Diocese of Hong Kong Aggravating Liturgical Abuses in 2019-nCoV Epidemic

  • Thread starter Thread starter savedbychrist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

savedbychrist

Guest
Previous post:
40.png
Diocese mandating Communion in hand due to epidemic Traditional Catholicism
The 2019 Novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) is spreading in China, and two cases have been found in Hong Kong. The Diocese of Hong Kong, in response to the outbreak of this epidemic, has released a set of pastoral guidelines, which mandates that “all the faithful must stop receiving Communion on the Tounge, and receive on the Hand only”. (See the Original Document Article 2.8) [FB_IMG_1579794384576] [FB_IMG_1579794386922] . . . . Epidemic prevention is important, but the Communion is something diff…
I have emailed the Apostolic Administrator and the President of the Diocesan Liturgy Committee over my concern. Yet before they have likely read my mail, a set of updated pastoral guidelines was posted, pushing more ridiculous rules, after the government has raised the 3-tier response level from Level 2 to Level 3.

Excerpt from the new guidelines:
Article 2.11
The clergy and extraordinary ministers of the Holy Communion will distribute Communion to the faithful before taking Communion for themselves, lest their saliva be passed to the faithful.

Article 2.12
The clergy and extraordinary ministers of the Holy Communion should wear surgical masks when distributing Communion. They may also omit the reminder of “Corpus Christi”, and the receiver of Holy Communion may omit the response of “Amen”.

I’ve never heard before, that “Corpus Christi” and “Amen” were meant to be mere “reminders and responses”. I’ve been taught that it was a confession of faith to the real presence before receiving Jesus. We have already gone from “Corpus Domini nostri Jesu Christi custodiat animam tuam in vitam æternam” to “Corpus Christi” in 1969; and now we’re going from “Corpus Christi” to nothing at all. How effective would that be in preventing disease spreading? I am afraid there lies hidden agenda behind this “anti-epidemic pastoral guidelines”.

They have not even asked for an indult from the Holy See before making these changes that deviate from the requirements in the IGRM and reminders in the Redemtpionis Sacramentum. Now I feel like in the Diocese, the Apostolic Administrator is being his own Pope Francis, and the President of the Liturgy Comittee is being his own Cardinal Sarah.

For Chinese version of the updated pastoral guidelines, refer to this website:
 
In my opinion, things are getting a bit ridiculous. If it’s really this bad, people “might” not be able to attend Mass. It’s just not safe.
I am afraid there lies hidden agenda behind this
This whole epidemic is rather odd. The WHO and CDC still haven’t verified many of the claims being made by Chinese health officials.
 
Last edited:
If you go and look at videos and pictures posted on Twitter and Weibo from Wuhan, you will see that all of these temporary guidelines are totally called for and it’s better than stopping communion altogether. This virus is much, much worse than being reported or “confirmed” because the Chinese have simply stopped testing people. Their medical system is completely overwhelmed and the death rate with this is high…It’s very possible that this will be a worldwide pandemic if the Chinese cannot drastically turn things around.
 
Numbers can be pretty inaccurate at the early stage of an outbreak, but the current mortality rate of the virus is around 3%, compared to 1-2% for an average strain of influenza.

So it’s not (yet) a ton more deadly than the average flu, but the really big problem is that it is contagious before the person ever feels symptoms. So yeah… good luck containing something like that.
 
I’m actually more concerned, from a Christian standpoint, about a lot of people possibly getting sick than I am about whether some bishop on the other side of the world is suggesting that people “may” (voluntarily, it’s not a required “must”) skip saying “Corpus Christi” and “Amen”.

Seriously, people need to look at the big picture in a time of potential emergency.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top