E
edjlopez23
Guest
For example like the Third-order Franciscans, preferably something more traditional.
Last edited:
Lay Dominican here. I’m not sure what you mean by this. One joins a religious order due to its charism, not traditional practices. That should be your first concern. I as a lay Dominican am a lay member of the Order of Preachers. We are not a Dominican fan club, we are Dominicans. I can participate in the traditional practices of the Order and pray the EF breviary privately, but I’m not in the Dominicans because they have their own liturgy.something more traditional.
Do the lay Dominicans and the lay groups of ICKSP and FSSP take vows?EDIT: That being said, if you are interested in a group whose charism is tied specifically to the TLM, I know the ICKSP has such a group, and I think the FSSP does too.
I can’t say about the FSSP or ICKSP for sure, but I bet they’re like the lay Dominicans, which means that answer is no. Lay Dominicans make one promise, not a vow, and that is to live according to the Rule of St. Dominic. We don’t make vows of chastity and poverty: we can still own things and we can still get married.Do the lay Dominicans and the lay groups of ICKSP and FSSP take vows?
You don’t have to. I don’t. I am free to attend the TLM. I am free to pray (albeit privately) the EF breviary and the Dominican breviary per Summorum Pontificum. There are a few trads in my chapter. But the primary reason one joins a religious order is because of its charism. I could be in a chapter with many trads now, but I could move and be in a chapter with none. If I decide then to leave the Order, then I was never in it for the right reason to begin with. Traditional practices enhance my life as a Dominican, but they’re not the center of it.People shouldn’t have to choose between the traditional mass and a particular way of life (started by a Saint who them self attended the Traditional Mass all their life and had it play a major royal in their daily spiritual life along with everyone else in the order up until recently.)
I suppose that makes sense and it depends whether they want to chant the office together or privately etc. I suppose it depends what is meant by “lay religious order” and how much they intend to do as a group or not.You don’t have to. I don’t. I am free to attend the TLM. I am free to pray (albeit privately) the EF breviary and the Dominican breviary per Summorum Pontificum. There are a few trads in my chapter. But the primary reason one joins a religious order is because of its charism.
Generally, lay Dominicans meet up together as a chapter once a month. I don’t see my fellow Dominicans very often (though that’s also due to me living a ways away). As for lay religious Order, we are a part of the Dominican Order. We’re not considered less a part of it because we aren’t nuns or priests. We have O.P. after our names (after first promises) just like the religious Dominicans do.I suppose that makes sense and it depends whether they want to chant the office together or privately etc. I suppose it depends what is meant by “lay religious order” and how much they intend to do as a group or not.