Defensive or abusive?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SDMom82
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The next day IS a knee jerk reaction…the hurt was fresh in his mind. It often takes ppl a few days to simmer down after they are upset. This is normal behaviour.

They are both being immature. They are both at equal fault.

I have to say that I have NEVER slapped my husband ever and I have been very very angry with him. It is wrong to slap someone b/c you’re angry.
Maybe the OP will continue to post to let us help her with things as they continue to unfold…I am hoping you are right, but my instincts tell me there is more…
 
and some of us confirmed it also in agreement.
I am thinking (and it is speculation since we don’t know this family personally) that what the OP really needs right now is to get beyond her self blame and look at the dynamics going on with her husband…I suspect, and it is only speculation, that there is alot going on with her husband, and would hate for the OP to “not see it” due to her own regrets about her momentary behavior. Just a hunch. Might be wrong. The OP already has shown much regret and desire to improve things…showing she is likely of good will…I have not heard that her husband has also voiced such…if he has, then praise our Good Lord…I am not out to blame anyone, just concerned that this woman may assign herself a “role” that she does not deserve…and have concerns based on several comments she has made that the situtation is stickier than presented…that she may be in a bad spot that is not proportionate to her tiny contribution… I don’t think further debate on this will be helpful, since none of us know the full dynamics, but I do hope we all leave this thread an inviting place for the OP to continue to share…the last thing she needs is us in an argument over her argument!!! LOL!
 
I am thinking (and it is speculation since we don’t know this family personally) that what the OP really needs right now is to get beyond her self blame and look at the dynamics going on with her husband…I suspect, and it is only speculation, that there is alot going on with her husband, and would hate for the OP to “not see it” due to her own regrets about her momentary behavior. Just a hunch. Might be wrong. The OP already has shown much regret and desire to improve things…showing she is likely of good will…I have not heard that her husband has also voiced such…if he has, then praise our Good Lord…I am not out to blame anyone, just concerned that this woman may assign herself a “role” that she does not deserve…and have concerns based on several comments she has made that the situtation is stickier than presented…that she may be in a bad spot that is not proportionate to her tiny contribution… I don’t think further debate on this will be helpful, since none of us know the full dynamics, but I do hope we all leave this thread an inviting place for the OP to continue to share…the last thing she needs is us in an argument over her argument!!! LOL!
agreed and benefit of the doubt should also be given to her husband.

CAF threads on marriage often get over the top b/c posters are too quick to make assumptions on the health of someone’s marriage.
 
I understand the confusion, but this part of the story does check out — “Balboa Park December Nights, the nation’s premier holiday festival, will take place for the 34th consecutive year on Friday, Dec. 2, 5-10pm, and Saturday, Dec. 3, noon-10pm”
Perhaps that explains it. I just hope we’re not getting too caught up in seasonal events that we’re blending it all together.
 
I disagree…abuse is still abuse. She abused him when she slapped him.

What a double standard!!! NO wonder abused men are afraid to speak up!
? Sorry, I don’t understand your response to that post. I was not referring to the slap in that post.

My sympathies would be for anyone abused male or female. Here, I can only respond to what she said. If she has lied and she is 182 lbs and slapped her 98 lb husband or lied in any other material way, it is her wrong and her sin.

As I said to her, she needs expert advice not ours. If she is abusing her husband, expert advice would still be needed.
 
I am thinking (and it is speculation since we don’t know this family personally) that what the OP really needs right now is to get beyond her self blame and look at the dynamics going on with her husband…I suspect, and it is only speculation, that there is alot going on with her husband, and would hate for the OP to “not see it” due to her own regrets about her momentary behavior. Just a hunch. Might be wrong. The OP already has shown much regret and desire to improve things…showing she is likely of good will…I have not heard that her husband has also voiced such…if he has, then praise our Good Lord…I am not out to blame anyone, just concerned that this woman may assign herself a “role” that she does not deserve…and have concerns based on several comments she has made that the situtation is stickier than presented…that she may be in a bad spot that is not proportionate to her tiny contribution… I don’t think further debate on this will be helpful, since none of us know the full dynamics, but I do hope we all leave this thread an inviting place for the OP to continue to share…the last thing she needs is us in an argument over her argument!!! LOL!
Good post.
 
? Sorry, I don’t understand your response to that post. I was not referring to the slap in that post.

My sympathies would be for anyone abused male or female. Here, I can only respond to what she said. If she has lied and she is 182 lbs and slapped her 98 lb husband or lied in any other material way, it is her wrong and her sin.

As I said to her, she needs expert advice not ours. If she is abusing her husband, expert advice would still be needed.
I humbly disagree so let’s agree to disagree. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top