Does God approve of cannibalism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rocks_91
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I read an article on Wikipedia about a plane that crashed in the Andes in 1972 and the passengers fed on their dead friends to survive.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uruguayan_Air_Force_Flight_571

My question is… does God approve of cannibalism in such circumstances?
Hi.

This question has been discussed in this past CAF thread. Posts #22, 28 and 29 may give you some insight. There doesn’t appear to be an official Church teaching, but the posts note one priest’s thoughts on the matter, as well as the Church’s reaction (via a bishop) on the incident you mentioned.
 
Wikipedia does not tell the whole story.

Nevertheless it is a great story. It was documented in a book I read as a class assignment in high school (many years ago). We discussed the story in detail. This was a great catholic high school too. What a wonderful experience.

Anyway, the survivors knew they had to resort to use of the dead bodies to survive. They also knew this might be a sin. When they were rescued, they had access to leaders in the church and related what happened. They were forgiven completely.

Going by memory, I believe their action was declared not a sin due to the circumstances.
 
On the Wikipedia site, there is this excerpt.

In fact, our survival had become a matter of national pride. Our ordeal was being celebrated as a glorious adventure… I didn’t know how to explain to them that there was no glory in those mountains. It was all ugliness and fear and desperation, and the obscenity of watching so many innocent people die. I was also shaken by the sensationalism with which many in the press covered the matter of what we had eaten to survive. Shortly after our rescue, officials of the Catholic Church announced that according to church doctrine we had committed no sin by eating the flesh of the dead. As Roberto had argued on the mountain, they told the world that the sin would have been to allow ourselves to die. More satisfying for me was the fact that many of the parents of the boys who died had publicly expressed their support for us, telling the world they understood and accepted what we had done to survive … despite these gestures, many news reports focused on the matter of our diet, in reckless and exploitive ways. Some newspapers ran lurid headlines above grisly front-page photos. (247–8)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top