Does God have a "best" plan for us?

  • Thread starter Thread starter KarenM5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

KarenM5

Guest
I was talking with my 18yr old son tonight about vocations and told him that he should pray to understand God’s plan for his vocation. He countered by saying that he didn’t think we are “predestined” to a certain path. My response was that I believe God has a “best” plan for us. I agree that God’s plan for all of us is salvation, but what about our path along the way? Don’t prayer and sacraments help us follow that path? Isn’t there a “best” path? In two nights we have an internet discussion planned with my son, his girlfriend and my 25 yr old son. I could use some guidance in Scripture and the Catechism!

Karen
 
From here:

The Catholic Church does teach that the elect are predestined, while concomitantly free will is respected so that God is not involved with coercion. At the same time the Church condemns a parallel assertion that one is predestined to hell. That is the fault of the Calvinists.
Code:
                               The best way to explain this is that God has foreknowledge                                   of all those that would respond to his gift of                                   self. While he wills all to be saved **(cf.                                   1 Tim 2:3)** , not all accept him (also, **Jn                                   1:11-12** ).                                   In addition to this foreknowledge, God also has                                   provided all the grace necessary for those to be                                   saved. In this way he has determined their salvation:                                   by insuring it. So, in the end, God not only knows                                   who will be saved, he "saw to it" that                                   they were saved, and respected the free will of                                   those who were not.

                               The problem that Calvinists and others have pertains                                   to God's sovereignty. They believe that since God's                                   will is perfect and sovereign, everything he wills                                   comes to be, and all that is -- is his will. The                                   latter portion is their mistake.

                               In reality, God allows evil actions to happen,                                   but he does not will them in his perfect will.                                   He cannot be construed to be responsible for the                                   evil in the world, even though no evil could take                                   place without his consent.

                               In the same way, souls are lost. God does not                                   desire the condemnation of man (Jesus said, " I                                   **come not to condemn, but to                                   save**... ") but                                   their salvation. If his will seems to be thwarted                                   (by losing souls) it is only an illusion, a clever                                   diversion from the truth. His perfect will is that                                   men be free, free to accept or reject him.

                               So, if you wonder, is God aware of your outcome?                                   Yes. Is he preparing a place for his children?                                   Yes. Are you one of his children? Have you entered                                   into his covenant family and eaten the covenant                                   meal? Ultimately, your fate is in God's hands,                                   what you require is trust in his mercy and a clear                                   conscience. Look at Paul's response to those who                                   tried to question him (**1 Cor                                   4:3-5**)
God Bless,
RyanL
 
40.png
KarenM5:
I was talking with my 18yr old son tonight about vocations and told him that he should pray to understand God’s plan for his vocation. He countered by saying that he didn’t think we are “predestined” to a certain path. My response was that I believe God has a “best” plan for us. I agree that God’s plan for all of us is salvation, but what about our path along the way? Don’t prayer and sacraments help us follow that path? Isn’t there a “best” path? In two nights we have an internet discussion planned with my son, his girlfriend and my 25 yr old son. I could use some guidance in Scripture and the Catechism!
Sounds like you are on the right track. The section of the on the Fourth Commandment, especially Part III (Duties of Family Members) and Part IV (The Family and the Kingdom)*Catechism * might help a little. There the Catechism speaks of each person having a unique vocation which comes from God:Just as the child grows to maturity and human and spiritual autonomy, so his unique vocation which comes from God asserts itself more clearly and forcefully. Parents should respect this call and encourage their children to follow it. (2232)
 
I am reading a really great book “The Holy Longing” by Father Ronald Rolheiser. He makes the point that people who only try to establish a relationship with God, and not the Body of Christ, are not in full spirituality - Jesus established a community, His body, here on earth and it is our duty to work for them, with them, and in them.

My reason for bringing this up, beyond prayer and sacraments, it is our fellow Christians in the Body of Christ that also participate in us finding our vocation, as God works through them - we are a community, and God is a living God, so He is around us and in all of us so we should listen there too.
 
The question was; " is there a best path"? I think absolutely there is. I love this passage from Jeremiah…

Jer 29:11-14
11’For I know the plans that I have for you,’ declares the LORD,’ plans for welfare and not for calamity to give you a future and a hope. 12’Then you will call upon Me and come and pray to Me, and I will listen to you. 13’And you will seek Me and find Me, when you search for Me with all your heart.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top