M
Melchior
Guest
I understand what you are saying Sue. But context is everything. Would you want to hear rap music replace hymns during Sunday Mass? I am guessing the answer is no because the style of music is not fitting for Mass. Are words the only content of music that matters? Don’t we always choose melodies and tunes that are appropriate to certain contexts? No Bach at a 1st birthday party because kids tunes are what is appropriate to the occasion.although we’ve gotten off topic here, I think it’s a matter of preference. who’s to say what kind of music is more pleasing to God? is one instrament better than another? suppose you went down to Harlum and saw a bunch of teenagers who looked really rough rapping about God. it sounds obsurd, but they do it. they turn over a trash can and drum on it to geta beat going and they rap about Jesus. isn’t that better than them rapping about sex and drugs? Who are we to say that they aren’t pleasing God?
Just because some people sing the Devine Nercy Chaplet in a jazzy tune, doesn’t make it any less holy. if they are singing it from their heart, what does it matter. as we mature in our faith, yes, we may grow away from that kind of music, but the people who are doing it in EWTN are youths. be glad they are there and not singing something else. All three of them have lovely voices and I find the melody easy to fallow and I sing along and dedicate every note along with every word to Jesus. maybe when I am 40, that won’t appeal to me anymore and I’ll stick with the more solomn and traditional one. just as I don’t sing the supper blessing in the tune to “are you sleeping” anymore.
We are to offer God our best, in the beauty of holiness. And the best for worship is not popular music. There is nothing wrong with pop music. But I think you make my point when you say it is a matter of taste. Is the music in this context for us (our entertainment) or our we singing to God?
I am sorry for getting off topic. But you did ask what we Protestants thought of the DMC. I like it alot when done reverently.
Further I hate when I people say it is a poor man’s rosary.
Mel