terrified him. He grovelled on the ground and could speak no clear words but nice master.
Here we have a wise and magnificent Frodo Baggins, making a clear statement of what he would do in “the last need” if attacked by Sméagol. And what he boldly proclaims that he would do is one of the most terrible things imaginable: to use an evil instrument of magic to force someone to destroy himself. Sam is surprised and approves and we are seemingly expected to do the same.

I’m not willing to put the time in finding it, but I also distinctly remember being surprised the last time I read the book to notice for the first time a passage in which Frodo declares that he has positive permission from the Council to use the Ring. Combining these two, it would appear that Tolkien didn’t have the full idea of the Ring as a symbol of sin that must be destroyed rather than used for any purpose no matter how grave, which many fans have developed and which the movie suggested, nor a full consciousness of the concept, also I suspect developed by later fans, that ordinary folks should not use magic in fantasy literature. Certainly the general theme is there, instinctively perhaps, but at the end of the day to Tolkien the Ring is apparently simply too dangerous and corrupting a tool to keep in existence, not something that in principle may never be morally used by any person for any purpose.
 
I didn’t think I was going to do this, but I actually went and found one of the actual passages in question in the book. I don’t think your interpretation of it eventually dominating Frodo holds with the whole tone of the speach.

Here we have a wise and magnificent Frodo Baggins, making a clear statement of what he would do in “the last need” if attacked by Sméagol. And what he boldly proclaims that he would do is one of the most terrible things imaginable: to use an evil instrument of magic to force someone to destroy himself. Sam is surprised and approves and we are seemingly expected to do the same.

I’m not willing to put the time in finding it, but I also distinctly remember being surprised the last time** I read the book to notice for the first time a passage in which Frodo declares that he has positive permission from the Council to use the Ring**. Combining these two, it would appear that Tolkien didn’t have the full idea of the Ring as a symbol of sin that must be destroyed rather than used for any purpose no matter how grave, which many fans have developed and which the movie suggested, nor a full consciousness of the concept, also I suspect developed by later fans, that ordinary folks should not use magic in fantasy literature. Certainly the general theme is there, instinctively perhaps, but at the end of the day to Tolkien the Ring is apparently simply too dangerous and corrupting a tool to keep in existence, not something that in principle may never be morally used by any person for any purpose.
I do not remember such a passage.

I have also always understood the passage you quoted as Frodo speaking to Smeagol for his own good in the violent terms he would understand. Also as a foreshadowing/prophecy by Frodo of Gollum’s eventual end.

To answer the original question. As a story: Lord of the Rings (although Aslan’s "crucifixion’ scene in the book/movie had me sobbing). It was perfect. As commentary, probably CS Lewis.

Hard to separate the two really; they were such close friends, and rumor says that Lewis died a Catholic. If so, it was Tolkien’s doing (if any creature can take credit).
 
CS Lewis’s essays are powerful and topical in a way that Tolkien is not. But the imaginative scope of Middle Earth sets the standard for all that kind of writing, including the Narnia Chronicles.
Perfectly put. Much better than what I said.🙂
 
I read The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe in fifth grade and then read The Screwtape Letters over the summer. From what I remember, I loved The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe and thought that The Screwtape Letters was alright, though I liked some of the “advice” given to Wormwood and still recite some of it to myself in prayer or Mass (mainly the parts of getting distracted).

I’ve never read Tolkien but would love to. I have seen Fellowship of the Ring once and thought it was very well done. I need to re-watch it (and the rest of the films for the first time) again soon. Maybe over Christmas break when I’m home from school. If I like them I’ll read the books. I have all three books in one volume, which makes it a good 1000 page book with not so big print. Not something I can lug around, but I may start to read it now over break.

Personally, whenever I hear a Led Zeppelin song I think of J.R.R. Tolkien and Middle Earth. It has that feel to it, especially “The Battle of Evermore” youtube.com/watch?v=4axrTFBV3cU “Ramble On” even mentions Mordor. Zeppelin makes me want to read LOTR.

Something tells me I should read Tolkien.
Warning: LotR is “addicting”. I’ve read it over a dozen times :o
 
I think that Fr. Barron brings this up in his discussion of LOTR (its on Youtube somewhere) I get the point, but connecting Frodo to Christ seems a bit problematic to me since Frodo ultimately does give in to the temptation of the Ring at the end.
Frodo is not “all” Christ.

Christ is Priest, Prophet and King. Tolkein “splits Him up” as Frodo, Gandalf, and Aragorn.

EDIT: my apologies. This has already been dealt with. I was making my way through the thread. Sorry.
 
One more. Maybe I’ll get to more later, maybe not.
I have read the Ainulindale many times, and never saw in it a predetermination of how the various races would act, but rather an image of the Middle Earth to come. The most one can see in the great music is a fantasy version of predestination, which, in the context of Catholic theology, does not override the free will of any individual. Incidentally, if the elves do not have free will, then their wills are fixed - there is no via media.

The Nazgul became evil by choice, corrupted by their lust for power. Orcs, trolls and other creatures who began their existence as evil are a special case in Tolkien’s world, and are clearly not meant to be analysed in the context of moral theology. Again, they are concrete depictions of evil, not a theology of it. I can see Tolkien getting impatient with this question. Would you say that Beowulf is morally problematic for Catholics given that Grendal begins and ends his days in evil?
The Great Music was a flourishing of thought of the Ainur which was then in some way embodied in the created world. I forget exactly where it says it, whether in the Ainulindale or somewhere else in The Silmarillion, but Men are indeed the only creatures whose lives are not determined by that Great Music, which to all other things “is as fate” if I recall those exact words correctly. Also the Elves do not leave the confines of the World like Men do, to enter the timeless Halls of Iluvatar and eventually take part with the Ainur in the Second Music, but instead remain in Mandos from which they eventually emerge re-enfleshed like Glorfindel. Here I think we see an influence of the original Norse concept of elves as local spirits of certain places. Elves are more like the Valar in their power and beauty and deathlessness and connection to the earth, while Men are more like them in having Free Will and a supernatural vocation to the Beatific Vision (to deliberately slip into ordinary Christian language). It is because of this that Morgoth hates and fears Men, even those he deludes into serving him.

Now when it comes to the problem of evil we see a very Christian concept that evil comes about though the rebellion of free creatures against an “original” plan of God, but at the same time that evil just proves to be an instrument God uses to bring about better things than the forces of good would have produced on their own, and so ultimately nothing can be done which does not have its ultimate source in God. As Manwe said, in time even evil is shown to be good to have been. But as Mandos said, it still remains evil. It’s a very profound and accurate mix of predestination and free will.

However, the application to Elves and apparently Orcs, in light of an apparent lack of free will on their part, can be problematic. It would appear that when they are being good the Elves are essentially acting out good parts of the Music, and Orcs or the Elves when they are behaving badly are acting out bad parts of the Music, all ultimately culminating in something good of course. The problem is obviously the situation of having intelligent creatures with no free will, and, doubly problematic, having intelligent creatures with no free will who do evil.

Regarding Grendal, I would not expect an old Anglo-Saxon story to get much into the psychology of any of its characters, least of all its monsters, or to be theologically complex.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top