That there is suffering in Purgatory is part of the dogma and must be believed. This does not mean images like what’s originally linked in this thread need to be held. Images like that portray Purgatory as just a miserable place, failing to account for the fact that charity exists in Purgatory, plus the guaranteed assurance that they are heaven-bound.I think purgatory is a mystery - which is to say, we know things about it, but we don’t fully comprehend it. So many saints have had visions of purgatory as a place of pain, and so many theologians and Church Fathers have held such, as well as the Scriptural references involving fire, it would be shortsighted of us to dismiss the idea that purgatory must have some element of unpleasantness. However, it’s also true that saints have had visions of purgatory as a joyful place. It’s a mystery, but let’s not throw out the insights of so many great Catholics.![]()
Purgatory is a doctrine of God’s great mercy. The souls there do suffer, but because they are in a state of grace, the suffering is borne willingly and joyfully, because the “fire” of Purgatory is nothing more than the fire of God’s own love, and where that love is, joy inevitably exists. God doesn’t torment souls who died in a state of grace; that is contrary to his nature.
I prefer to hold on to this comforting image of Purgatory, which we are permitted to believe. We are in Purgatory, suffering as the cleansing fire burning away what is unworthy of heaven, while we long for the presence of God. Not too far from us is an open door to heaven, with God standing there, constantly inviting us to come to him and be with him. But we willingly choose to remain until we know that we have shed the last of our imperfections and attachments.