Do Patients in a Vegetative State Recognize Loved Ones? [study suggests some do]

  • Thread starter Thread starter ethereality
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

ethereality

Guest
sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/12/131216155010.htm

Apparently some patients in a vegetative and apparently non-responsive state do respond to stimuli. This study may be good to share with science-minded associates critical of the Church’s position regarding healthcare for such patients.

What are your thoughts?
 
sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/12/131216155010.htm

Apparently some patients in a vegetative and apparently non-responsive state do respond to stimuli. This study may be good to share with science-minded associates critical of the Church’s position regarding healthcare for such patients.

What are your thoughts?
Yes, I have seen vegetative and “apparently non-responsive state” patients respond to both verbal and tactile stimulation. The perfect example was Terry Schiavo. She was believed to be in a vegetative and apparently non- responsive state. Yet, when Fr. Frank Pavone from Priests For Life went to her bedside side, she reportedly responded to his words and touch with eye contact. She had also reportedly made eye contact with her family.
 
I spent a year of training working with patients in comas, and those who had come out of comas but with severe brain damage – considered “vegetative”. Of the ones who came out of long term comas ( 3 weeks to 4 months) ALL of them who recovered most of their mental faculties reported that they heard conversations in their presence, were aware of people coming and going in their rooms, and could even repeat some conversations (much to the embarrassment of some of their caretakers!).

Those with severe brain damage (vegetative) usually responded to verbal and tactile stimuli, and often responded more vigorously to those they recognized who were with them on a daily basis, and especially to family members, smiling, moving their hands or arms, making eye contact, etc…

I would treat anyone in a coma (especially the terminally ill) as being able to hear and understand what is said in their room. When I worked Hospice/Terminal Care, I learned that hearing is the last faculty to fade away at death. We spoke to those in comas all the time, always explained what we were doing when getting ready to turn or bathe them, just as we would with a patient who was conscious. I believe they can still hear, and often understand a lot more than they seem to, even with severe brain damage!
 
Yes, I have seen vegetative and “apparently non-responsive state” patients respond to both verbal and tactile stimulation. The perfect example was Terry Schiavo. She was believed to be in a vegetative and apparently non- responsive state. Yet, when Fr. Frank Pavone from Priests For Life went to her bedside side, she reportedly responded to his words and touch with eye contact. She had also reportedly made eye contact with her family.
This is only my personal opinion, im certainly no expert on this kind of thing…but look at steven hawking he is in a state where he cant talk with his mouth, he cant walk, he cant feed himself, he cant do anything for himself…but when he is connected to his communication computer it proves that although his body is in a vegetative state, his brain is fully working
 
“Vegetative State” usually means the patient does not have brain function to respond with rather than working brain with no means to respond.

However, there are accounts of individuals near death that acquire knowledge and memory without brain activity.

So perhaps people can recognize others. Although they may have no means of telling anyone about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top