Difficult sibling

  • Thread starter Thread starter Amalie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Amalie

Guest
My sister has been unkind to my parents for years and they have tolerated/enabled it. I have also enabled it because I just wanted her to love me, and I settled for less than appropriate behavior. She doesn’t take feedback or criticism well, so you have to be really courageous to confront her. And I’m trying get better about confronting people when needed rather than just pretending it’s ok.
For example- sister lived with mom and sad rent free for 5 years as a single mom. Parents tried to ask for rent and she always had excuses. Meanwhile I never moved back in, always paid my own way, paid my own student loans, worked multiple jobs, etc. she used to come “visit” my husband and I, but only when she needed a babysitter. Not to actually spend time with us.

Sister hasn’t contributed anything to my parents home/finances- it’s long and complex but my parents were in a real financial disaster because my dad has presumed CTE (from playing football and is impulsive and has a LOOONG history of depression, difficulty working. Mom had a hard time “managing” him because of her own stress and depression. I helped mom with finances for years, and invested a good amount of time and money into helping with home damage after a flood, and in helping fix up the house with repairs that needed to be done. Not much from sister. Actually nothing contributed. Which didn’t bother me because my sister and brother in law were trying to get financially on solid ground themselves. But then they would ask us for help with credit card debt etc. ( we said no).

This year mom got diagnosed with stage 4 cancer, and dad has mild dementia, and living alone in their home was too much to keep up with for them , both financially and chores /maintenance wise. My sister tried to move them in with her ( Even though I knew it wouldn’t work and warned her. ) Mom and sister fought like cats and dogs.my sister said some incredibly hurtful things about my parents including “I should charge them rent”. ( because she never paid rent? How is this logical? ). I moved my mom out with us and sister hasn’t called in 3 weeks. We have much less square footage for the 4 of us than they have but much more peace.
I’m trying to not judge. But I really think she’s a jerk. This is so painful. I feel like an orphan- no sister I can count on, losing mom and dad.
She has gotten away with being a jerk for a long time. I long for justice and for her to realize how selfish she is, and to change. I don’t want to “lower my standards” and teach her that her that this behavior is ok. It’s not. . Does anyone have siblings like this who have changed? I just want this cross to be over. I want her guardian angel to kick her in the butt and help her be giving and loving.

Im tired of being the only one running around trying to hold this family together when no one seems to care other than my mom. And she is dying. I’m just so angry I could cry.

Yes I have a counselor. And yes it was therapeutic to share this.
Other tips?
 
Last edited:
  1. Follow the strategies you and your therapist have decided on. (The two of you have the information needed to make these decisions; we on this site do not.)
  2. People change only when it benefits themselves.
  3. If she were my sister, I’d cut my losses and run; however, see #1.
 
I’d advise meditating on the second half of the story of the Prodigal Son. This dynamic in families has been around since the beginning of time, and Jesus talked about it.

Your prodigal sibling may not have yet returned to the family, leave that to the Holy Spirit.


He became angry, and when he refused to enter the house, his father came out and pleaded with him.

He said to his father in reply, ‘Look, all these years I served you and not once did I disobey your orders; yet you never gave me even a young goat to feast on with my friends. But when your son returns who swallowed up your property with prostitutes, for him you slaughter the fattened calf.’

He said to him, ‘My son, you are here with me always; everything I have is yours. But now we must celebrate and rejoice, because your brother was dead and has come to life again; he was lost and has been found.’”
 
But I really think she’s a jerk.
Sounds like an accurate assessment, based on the information provided here.

We can’t choose our family, but we can choose how we will or won’t interact and what boundaries we will put in place.

Keep working with your counselor. You need to set boundaries both for sister and for yourself. For example, a boundary for you should be to release any expectation you have of support (financial, emotional, helping with mom and dad) from her.

Your boundary for her could be that she can only come visit mom and dad when it works for you, so long as they are living under your roof.

When you leave your expectations at the door, it is amazing how much more joyful life can be because you aren’t constantly being disappointed by someone else.

And yes, unfortunately, some people are just jerks. They are born jerks, they live a life of jerkiness, and they die a jerk. It is hard to watch, but most families have at least one, it seems. It may not even be their fault, but you don’t need to have that vibe around you. Protect yourself and don’t feel bad about doing so. Find some lovely, supportive friends who understand what a healthy give-and-take relationship is all about.
 
Last edited:
trying to not judge. But I really think she’s a jerk. This is so painful.

John 7:24 Stop judging by outward appearances, and start … - Bible Hub


Stop judging by outward appearances, and start judging justly.” Berean Literal Bible Do not judge according to appearance, but judge the righteous judgment.

You are supposed to judge by the inspiration of the Holy spirit… This is related to the 7 gifts of the H.s in Isaiah 11 1-7.

It is difficult if you can’t hear the direction from the H.S

If you can’t do that then teach or tell them to practice " telling each other what they want to hear"
This is how communication starts understanding what each person “wants” to hear and believe

As I function in the 9 gifts of the H.S. I hear direction from H.S.

I have many examples. 1 is when I was told to travel from michigan to Portland Oregon. And work at a evangelist church. I also applied to work at a Wal-Mart and they called me to do the 2nd interview. And as I hung up the phone the H.S spoke and said " if you take that job it will inter fear with what I want you to do"
I answered the H.S .with what . job do you want me to do. The H.S. said I want you to apply to the Christian radio station and work there.as a DJ
So that’s what I did … And I got the job.

The H.S. speaks we need only to listen.

So may God bless you also.
 
Last edited:
For practical advice, may I suggest the More2Life radio show (11am NYC time, EWTN radio) or podcasts (let me know if you need links). This is a Catholic psychologist and his wife, and he has a great way of explaining how to set boundaries with people like your sister (which he gives every few shows).

Plus, I am sure you are very sad about your mother’s condition. I find myself, when in similar circumstances, really focusing a lot on some other much less important issue in my life. Sure, your sister is acting like a jerk, but is that the most important issue in your life right now?

What you are doing in caring for your mother is incredibly difficult and will probably get much more difficult. Don’t let your sister take your attention off the important things in your life. And gather your spiritual resources together now, so they will be in place when they become even more needed.
 
Last edited:
I have many examples. 1 is when I was told to travel from michigan to Portland Oregon. And work at a evangelist church. I also applied to work at a Wal-Mart and they called me to do the 2nd interview. And as I hung up the phone the H.S spoke and said " if you take that job it will inter fear with what I want you to do"
I answered the H.S .with what . job do you want me to do. The H.S. said I want you to apply to the Christian radio station and work there.as a DJ
So that’s what I did … And I got the job.

The H.S. speaks we need only to listen.
At what point did you go to Arizona?

@camoderator
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top