Faith-Alone saves

  • Thread starter Thread starter SedesDomi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Kaycee…

Blessing to you in Christ…

As I no longer have the time to invest in here that I once did… I will try and respond appropriately…(understanding that I may not be able to return any response you offer…)

First…
I find it oddly peculiar that you would say that I do not love scripture because i do not agree with your interpretation of this verse. I have heard the argument you put forth many times and quite frankly see it more as a reading into scripture to get what you need than anything else…

A simple question would be Why was Romans Written. The whole book, in context. It was written to describe to the Romans the differences between the old way (Jewish/Abraham) and the new way (Christianity), and the benefits of being a Christian. If you understand that Context, which is the proper context, you can see why saying that Romans 4 is talking about all works makes no sense…

I do not read scripture in single passages, or in a piece of a chapter here or there (not saying you do) but the only way to get the interpretation you mentioned is if you do take just the very start of Romans 4. Everywhere else it is talking about the old, Jewish way…

Romans 4 is just a sum up of those differances…

You can either have faith in Jesus, or you can follow the OLD law.

To be fair, I criticize my Fellow Catholics as well when they try and use Romans 1 to show the error of Protestantism for the same reasons…

However, this particular verse aside… was my statement wrong…
Does God want us to follow the new convent in Christ, or follow the old, Covenant law of Abraham, and Moses.

You are a brother (or sister) in Christ that has much zeal and I respect you for it. I also understand that this argument has raged since Martin Luther first interpreted it this way. I have offered my piece, you have offered yours…

May the peace of Christ be with you always…
 
Kaycee…

Blessing to you in Christ…

As I no longer have the time to invest in here that I once did… I will try and respond appropriately…(understanding that I may not be able to return any response you offer…)

First…
I find it oddly peculiar that you would say that I do not love scripture because i do not agree with your interpretation of this verse. I have heard the argument you put forth many times and quite frankly see it more as a reading into scripture to get what you need than anything else…

A simple question would be Why was Romans Written. The whole book, in context. It was written to describe to the Romans the differences between the old way (Jewish/Abraham) and the new way (Christianity), and the benefits of being a Christian. If you understand that Context, which is the proper context, you can see why saying that Romans 4 is talking about all works makes no sense…

I do not read scripture in single passages, or in a piece of a chapter here or there (not saying you do) but the only way to get the interpretation you mentioned is if you do take just the very start of Romans 4. Everywhere else it is talking about the old, Jewish way…

Romans 4 is just a sum up of those differances…

You can either have faith in Jesus, or you can follow the OLD law.

To be fair, I criticize my Fellow Catholics as well when they try and use Romans 1 to show the error of Protestantism for the same reasons…

However, this particular verse aside… was my statement wrong…
Does God want us to follow the new convent in Christ, or follow the old, Covenant law of Abraham, and Moses.

You are a brother (or sister) in Christ that has much zeal and I respect you for it. I also understand that this argument has raged since Martin Luther first interpreted it this way. I have offered my piece, you have offered yours…

May the peace of Christ be with you always…
Thank You for the extremely gracious respsonse, It is very refreshing and much appreciated! 👍
 
Faith leads to trust.

Trust leads to hearing.

Hearing leads to obeying.

Obeying leads to action.

No action means no obeying.

No obeying means no hearing.

No hearing means no trusting.

No trusting means no faith.

Thus, faith-alone also means trust-alone, hearing-alone, obeying-alone, action-alone; because all lead to the other, and the lack of one means the lack of the others.
What you have shown is that faith is necessary. You have not shown that faith alone is all that is required. Indeed, you have disproven that point.

Peace,
-Robert
 
You seem to have gotten the progression wrong.
We are to first have faith in the salvific works of Jesus to which we add:
  1. virtue
  2. knowledge
  3. self-control
  4. steadfastness
  5. godliness
  6. brotherly affection (philos)
  7. love (agape)
    This is the progression of the maturation of our faith from childhood to adulthood. An entire series of sermons (not homilies) could be composed to expound this growth. See the second papal encyclical for corroboration.
Matthew
 
I noticed a flaw in your reasoning.

How did you draw this conclusion that hearing leads to obeying? It may not lead to obeying.
Saving faith is obedient faith. If a person has what they call “faith” but it is not obedient, then such a one will die out when temptations come, they will not be able to hold fast.
This is clearly demonstrated by Jesus in the parable of the sower, where so many people hear the word of God, but do not necessarily obey.

Luke 8:11-15
11 Now the parable is this: The seed is the word of God.
12 The ones along the path are those who have heard; then the devil comes and takes away the word from their hearts, that they may not believe and be saved.
13 And the ones on the rock are those who, when they hear the word, receive it with joy; but these have no root, they believe for a while and in time of temptation fall away.
14 And as for what fell among the thorns, they are those who hear, but as they go on their way they are choked by the cares and riches and pleasures of life, and their fruit does not mature.
15 And as for that in the good soil, they are those who, hearing the word,** hold it fast in an honest and good heart, and bring forth fruit (works, isn’t it?)**with patience.
“And every one who hears these words of mine **and does not do them (works, isn’t it?) **will be like a foolish man who built his house upon the sand” Matthew 7:26
I agree that obedient faith will produce fruit, but the growth of fruit does not require effort, as do the good works that grow also out of grace.
The truth is, God’s grace alone saves!
It is grace that allows us to see ourselves as we really are:

“For if any are hearers of the word and not doers, they are like those who look at themselves in a mirror; 24 for they look at themselves and, on going away, immediately forget what they were like. 25 But those who look into the perfect law, the law of liberty, and persevere, being not hearers who forget but doers who act — they will be blessed in their doing.” James 1:23-25

Those who are obedient will be blessed in their doing.
 
just what is faith any way?can some one tell me what faith is.
Faith is not simply a feeling, a mere sentiment that results only in positive speech. It is not an optimistic decision. Neither is it passive orthodoxy. Faith is a response, directed towards Christ as it satisfying object. That is why faith must have content. Truths about Christ must be understood and believed. Christian faith is trust in the eternal God as revealed in Scripture and His promises secured by Jesus Christ. It is called forth by the gospel as the gospel is made understandable through the supernatural and free work of the Holy Spirit. Christian faith is not inherited or passed mechanically on; it is a personal act, involving the mind, the heart and will. It is not faith in an idea or philosophy, but in the Triune God.

Faith involves three steps or aspects: knowledge, agreement and trust. Redemptive facts must be made known so that they may be accepted (Romans 10:14).

Calvin defined faith as “a firm and sure knowledge of the divine favour towards us, founded on the truth of a free promise in Christ, and revealed to our minds and sealed on our hearts by the Holy Spirit” (Institutes, III.2.7).

Through faith we run to Christ and hold fast to Him, who satisfied the law on our behalf (Romans 10:4; Galatians 3:10-13). In this way we are accounted righteous in the sight of God through faith alone, without doing the works of the law. We are simul iustus et peccator.

But since faith unites to Christ it cannot be lifeless. It works through love (Galatians 5:6). It seeks to doo all the “good works, which God prepared beforehand” for us (Ephesians 2:10).

James rightly says, faith without works is dead, being by itself. He is here describing a faith that knows the gospel and even agrees with it, but has fallen short of trust in God. Failure to grow, develop, and bear the fruits of righteousness shows that the free gift of God in Christ has never been received.

James is concerned about those who merely say they believe but do not actually and genuinely believe. If they did, their behaviour would be holy, manifesting their heart-faith. In this sense faith and works are inseparable, but as regards the obtainment of salvation, it is not what is done in us, but what is done for us (on Calvary) that matters. But if we really look upon the crucified and risen Saviour, our lives would necessarily be transformed. It cannot be otherwise.

tecmalta.org/tft219.htm
 
Faith is not simply a feeling, a mere sentiment that results only in positive speech. It is not an optimistic decision. Neither is it passive orthodoxy. Faith is a response, directed towards Christ as it satisfying object. That is why faith must have content. Truths about Christ must be understood and believed. Christian faith is trust in the eternal God as revealed in Scripture and His promises secured by Jesus Christ. It is called forth by the gospel as the gospel is made understandable through the supernatural and free work of the Holy Spirit. Christian faith is not inherited or passed mechanically on; it is a personal act, involving the mind, the heart and will. It is not faith in an idea or philosophy, but in the Triune God.

Faith involves three steps or aspects: knowledge, agreement and trust. Redemptive facts must be made known so that they may be accepted (Romans 10:14).

Calvin defined faith as “a firm and sure knowledge of the divine favour towards us, founded on the truth of a free promise in Christ, and revealed to our minds and sealed on our hearts by the Holy Spirit” (Institutes, III.2.7).

Through faith we run to Christ and hold fast to Him, who satisfied the law on our behalf (Romans 10:4; Galatians 3:10-13). In this way we are accounted righteous in the sight of God through faith alone, without doing the works of the law. We are simul iustus et peccator.

But since faith unites to Christ it cannot be lifeless. It works through love (Galatians 5:6). It seeks to doo all the “good works, which God prepared beforehand” for us (Ephesians 2:10).

James rightly says, faith without works is dead, being by itself. He is here describing a faith that knows the gospel and even agrees with it, but has fallen short of trust in God. Failure to grow, develop, and bear the fruits of righteousness shows that the free gift of God in Christ has never been received.

James is concerned about those who merely say they believe but do not actually and genuinely believe. If they did, their behaviour would be holy, manifesting their heart-faith. In this sense faith and works are inseparable, but as regards the obtainment of salvation, it is not what is done in us, but what is done for us (on Calvary) that matters. But if we really look upon the crucified and risen Saviour, our lives would necessarily be transformed. It cannot be otherwise.

tecmalta.org/tft219.htm
so faith then is an action?ie response to God.is this not also a decsion to follow Him?faith needs content ie beleif in certain things.so then faith is beleif?ie that Christ’s death and reserection saved us.i’ll get back to this me need some tractor time.
 
Faith-alone eventually leads to Pelegianism–the notion that you can save yourself all by yourself, and don’t need God.

You can simply believe yourself saved, and you are.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top