H
heisenburg
Guest
Kaycee…
Blessing to you in Christ…
As I no longer have the time to invest in here that I once did… I will try and respond appropriately…(understanding that I may not be able to return any response you offer…)
First…
I find it oddly peculiar that you would say that I do not love scripture because i do not agree with your interpretation of this verse. I have heard the argument you put forth many times and quite frankly see it more as a reading into scripture to get what you need than anything else…
A simple question would be Why was Romans Written. The whole book, in context. It was written to describe to the Romans the differences between the old way (Jewish/Abraham) and the new way (Christianity), and the benefits of being a Christian. If you understand that Context, which is the proper context, you can see why saying that Romans 4 is talking about all works makes no sense…
I do not read scripture in single passages, or in a piece of a chapter here or there (not saying you do) but the only way to get the interpretation you mentioned is if you do take just the very start of Romans 4. Everywhere else it is talking about the old, Jewish way…
Romans 4 is just a sum up of those differances…
You can either have faith in Jesus, or you can follow the OLD law.
To be fair, I criticize my Fellow Catholics as well when they try and use Romans 1 to show the error of Protestantism for the same reasons…
However, this particular verse aside… was my statement wrong…
Does God want us to follow the new convent in Christ, or follow the old, Covenant law of Abraham, and Moses.
You are a brother (or sister) in Christ that has much zeal and I respect you for it. I also understand that this argument has raged since Martin Luther first interpreted it this way. I have offered my piece, you have offered yours…
May the peace of Christ be with you always…
Blessing to you in Christ…
As I no longer have the time to invest in here that I once did… I will try and respond appropriately…(understanding that I may not be able to return any response you offer…)
First…
I find it oddly peculiar that you would say that I do not love scripture because i do not agree with your interpretation of this verse. I have heard the argument you put forth many times and quite frankly see it more as a reading into scripture to get what you need than anything else…
A simple question would be Why was Romans Written. The whole book, in context. It was written to describe to the Romans the differences between the old way (Jewish/Abraham) and the new way (Christianity), and the benefits of being a Christian. If you understand that Context, which is the proper context, you can see why saying that Romans 4 is talking about all works makes no sense…
I do not read scripture in single passages, or in a piece of a chapter here or there (not saying you do) but the only way to get the interpretation you mentioned is if you do take just the very start of Romans 4. Everywhere else it is talking about the old, Jewish way…
Romans 4 is just a sum up of those differances…
You can either have faith in Jesus, or you can follow the OLD law.
To be fair, I criticize my Fellow Catholics as well when they try and use Romans 1 to show the error of Protestantism for the same reasons…
However, this particular verse aside… was my statement wrong…
Does God want us to follow the new convent in Christ, or follow the old, Covenant law of Abraham, and Moses.
You are a brother (or sister) in Christ that has much zeal and I respect you for it. I also understand that this argument has raged since Martin Luther first interpreted it this way. I have offered my piece, you have offered yours…
May the peace of Christ be with you always…