Does God grieve over an extinct species?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sunflower15
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I saw in the news a few minutes ago that $14,000,000 is being allocated by the government to help save the Hawaiian crow. Interestingly, a priest speaker for Cross International was at church this morning raising funds. I wonder what is more important to God: feeding children who live on garbage dumps, providing them medical care, or the Hawaiian crow, which at this time only lives in captivity.
 
I saw in the news a few minutes ago that $14,000,000 is being allocated by the government to help save the Hawaiian crow. Interestingly, a priest speaker for Cross International was at church this morning raising funds. I wonder what is more important to God: feeding children who live on garbage dumps, providing them medical care, or the Hawaiian crow, which at this time only lives in captivity.
I also wonder if God would rather we use the billions of $ we are using in the war in Iraq, which isn’t solving that much years into it, or saving the hungry orphaned children all over the world, including the “casualties” of war…

The Hawaiian crow might in a hundred years be the species that helps us discover some rare species of flower which can be used in pharmacopoeia to cure some future epidemic…if we are going to get hypothetical…

But, I “get” your point…
 
God cares.

Our Lord said the Father cared about even the sparrow.

Therefore God cares about animals.

The rest is theological analysis of grieving. I don’t want to go there. What I know is that God cares for each and every animal that lives. Imagine how could you even know of the existence of every single animal. And yet God cares about them all. That’s quite overwhelming.

A species as it is, you know, as not a sum of actual animals, but a class of them, who knows… it’s a different thing. We shouldn’t project our ecological ideas on God, but I don’t think God doesn’t care.

Actually, the story of the Flood gives an example of God preserving species. A pair of each went into the Ark and so the species were preserved. Therefore I think God cares about species in addition to caring about each individual animal.
 
God cares.

Our Lord said the Father cared about even the sparrow.

Therefore God cares about animals.

The rest is theological analysis of grieving. I don’t want to go there. What I know is that God cares for each and every animal that lives. Imagine how could you even know of the existence of every single animal. And yet God cares about them all. That’s quite overwhelming.

A species as it is, you know, as not a sum of actual animals, but a class of them, who knows… it’s a different thing. We shouldn’t project our ecological ideas on God, but I don’t think God doesn’t care.

Actually, the story of the Flood gives an example of God preserving species. A pair of each went into the Ark and so the species were preserved. Therefore I think God cares about species in addition to caring about each individual animal.
:extrahappy: YES!!!
Exactly! If God did not care about species of animals, the story of Him telling Noah to build this huge ark wouldn’t make sense! …a much smaller, easier vessel would have sufficed…and a certain amount of the animals they liked to eat…not all the species available to Noah…and in couples! [to ensure the preservation of the different species of known animals in that habitat].

So, to answer all those who believe God places an extraordinary amount of importance on HUMANS over ANIMALS…NOT REALLY! Biblically speaking, at least.

He did preserve humanity [as a SPECIES not individuals] in Noah’s family, ALONG with the animals, needed to keep their species [NOT of *individual animals, just their SPECIES]
 
:extrahappy: YES!!!
Exactly! If God did not care about species of animals, the story of Him telling Noah to build this huge ark wouldn’t make sense! …a much smaller, easier vessel would have sufficed…and a certain amount of the animals they liked to eat…not all the species available to Noah…and in couples! [to ensure the preservation of the different species of known animals in that habitat].

So, to answer all those who believe God places an extraordinary amount of importance on HUMANS over ANIMALS…NOT REALLY! Biblically speaking, at least.

He did preserve humanity [as a SPECIES not individuals] in Noah’s family, ALONG with the animals, needed to keep their species [NOT of *individual animals, just their SPECIES]
So, it seems God DID charge humans [Noah] with preserving the different SPECIES of animals for posterity…while letting other humans perish [including innocent hungry children…for those with issues about saving animals over humans].

In our Bible and Tradition :coffeeread:, humans were CHARGED with the DUTY to preserve SPECIES of animals [not individual animals but their type], even in cases of natural catastrophes! *

That is the part that I had to struggle with…under normal circumstances, I would certainly be all for taking care of animals, but for God, we have to take care of ensuring the survival of at least enough to preserve their kind even under the most dire of situations*! WOW! In his infinite wisdom, HE thinks it’s essential enough that we have that event and a story in the Bible to remind us…Hm,m,m…

Or, does anyone think it was an easy task to build an ARK for these animals?:confused: If I were Noah, I would have probably wondered if we really needed ALL these species…😃
 
Ironically, DDT is very useful in fighting malaria. African children are dieing of this disease, and we seem more interested in saving the bald eagle.
Please share. Maybe you have more current facts??? But it is my understanding that in the year 2000, 120 countries adopted a treaty to phase out POP’s (persistent organic pollutants, including DDT). The United Nations’ Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants*** allows ***for it’s use (DDT) for control of malaria in some 25 countries, including South Africa.
 
Ironically, DDT is very useful in fighting malaria. African children are dieing of this disease, and we seem more interested in saving the bald eagle.
These aren’t mutually exclusive, people who want to save one typically want to save the other as well…
and conversely, people who don’t care to save one also do not care to save the other…
just to use the “red herring” in arguments to stop ALL saving of life…
Let’s save both!😉
 
So, to answer all those who believe God places an extraordinary amount of importance on HUMANS over ANIMALS…NOT REALLY! Biblically speaking, at least.
I cannot agree. God created us in His image, therefore He does place an extraordinary amount of importance on us. Also, the example I used said that God the Father cared about each little sparrow, therefore all the more did He care for us humans. Furthermore, God specifically told us to be the stewards of the earth and to rule it.
He did preserve humanity [as a SPECIES not individuals] in Noah’s family, ALONG with the animals, needed to keep their species [NOT of *individual
animals, just their SPECIES]

God preserved the species that way, but there is no ground to read that example as an exclusion of the importance of invidual animals.
 
I waited a long time to reply, to try to sincerely seek what you find so “balanced” about this post, and still don’t get it.

The only reason why this world inhabited by humans survived so long is that humans until VERY recently [last few centuries] were NOT like us.

When we see how “primitive” [wise in my opinion] peoples live still today, it tells us a LOT about why those people and this world have been around for so long.

However, it won’t be the same with us, because we are on a “self-destruct pattern”…what we call a “culture of death” is just the tip of the iceberg…the rest of the iceberg looms underwater…our disregard for all life forms and the ecology that sustains us.

The only way I can imagine that this world can keep going is by destroying us…which it can… a few viruses, a few tsunamis, or just letting us kill one another for a myriad of insane reasons…because it is our “bithright” to “subdue and oppress” everything is sight and out of sight.

Aside from this, what if God meant for us to have all sort of medicines from plants we are destroying? Or He thought we could be happier by interacting with other great living things, especially animals, who can sometimes rescue us from things people can’t, due to their acute animal sense of smell or hearing…such as in avalanche or emergency situations.

The worst case of the misuse of this I can think of is when we use dogs during war, utilizing their animal instincts meant to save humans in order for US to kill humans…SAD! And, you think we are at the “top of the moral chain” …I’m not so sure.

I surely don’t believe THIS was God’s Plan for His creation!😦

And, creation is NOT for US, it’s for HIM!😉
“You are worth more than many sparrows.”
The good of man is more important than that of animals.
We should avoid causing unnecessary cruelty or suffering to animals, true, but in the final analysis, the good of man must take precedence over saving a species of animal from extinction.
 
I cannot agree. God created us in His image, therefore He does place an extraordinary amount of importance on us.
In other stories of the Bible, yes. Not on that one, though.

Also, the example I used said that God the Father cared about each little sparrow, therefore all the more did He care for us humans. Furthermore, God specifically told us to be the stewards of the earth and to rule it.

To rule or to care for it?

God preserved the species that way, but there is no ground to read that example as an exclusion of the importance of individual animals.
I’m not arguing against caring for individual animals including mammals and humans.

I am just saying that from the story of Noah and the Flood, we see that God was VERY adamant about preserving the SPECIES of humans and animals ALIKE.

That God did NOT say to Noah, “forget the species of animals, just save as many human children as possible” as some posters would suggest…
 
“You are worth more than many sparrows.”
The good of man is more important than that of animals.
We should avoid causing unnecessary cruelty or suffering to animals, true, but in the final analysis, the good of man must take precedence over saving a species of animal from extinction.
Do you have any biblical backing other than being worth more than sparrows? Because that sincerely seems to pale in comparison to a whole story of the command and the details of building an ARK to ensure the continuity of the SPECIES of these animals…

I don’t think that it has to be a one or the other type of setting…we can advocate for LIFE in general and take care of God’s creation responsibly.

I’m NOT saying humans are not important to God!

And, saying the rest of creation is VERY important to God…and HE TRUSTED humans with its care and preservation…at least to not let species be completely wiped out, IF it is avoidable!
[If it isn’t avoidable, then it isn’t, obviously!]

However, showing high disregard or even showing lack of commitment to preserving God’s living things seems quite disturbing to me…
 
Ironically, DDT is very useful in fighting malaria. African children are dieing of this disease, and we seem more interested in saving the bald eagle.
Awake: I am still waiting for you to explain your statement. Were you awake when you wrote this, ***or do I misunderstand ***the history and the reasons for banning DDT, and allowing DDT to be still used in underdeveloped countries, including Africa?

The whole story of DDT fits perfectly into this discussion. DDT kills ALL insects, it doesn’t discriminate. It doesn’t biodegrade either. It stays in the ground and gets into the water and stays there too. It is INEXPENSIVE to produce, and was zealously applied to crops before all of the rammifications of its use were clear.

It was actually falconers who alerted the government that something was happening to Peregrines–their nests were failing (in huge, widespread numbers), the calcium in their egg shells too thin to make it to a successfull hatch.

Then it was discovered that this situation was also occurring with the bald eagle. Bald eagle numbers dropped to approximately 500 nesting pairs in the lower 48 states in the 1960’s. It was determined that DDT was responsible, and now decades later, after the banning of DDT, and breeding and release programs, eagles now number more than 10,000 nesting pairs in the lower 48 states, plus an additional 20,000 in Alaska, and tens of thousands more in Canada.

It was the Peregrine falcon, and the bald eagle, ***that brought our attention ***to the fact that there was something wrong with DDT. It killed ***all ***the bugs–those bugs eaten by birds who were subsequently eaten by the falcons. And the DDT got into the water and got into the fish. Bald eagles eat primarily fish–and that is how the DDT got into the eagles’ systems.

Thank God for the peregrine and the eagle!!! And if we were not paying attention to these birds and noticing that something was severely wrong–who knows how much more havoc and devastation would have occurred because we humans were careless with this chemical DDT.

We now use safer insecticides (in the developed nations), but DDT is so cheap to produce that we allow its use in certain at-risk-for-malaria, underdeveloped countries like Africa.

Human life is saved in these countries, but there is continuing destruction to their ecosystems. DDT is the cheap immediate answer for these countries. (Ironically, though DDT is outlawed in the USA, it is manufactured here and sold to the countries that are allowed to use it for epidemic malaria.) I understand that Bill Gates is putting up money to help fund a vaccine to end malaria.

If DDT had been allowed to continue, I wonder how long it would have been before we destroyed our entire ecosystem? And for us humans who have dominion over the earth–we should be more careful with our science projects. Loving the earth and all of God’s creatures is a WIN-WIN for the entire planet, especially the humans.

Are we superior to animals?? Of course!! It is only we who have the capacity to destroy the entire planet with our science projects…chemicals, bombs…

So Mr. or Mrs. Awake–I did not mean to pick on you–maybe your statement was posed to make people think. Maybe a lot of people are not aware of the history of DDT, or the fact that it was God’s other creatures that alerted us to our chemistry lesson gone bad.

I encourage everyone to learn about DDT, and you can thank a falcon and an eagle for being the proverbial canaries in the mine. If it were not for them, and their close call with extinction, who knows how many species would have in fact met this end, who knows what the extent of damage to our ecosystem would have been.
 
Pope Benedict XVI on Creation & our responsibility~

'***If we recognize this it will obviously follow that the Redemption, being Christian, and simply Christian faith, also means responsibility always and everywhere with regard to Creation

Twenty-three years ago Christians were accused - I do not know if this accusation is still held - of being the ones truly responsible for the destruction of Creation because the words contained in Genesis - “subdue the earth” - were said to have led to that arrogance with regard to creation whose consequences we are reaping today.

I think we must learn again to understand this accusation in all its falsity: as long as the earth was seen as God’s creation, the task of “subduing” it was never intended as an order to enslave it but rather as the task of being guardians of creation and developing its gifts; of actively collaborating in God’s work ourselves, in the evolution that he ordered in the world so that the gifts of Creation might be appreciated rather than trampled upon and destroyed.’***

[catholicsandclimatechange.org/pdf/Pope_Aug_6_08.pdf]](http://www.catholicsandclimatechange.org/pdf/Pope_Aug_6_08.pdf])

I was surprised that the Pope actually mentioned Genesis, the translation to “subdue the earth” and commented that the attitude of arrogance led to the ecological problems we now have.
I’m very proud of him!
 
Let the heavens be glad and the earth rejoice;
let the sea and what fills it resound;
let the plains be joyful and all that is in them.
Then let all the trees of the forest rejoice
before the Lord who comes,
who comes to govern the earth,
To govern the world with justice
and the peoples with faithfulness.
[Psalm 96:11-13]


Somehow, I imagine that God allow humanity to be curators of a museum guarding all his creations. Great masterpieces!
And, that humans have defaced and defiled almost every single one, to the point of destroying some.
And, to add insult to injury, when He comes back to check on his creation, some of us plan to tell Him:
‘well…you said WE were in charge here!’ as if that explained it all…😦
 
Let the heavens be glad and the earth rejoice;
let the sea and what fills it resound;
let the plains be joyful and all that is in them.
Then let all the trees of the forest rejoice
before the Lord who comes,
who comes to govern the earth,
To govern the world with justice
and the peoples with faithfulness.
[Psalm 96:11-13]


Somehow, I imagine that God allow humanity to be curators of a museum guarding all his creations. Great masterpieces!
And, that humans have defaced and defiled almost every single one, to the point of destroying some.
And, to add insult to injury, when He comes back to check on his creation, some of us plan to tell Him:
‘well…you said WE were in charge here!’ as if that explained it all…😦
:clapping::clapping::clapping::clapping::clapping:

Fabulous post!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top