Do those who commit suicide go to heaven or hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornInMarch
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I believe I can say that a person who commits suicide will not go directly to Heaven simply because it is the logical conclusion when we consider the situation.

First I’ll say this. I don’t think there are very many HOLY people in the world who will go straight to Heaven, since all humans have imperfections and small sins that must be expiated.

Persons who commit suicide in their right mind, of their own free will, will go to Hell unless granted the grace of perfect contrition. So, if they are spared the punishment of Hell they will certainly go to Purgatory to expiate the terrible sin they just committed.

Persons who commit suicide because of intoxication, mental illness, or other problems also likely would have to go to Purgatory because of all the sins which led them into the destroyed emotional state that caused them to commit suicide.

I really don’t see where you are basing your objection to my very logical assumption. Since it’s not a stretch to say that almost everyone who does not go to Hell will go to Purgatory for a time, I don’t see how it is wrong to say that people who commit suicide are very unlikely to go straight to Heaven.
I don’t have the numbers but I would bet that the vast majority of people who kill themselves are not in their right mind.

It is not a logical assumption it simply what you believe to be true.

I was not raised with a God who would leave a very sick person out of heaven at not fault of his own.
 
The more that I look around, the more I believe that many who believe in God are in for a seemingly greater surprise concerning God than some of those that do not believe in God.
Which probably comes from looking around. The world is an extremely poor teacher.
 
Persons who commit suicide because of intoxication, mental illness, or other problems also likely would have to go to Purgatory because of all the sins which led them into the destroyed emotional state that caused them to commit suicide.
I don’t disagree with your argument in principle. However, I don’t think it is necessarily the case that those who commit suicide due to mental illness always are brought to the point of what you call a “destroyed emotional state” due to their own sins.
 
In other words, it is unfortunate to not be born mentally ill, because you don’t get a free pass to Heaven.

I understand what you’re saying Shelby, and it is completely fitting with Catholic theology and taught in the catechism concerning the factors that affect a person’s culpability to sin. It does not, however, pretend that these factors necessarily make sin disappear. There are good mentally ill people and there are evil mentally ill people, just as there are good people and bad people. All of this is known to God.

It is the disappointing reality of our age that in our insatiable quest to make sin disappear for our own peace of mind, we accomplish the exact opposite result.
I am not trying to make sin disappear, nor am I choosing to assume I know who and how is not going to hell. So severely autistic child sins and doesn’t even know it is a sin so cannot be truly sorry for it, he may not get into heaven.

It is also disappointing to see so many working so hard to point out every little sin in all those around him, rather than letting God do what He thinks is best.

Have you ever been around severely mentally ill people? Some barely appear to resemble human beings at all. Yes God knows all, that is why to speculate either way seems pointless because no one knows but God.
 
Are you God?
That’s a rather ridiculous question.
Did the person who is referred to as the “good thief” receive what you seem to consider “God’s infinite Justice”?

Seems to me that Jesus, God-Incarnate, meant right away with what He said to him who is referred to as the “good thief” but was probably an insurrectionist.

The more that I look around, the more I believe that many who believe in God are in for a seemingly greater surprise concerning God than some of those that do not believe in God.
I don’t understand the purpose of your post. Are you trying to say that God is not infinitely just? Are you trying to do away with the fact (at least in your own mind) that sin exists and satisfaction must be paid to God for the offenses done against him?

I really don’t understand what you are getting at here; please make yourself clear.
I don’t have the numbers but I would bet that the vast majority of people who kill themselves are not in their right mind.

It is not a logical assumption it simply what you believe to be true.

I was not raised with a God who would leave a very sick person out of heaven at not fault of his own.
I won’t object to what you said here, since much of it is true. However, there is something I have to say.

In response to your last sentence: I didn’t say anything about that. I said that I think it likely that a person who commits suicide will go to Purgatory, if they don’t go to Hell, regardless of their mental state. I think that is a less fantastic statement than saying that a person who is mentally ill would probably go straight to Heaven. That, there, is a very bold statement.
 
As someone who has lost a husband to suicide, I will relate what the priest at R’s Memorial (he was not Catholic) said to my daughters.

“Your dad was obviously not in his correct mind when he died. He could not have been, since we know he loved you. He would not want this pain to be visited upon you. His mental state was damaged. When he stands before God, he stands there with all his faults, failings, and his successes and good deeds before him. In between him and the Lord will be the love that you and your mom has for him. The love of his parents and his brothers. The love of his friends. God will weigh the love against the illness of his mind, and will show mercy.
You loved your dad. We will pray for his salvation. And we will ask God to extend His infinite mercy. THIS is what you can do for daddy right now. We will share in this prayer with you.”


Some will say this is correct and some will say this is misleading. All I know is that it was the first time my younger daughter was able to stop crying. He gave her the hope that she could be a part of her father’s healing, All we can do is love. All we can do is love. And forgive.
It’s not a definitive answer. But for us, it will do.
Peace.
 
That’s a rather ridiculous question.

I don’t understand the purpose of your post. Are you trying to say that God is not infinitely just? Are you trying to do away with the fact (at least in your own mind) that sin exists and satisfaction must be paid to God for the offenses done against him?

I really don’t understand what you are getting at here; please make yourself clear.

I won’t object to what you said here, since much of it is true. However, there is something I have to say.

In response to your last sentence: I didn’t say anything about that. I said that I think it likely that a person who commits suicide will go to Purgatory, if they don’t go to Hell, regardless of their mental state. I think that is a less fantastic statement than saying that a person who is mentally ill would probably go straight to Heaven. That, there, is a very bold statement.
Just to be clear, I didn’t say straight to heaven, but that is really not the point. My point was that none of us truly know what God will do with any of us. Someone that commits suicide because they are extremely mentally ill, may not be seen as all that different from those that are perfectly sane yet still sinners.

What I am trying to say is that most people that kill themselves have had a great deal of horror and pain in their lives:shrug: to get them to that point. Only God knows how much they have already suffered and if or when they should be given peace. I would never presume to have the answer to who and who isn’t going to heaven. I just work on doing what God would want me to do.
 
I think it is impossible to say, because some seemingly sane people can have temporary insanity when they go through extreme situations or extreme grief and in that instance kill themselves out of insanity of the moment. Just like when someone kills someone else out of temporary insanity when pushed to the brink and they snap. Also the side effect from some drugs can cause depression and suicidal tendencies and the person would not be in control in that situation even though they may seem fine on the outside. There’s so much to it that only God can be the judge. And like someone else said, a person can jump off a bridge in temporary insanity then come to their sense in the seconds before they hit and will repent just before dying. So only God really knows.
 
Also, I don’t think someone in their right mind could kill themselves. They may want to sometimes and may think about it, but to actually go through with it, they can’t be in their right mind. Because someone in their right mind will stop to think, how will this affect my children, my family, the state of my soul and afterlife etc. Do I want my children to grow up with that memory/wound, do I want to traumatize my kids or loved ones with them finding my body etc. People in their right mind think about things like what if they don’t succeed and end up crippling themselves and really making their life worse etc. People in their right mind think about things like that and can’t go through with it. I remember reading one true story of a near death experience where a young woman tried to kill herself by crashing her car, and she did die but God sent her back, and she ended up living but being crippled for life. However bad she thought her life was before got made worse after that attempt. So people in their right mind think about things like that. So I think someone has to not be in their right mind to actually go through with the act. However bad life may seem now, would someone not want to stand before God and look at Him having just killed themselves? I know I wouldn’t! No one can help you when you stand before God, not your mom or dad or family, and even prayer won’t help because the one you would pray to is the one you’re standing in front of having to explain your actions to! People in their right mind think about things like that especially if they believe in God.
 
There’s no way to know. But I DO know that one rarely (if ever) commits suicide while in a state of mind that would allow full/sufficient consent.
 
I believe I can say that a person who commits suicide will not go directly to Heaven simply because it is the logical conclusion when we consider the situation.
Is it the “logical conclusion” according to you, to human logic?

“My Ways are not your ways and My Thoughts are not your thoughts”, could be that God’s Logic might not be the “logical conclusion” that you come too.
First I’ll say this. I don’t think there are very many HOLY people in the world who will go straight to Heaven, since all humans have imperfections and small sins that must be expiated.
You can think whatever you want but that doesn’t mean that God has to go by what you think.
Persons who commit suicide in their right mind, of their own free will, will go to Hell unless granted the grace of perfect contrition. So, if they are spared the punishment of Hell they will certainly go to Purgatory to expiate the terrible sin they just committed.
The Church, as far as I know, has never “consigned” anyone to hell but yet you seem to be quite ready to do this, have you ever been at Mass when the “prayer” is prayed, “Lord, have Mercy on us ALL”?
Persons who commit suicide because of intoxication, mental illness, or other problems also likely would have to go to Purgatory because of all the sins which led them into the destroyed emotional state that caused them to commit suicide.
I would think that this is something that it up to God since God is our Judge, not you or anyone else.
I really don’t see where you are basing your objection to my very logical assumption. Since it’s not a stretch to say that almost everyone who does not go to Hell will go to Purgatory for a time, I don’t see how it is wrong to say that people who commit suicide are very unlikely to go straight to Heaven.
One of the things about how some seem to think of “God’s infinite Mercy” is how puny and petty this “infinite Mercy” seems to be.

And on the same note, one of the things about how some seem to view “God’s inifinite Justice” is how bloodsucking, cruel, petty, vindictive, without the slightest chance of any extenuating and/or mitigating circumstances entering in much less any thing even slightly hinting of mercy.
 
Contradiction? All I see is that you started with a false premise. God doesn’t “give people problems”. He tolerates evil in the world to give people the infinitely greater good of free will.
As far as "God doesn’t “give people problems”, isn’t this what the Church seems to refer to as “carrying one’s cross”?
That’s the problem of evil for you.
Could be that God, in God’s Plan, has given us the ability to be active participants in God’s Plan of Salvation for All rather than for us to just pick up our “get out of hell” card.
 
In other words, it is unfortunate to not be born mentally ill, because you don’t get a free pass to Heaven.

I understand what you’re saying Shelby, and it is completely fitting with Catholic theology and taught in the catechism concerning the factors that affect a person’s culpability to sin. It does not, however, pretend that these factors necessarily make sin disappear. There are good mentally ill people and there are evil mentally ill people, just as there are good people and bad people. All of this is known to God.

It is the disappointing reality of our age that in our insatiable quest to make sin disappear for our own peace of mind, we accomplish the exact opposite result.
As far as “It is the disappointing reality of our age that in our insatiable quest to make sin disappear for our own peace of mind, we accomplish the exact opposite result”, another “disappointing reality of our age” seems to be that many of us are taught the Jesus took ALL of the SINS of ALL upon Himself on the cross and yet we seem to think/believe that Jesus did this in vain.

On the cross, Jesus said, “Father forgive THEM, they know not what they do.”.

Seems to be what one’s view of “THEM” is in the above statement is how one looks at what Jesus says in this statement.
 
This is a simple question. If someone commits suicide out of depression, guilt, desperation, or other reasons, do they go to heaven or hell?
Hitler committed suicide out of desperation, and I reckon he’s going to hell, but not for the suicide.
 
To answer the question directly: We don’t know. Final destinations are the sole privy of God. You can speculate all you want, but suicide, as are all mortal sins, doom us if they are not repented and forgiven however not all suicide is mortal sin.

If only the Church would speak clearly on this…oh wait, She has! From the Catechism (bold part is mine)2281 Suicide contradicts the natural inclination of the human being to preserve and perpetuate his life. It is gravely contrary to the just love of self. It likewise offends love of neighbor because it unjustly breaks the ties of solidarity with family, nation, and other human societies to which we continue to have obligations. Suicide is contrary to love for the living God.

2282 If suicide is committed with the intention of setting an example, especially to the young, it also takes on the gravity of scandal. Voluntary co-operation in suicide is contrary to the moral law. **Grave psychological disturbances, anguish, or grave fear of hardship, suffering, or torture can diminish the responsibility of the one committing suicide. **

**2283 We should not despair of the eternal salvation of persons who have taken their own lives. By ways known to him alone, God can provide the opportunity for salutary repentance. The Church prays for persons who have taken their own lives. **
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top