Emulators! Dun Dun Duuuuuun

  • Thread starter Thread starter ILIKECEREAL
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Wouldn’t say it’s stealing or a sin to emulate a video game, just like downloading movies as well.

I downloaded Passion of the Christ from an illegal pirating website. I’m sure God will spare me 😛

Don’t be fooled, you’re not stealing anything. It’s simply another way for the major media companies to protect their market and bankroll. Here is the simple equation; stealing is taking something that belongs to someone else with no intent of returning it. Downloading a ROM or Emulated game is not stealing, since the person who owns that ROM or Emulator made it themself and have freely allowed you to download/play it. It’s a copy of the media. The original owners and producers still have ownership of the copy they made. You didn’t take anything from them.

If you buy a game or media, it is yours. You shouldn’t be bound by some ridiculous laws which prohibit what you can do with an item you paid for. If you want to give it to your friends, then so be it. Any emulated or pirated media was purchased by someone initially in the first place, and as the purchaser, that person is well within the Catholic faith’s guidelines to share that media. It’s called sharing, and Jesus was a big fan of it 😃

Now, reproducing it and selling it is a different story. If you’re making money off it, then that’s most certainly stealing profit/valuable property that somebody else is entitled to. Otherwise, pirate away.
 
Wouldn’t say it’s stealing or a sin to emulate a video game, just like downloading movies as well.

I downloaded Passion of the Christ from an illegal pirating website. I’m sure God will spare me 😛

Don’t be fooled, you’re not stealing anything. It’s simply another way for the major media companies to protect their market and bankroll. Here is the simple equation; stealing is taking something that belongs to someone else with no intent of returning it. Downloading a ROM or Emulated game is not stealing, since the person who owns that ROM or Emulator made it themself and have freely allowed you to download/play it. It’s a copy of the media. The original owners and producers still have ownership of the copy they made. You didn’t take anything from them.

If you buy a game or media, it is yours. You shouldn’t be bound by some ridiculous laws which prohibit what you can do with an item you paid for. If you want to give it to your friends, then so be it. Any emulated or pirated media was purchased by someone initially in the first place, and as the purchaser, that person is well within the Catholic faith’s guidelines to share that media. It’s called sharing, and Jesus was a big fan of it 😃

Now, reproducing it and selling it is a different story. If you’re making money off it, then that’s most certainly stealing profit/valuable property that somebody else is entitled to. Otherwise, pirate away.
Mostly correct, but you have come to an invalid conclusion and given some bad advice here.

I will grant that piracy is not “stealing” in the classical sense. To steal means that you deprive someone else of their property. Piracy is a new class of crime that must be considered differently.

However, in the modern Western world with our constructed beliefs in intellectual property, certain laws have arisen that prevent piracy and other types of crimes against IP. The Church is clear in her teaching that we are bound to obey all just laws. What is a just law? It is a law given by competent authority that does not command us to sin or otherwise violate our own systems of Christian ethics and belief. The Church is largely silent on modern laws of IP. This can more or less be construed as assent. If the Church felt that laws, especially in the USA, were unjust, she would speak against them officially, say, through a document issued by a committee of the USCCB. A cursory search of the USCCB website indicates that no documents have been issued specifically taking up the issues of IP.

All this means that laws on IP, unless otherwise declared unjust by the authority competent to govern us in spiritual matters, are lawful and binding on Catholics. You should not dismiss them lightly by saying that it is OK to pirate software, as long as you are not selling it or making money in some way. This is a false dichotomy. Piracy is still a crime even when no profit is made. The losses to the media industry, I will grant they can be exaggerated, but they are real.

It should be stressed that not all copying is illegal and sinful. There is a vast wealth of information on the Internet that is free for the taking, and just waiting for you to take advantage of it. I strongly exhort you to investigate alternative free licensing for software and media. Creative Commons is a good start. Download.com has a lot of software. You will find more just by using simple searches for things like “free software” and “open source”. I personally find no need or joy in piracy when there is plenty of stuff to be had free of charge and freely licensed for me to copy, modify, and reuse in any way I see fit.

If more content creators took advantage of alternative licensing, the world would be a better place. Take note! Alternative licensing can help gain you fame and fortune even if you feel funny about giving stuff away for free at first. Many indie bands have been launched by the mere release of a YouTube video or a free MP3 on, say, MySpace. Linux is an extremely popular choice for computer users that offers a completely free operating environment, with applications and games free for the asking. There is no limit to the wealth to be found in freely licensed media and software, and it can all be had without any worry of endangering your salvation.
 
I downloaded Passion of the Christ from an illegal pirating website. I’m sure God will spare me 😛
But that’s stealing… and downloading from an illegal website is essentially supporting it so that kinda makes it worse.
Downloading a ROM or Emulated game is not stealing, since the person who owns that ROM or Emulator made it themself and have freely allowed you to download/play it. It’s a copy of the media. The original owners and producers still have ownership of the copy they made. You didn’t take anything from them.
Hmm, let’s see what Nintendo has to say on their website regarding roms and emulators: nintendo.com/corp/legal.jsp#roms

*What is a Nintendo Video Game Emulator?

A Nintendo emulator is a software program that is designed to allow game play on a platform that it was not created for. A Nintendo emulator allows for Nintendo console based or arcade games to be played on unauthorized hardware. The video games are obtained by downloading illegally copied software, i.e. Nintendo ROMs, from Internet distributors. Nintendo ROMs then work with the Nintendo emulator to enable game play on unauthorized hardware such as a personal computer, a modified console, etc.

**Can I Download a Nintendo ROM from the Internet if I Already Own the Authentic Game?
**
There is a good deal of misinformation on the Internet regarding the backup/archival copy exception. It is not a “second copy” rule and is often mistakenly cited for the proposition that if you have one lawful copy of a copyrighted work, you are entitled to have a second copy of the copyrighted work even if that second copy is an infringing copy. The backup/archival copy exception is a very narrow limitation relating to a copy being made by the rightful owner of an authentic game to ensure he or she has one in the event of damage or destruction of the authentic. Therefore, whether you have an authentic game or not, or whether you have possession of a Nintendo ROM for a limited amount of time, i.e. 24 hours, it is illegal to download and play a Nintendo ROM from the Internet. *
 
I downloaded Passion of the Christ from an illegal pirating website. I’m sure God will spare me.
God will be willing to forgive you for this minor theft, but only if you are repentant. It sounds as if you are not. You may want to discuss this matter with your confessor. The theft itself is minor, but the attitude of indifference, or of Pride, is a grave matter.
 
*Mostly correct, but you have come to an invalid conclusion and given some bad advice here.

I will grant that piracy is not “stealing” in the classical sense. To steal means that you deprive someone else of their property. Piracy is a new class of crime that must be considered differently.

However, in the modern Western world with our constructed beliefs in intellectual property, certain laws have arisen that prevent piracy and other types of crimes against IP. The Church is clear in her teaching that we are bound to obey all just laws. What is a just law? It is a law given by competent authority that does not command us to sin or otherwise violate our own systems of Christian ethics and belief. The Church is largely silent on modern laws of IP. This can more or less be construed as assent. If the Church felt that laws, especially in the USA, were unjust, she would speak against them officially, say, through a document issued by a committee of the USCCB. A cursory search of the USCCB website indicates that no documents have been issued specifically taking up the issues of IP.

All this means that laws on IP, unless otherwise declared unjust by the authority competent to govern us in spiritual matters, are lawful and binding on Catholics. You should not dismiss them lightly by saying that it is OK to pirate software, as long as you are not selling it or making money in some way. This is a false dichotomy. Piracy is still a crime even when no profit is made. The losses to the media industry, I will grant they can be exaggerated, but they are real.*

The law is different from our law. That is a system of our beliefs. It cannot be cherry-picked, ie we cannot follow some parts and not others (again supported in the Bible). For public record sake, the Church will obviously publish that we are to abide by the laws of nations (can you imagine what would happen if they did otherwise?). It’s almost mandatory for them to do so. Yes, the Church recognizes and accepts these laws, but they are not vital for our spirituality nor do they determine sin.

*But that’s stealing… and downloading from an illegal website is essentially supporting it so that kinda makes it worse
*
Firstly, no, as has proven, it’s not stealing. For a start, I own the movie on DVD and paid for my ticket to watch it at theaters. While the law holds that these are not acceptable reasons to download it, they are justified in at least Jesus’ view. Would Jesus condone the act of constantly needing to pay for the same thing over and over? Doubtful. He was one to speak out against money-making and the ways of government. If Jesus followed the law, he wouldn’t have been crucified, nor would he have done many of the things he did. His law is not the same as the US national law. Technically, it’s also illegal for you to sell products on the street without a permit. Is the starving carpenter who can’t afford a permit and sells his carved religious icons on the street going to Hell? No way.

Hmm, let’s see what Nintendo has to say on their website

I stopped taking your post seriously after seeing ‘Nintendo’. Who are they to judge what is right and wrong? Did God give them authority to condemn people to Hell? No. They’re just another multi-million dollar company protecting their market and bankroll, of course they’re going to speak out against piracy, especially of their own products. Don’t you think they’re a little biased?

God will be willing to forgive you for this minor theft, but only if you are repentant. It sounds as if you are not. You may want to discuss this matter with your confessor. The theft itself is minor, but the attitude of indifference, or of Pride, is a grave matter.

Again, under simple construction of the equation, I didn’t steal anything, therefore I have not sinned in that regard. Somebody I happen to come across had a copied version of the film I wanted to watch, and they were nice enough to be willing to share. If Jesus had 2 cloaks and a fellow came by to ask him for one, would it at all be in his nature to say “If I give you this, you’re robbing the cloak maker of his profit, therefore no, I will not give you one of mine, go and buy your own”? Jesus would’ve given him the cloak off his own back if needed, he wouldn’t have demanded that they go buy their own, especially if they once already paid for a cloak before and had it stolen back by the maker.
 
While the law holds that these are not acceptable reasons to download it, they are justified in at least Jesus’ view.
With all due respect, no, they aren’t. Since it is clearly against the law and a crime to even distribute copyrighted material, ROMs, movies, etc, it is, therefore, not an acceptable practice to support such websites by downloading from them. We should stay away from those kinds of pirating sites - they are doing something that they probably already know they shouldn’t be doing. Why would you support something clearly illegal and a crime? You do not need these things (movies, ROMs) to survive, nor are they a necessity in life, so I do not believe it’s correct to say that it is justifiable in Jesus’ view. However, if one had to do something illegal in order to survive, like say your example of a starving carpenter who can’t afford a permit and sells his carved religious icons on the street, I could see bending a man-made law as an acceptable practice because of the clear necessity behind it.
I stopped taking your post seriously after seeing ‘Nintendo’. Who are they to judge what is right and wrong? Did God give them authority to condemn people to Hell? No. They’re just another multi-million dollar company protecting their market and bankroll, of course they’re going to speak out against piracy, especially of their own products. Don’t you think they’re a little biased?
It is Nintendo’s legal page. But I understand what you mean by how they could be biased. However, what is wrong with them speaking against piracy and the downloading of copyrighted ROMs? It is clearly illegal and it is good they make it crystal clear on their website. They even do this on Gamefaqs or virtually any other site that talks about the legality of downloading copyrighted ROMs. You really need to talk with your pastor about this. Elizium23 already said it best though, on how we are to follow all just laws “given by competent authority that does not command us to sin or otherwise violate our own systems of Christian ethics and belief.” Or you can send a PM to Fr. Vincent Serpa, one of the apologists here about this, I’m sure he would agree.
 
My 2 cents,

As the video game genre ages we are not faced with a situation where some of the games we loved in our childhood and would like to replay are unavailable. There are now many games that are impossible or nearly impossible to get a working hard copy of. Mainly many Nintendo, Super Nintendo, and very old PC games. In these cases where is there is no possible way to get a copy of the game I so nothing wrong with getting a virtual copy online. Consider the following:
  1. Many older games were produced by companies that no longer exist, there is no possible way to pay those who produced it.
  2. Second hand copies become increasingly more rare as time goes by where some games cannot be found or can only be found in questionable condition for over 100$.
  3. Emulating old games is not about wanting to get a free game or stealing, but wanting to appreciate an older product that is and will most likely never be available again in any format but as a ROM.
So I go by this rule: If I can easily find the game online for sale than I probably should not download it. If the game can no longer be easily found than I am sure the programmers would probably have wanted them games enjoyed and remembered, not merely forgotten because the counsel was no longer produced. If someone is downloading a game like Call of Duty, yes you are stealing. If someone is downloading and old SNES game I would say not.
 
Domiy, you have a warped view of Christian belief and you are misrepresenting Catholic teaching. Please read some Church documents regarding civic duty and good citizenship. The bottom line is that we are bound to obey just laws, and the Church, not we the laity, has the right to interpret for us which laws are just.

Catholic Encyclopedia: Civil Allegiance
The citizen’s chief duty is to obey the just laws of his country. To be able to distinguish what laws of the civil authority are just and obligatory, it will be advisable to lay down the principles of Catholic theology respecting the nature, subject-matter, and limits of the obedience which citizens owe to the State. To understand these we must know something of the mutual relations between Church and State. From the time of Our Lord to the present, no accusation has been more persistently made against Catholics than that they cannot be good Catholics and good citizens at the same time. They owe, it is said, a divided allegiance. On the one hand they are bound to obey an infallible pope, who is the sole judge of what comes within his sphere of authority, and who may be a foreigner; and on the other they must satisfy the claims of the State to the loyalty and obedience of its subjects. It is asserted that the duties of the citizen are sure to be sacrificed by devout Catholic to the interests of his Church. This conflict of jurisdictions did not arise in pre-Christian times. Each nation had its own religion, its own gods, its own worship. The national religion was a primary element in the constitution of the State. The chief ruler of the State was also supreme pontiff. As a citizen owed obedience to his country’s laws so he owed reverence and worship to his country’s gods. The State domineered with absolute sway over both the spiritual and the temporal; it claimed the whole devotion of both body and soul. Jesus Christ established a spiritual kingdom on earth, which we call His Church. He gave His Church authority over all matters concern with the worship of the one, true God, and the salvation of souls; it was His intention that the Gospel should be preached to every creature, that all men should enter His kingdom, that His Church should be Catholic, i.e. universal. This fact is of supreme importance not only in religion, but also in history and politics.
[BIBLEDRB]Mark 12:17[/BIBLEDRB]

Also, while you have spoken to refute the first part of my last post, you said nothing about my last two paragraphs, which were the most important ones. If there is such a wealth of freely available software and media out there, why in the world are we compelled to disobey just laws to pirate the proprietary stuff? Surely if we lacked free alternatives, there would be more of a compulsion to ignore the copyright laws, because if everything is locked up then you feel a greater need to enjoy a part of it. But not everything is locked up. Have a look on the web for freely licensed software and media. You will be pleasantly surprised to see how many video games and applications and songs and videos are ripe for the plucking, if you would only seek them, instead of looking on shady pirate sites for the new hotness.
 
Emulators are not illegal, pirating ROMs are.

I don’t break copyright anymore once I understood that it is a sin, not even to watch anime streams, which sucks because there is no decent anime on TV. I really wish to play classic SNES and N64 games but Nintendo is greedy and does not release all the games it could. If the virtual console selection wasn’t so poor I would buy a Wii…
 
With all due respect, no, they aren’t. Since it is clearly against the law and a crime to even distribute copyrighted material, ROMs, movies, etc, it is, therefore, not an acceptable practice to support such websites by downloading from them. We should stay away from those kinds of pirating sites - they are doing something that they probably already know they shouldn’t be doing. Why would you support something clearly illegal and a crime? You do not need these things (movies, ROMs) to survive, nor are they a necessity in life, so I do not believe it’s correct to say that it is justifiable in Jesus’ view. However, if one had to do something illegal in order to survive, like say your example of a starving carpenter who can’t afford a permit and sells his carved religious icons on the street, I could see bending a man-made law as an acceptable practice because of the clear necessity behind it.

Again, I stress, that the political laws of one country do not determine sin! What if doing something in one country is wrong, but in another country it is legal? Does that mean we can avoid sin depending on where we commit an act? No way. Does that mean smoking marijuana would be sinful in Australia, where it is still illegal, but not sinful in Amsterdam, where it’s a customary and legal act?

Your point about it not being a necessity to survive is flawed as well; technically you don’t need your car, your clothes, and all that junk in your garage to survive either, so why do you have them? Granted, you might have paid for them, but is not life more than bread alone? Yes, I download or stream movies that I want to watch. No, I don’t need these things to survive but I do them when I want to kill time or relax. I’m not getting all the benefits that I would by purchasing the DVD or watching it at the theater either so it works out. This is like if I went to a restaurant and they were charging $20 for a simple piece of bread. Is it wrong for me to walk down the street to the illegal street seller and buy his homemade bread for $5? No.
Domiy, you have a warped view of Christian belief and you are misrepresenting Catholic teaching. Please read some Church documents regarding civic duty and good citizenship. The bottom line is that we are bound to obey just laws, and the Church, not we the laity, has the right to interpret for us which laws are just.

Catholic Encyclopedia: Civil Allegiance

[BIBLEDRB]Mark 12:17[/BIBLEDRB]

Also, while you have spoken to refute the first part of my last post, you said nothing about my last two paragraphs, which were the most important ones. If there is such a wealth of freely available software and media out there, why in the world are we compelled to disobey just laws to pirate the proprietary stuff? Surely if we lacked free alternatives, there would be more of a compulsion to ignore the copyright laws, because if everything is locked up then you feel a greater need to enjoy a part of it. But not everything is locked up. Have a look on the web for freely licensed software and media. You will be pleasantly surprised to see how many video games and applications and songs and videos are ripe for the plucking, if you would only seek them, instead of looking on shady pirate sites for the new hotness.
You used a very passage that I was actually about to use for my own argument. Yeah, as Jesus said it himself, give to Ceasar (the law) what is Ceasars (the laws), and to God what is Gods. The entire context of that passage has the purpose to separate the two. Jesus makes it clear that the law stands as the law, and God’s law stands as a separate entity. By no means does it imply that they are interrelated or bound by eachother. Actually, it’s quite the opposite. Ceasar is Ceasar, and God is God.

And apologies for not referring to your last paragraph. I don’t know what you mean by it. I’m not a fanatic or expert on the whole freeware online stuff. I don’t pirate for the sake of pirating, it’s not like I’m doing it to support the industry. I do it for myself. All I know is that I want to watch a movie, and it’s either a choice of driving around for hours looking for a DVD or going to the theater, or streaming it online for free instantly. It makes life a lot easier to go by the second option, and as far as I know there’s nothing in the Bible that prohibits sharing or copying or, quite frankly, even doing something that is not within the laws of the place you live (as I pointed out before, this would be so problematic for the Church it’s scary. Sin would be avoided based on the location that it is done in? No way. Sin is sin whether you do it in one country or the next).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top