Eating Placenta as Cannibalism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter thewanderer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s amazing how many different answers are given to questions like this. Cannibalism is only a sin as far as it seriously damages a person’s body. Since this obviously does not involve damaging one’s body, it is not a sin.
 
It’s amazing how many different answers are given to questions like this. Cannibalism is only a sin as far as it seriously damages a person’s body. Since this obviously does not involve damaging one’s body, it is not a sin.
I would be very carefull with those statements, because something that was unthinkable 60 years ago it is common ocurrence nowdays.
I will propose an example.
We can keep a person alive even when the brain has sustained irreparable damage, let’s say that the person has been declared dead, his body is however pristine and his death was due to an accident so there is no real sickness involved, just trauma.
By your standards there would be nothing wrong if someone harvested the deceased’s organs and served them fricasse style.
After all no actual “damage” to the “donors” body occur right?
What is worse is that such a scenario could repeat itself if the right conditions are given.
Any one read about the siege of St. Petersburg by the nazis during WW II?

Peace 👍
 
I would be very carefull with those statements, because something that was unthinkable 60 years ago it is common ocurrence nowdays.
I will propose an example.
We can keep a person alive even when the brain has sustained irreparable damage, let’s say that the person has been declared dead, his body is however pristine and his death was due to an accident so there is no real sickness involved, just trauma.
By your standards there would be nothing wrong if someone harvested the deceased’s organs and served them fricasse style.
After all no actual “damage” to the “donors” body occur right?
What is worse is that such a scenario could repeat itself if the right conditions are given.
Any one read about the siege of St. Petersburg by the nazis during WW II?

Peace 👍
What if you get lost in the desert with a group of people and you’re all starving to death. One by one, the people in your group begin dying off from starvation. Are the survivors allowed to eat the meat of those who die so that they themselves can live? Or is there something intrinsically immoral about eating human flesh that would make this act impermissible?

This is why I don’t believe that eating human flesh is intrinsically wrong. If so, it would be wrong even in the situation I provided above, and even in the placenta situation. Which I highly doubt it is.
 
This is why I don’t believe that eating human flesh is intrinsically wrong.
I concur that it is not intrinsically sinful, though I do think it is a really bad idea except in an emergency situations.
 
The placenta is eaten for health purposes so would that not make it a good thing and not a sin?
 
As a midwifery student I do know, and have seen, the benefits of eating and encapsulating the placenta. But thank you for your clear answer. 🙂
This. It’s quite beneficial. It can prevent post partum depression and increase milk supply, among other things. The placenta is dried and encapsulated, and taken like vitamins. If consuming the placenta were immoral, than an infant consuming breast milk would be immoral, as well. The placenta isn’t flesh.

In Christ,
Ellen
 
I’d lean towards saying it isn’t immoral. As I understand it, you’d have to consider two questions. Is consuming a part of the body contrary to the ends for which it is made? Is consuming a part of the body something that could be gravely wrong? In the case of a cannibal serial killer, obviously both conditions are met. In the case of picking and eating boogers, at worst, it’s a bad habit. But if a bad habit like chewing your hair or something rises to the level of producing harm to oneself, then I think it becomes wrong because it becomes serious/grave to some degree. As someone else pointed out, a baby drinking breastmilk is clearly not wrong because that’s what breastmilk is made for and therefore it produces benefits to both mother and baby. Sort of related is the use of adult stem cells for medical purposes. If I’m correct, it’s acceptable because the ultimate use is consistent with the purposes for which the cells were made and the result is life giving. Because the placenta is disposed of anyway, consuming it may be healthful to the mother, and there is evidence for consuming it in nature, I have a hard time believing it’s immoral. However, someone recently pointed out to me that the placenta is packed with nutrients, but it also filters potentially dangerous substances, so a mother could potentially introduce harmful substances to her body by consuming it. For that reason, I’d stay away from it just in case.
 
Well, now that we have the opinions of our local peanut gallery, is there anyone here who is a theologian who can give us a definitive answer?

My personal opinion: EWW!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top